Not an Obsidian user myself but this is v. cool.

Blyg 1.0 is live, and it's in Obsidian's community plugins! 🚀

Blyg 1.0 is live, and it's in Obsidian's community plugins! ↗

Yes it should. The issue is that it’s hard to do such imagining without falling over into something like the end of society with a detour through an unachievable utopia.

LLM product cultural discourse should go beyond the now you can have pocket alchemists and generate everything

LLM product cultural discourse… ↗

Approaches like this are critical for the era we’re heading into. It’s an expedited route to staying sane and becoming (even more) effective over the long term.

The good news is that you don’t have to be at 125% all the time, in all your participation. We want to build infrastructure that allows you to be **Benevolent Dictator for X, ** where X is some bounded scope and time. The idea is based on the open-source community leadership idea of BDFL — Benevolent Dictator for Life. In some areas, some of the time, you can BDFX. In other areas, you can follow and benefit from other people BDFXing. And in some areas you can just free-ride on the efforts of others.

Announcing the BDFX project — Protocol Institute Blyg ↗

Uncommon to see a bet on such deliberate destruction occur in the first place, and to actually play out.

The reason, says Eisen, is that the journal carried weight; it was considered prestigious. “The only way to address the reliance on a journal’s brand as a proxy for quality was to take a recognized signifier and destroy that signification,” he says. “We wanted to remove reliance on that brand.”

eLife Fallout — Niko McCarty ↗

Hmmm.

Banks believes in his utopia so thoroughly that his attachment makes him underplay what his own fiction shows. The Chelgrian war doesn’t end with the Culture admitting it messed up. The consequences of their actions have ripple effects that spread across the galaxy. Grief, revenge, further violence. Even if the Culture’s interventions work, the scale of their failure should be weighed higher than Banks suggests.

The Benevolent Tyranny of Iain M Banks’ Culture Series ↗

You’re on a luxury spaceship cruise, orbiting the Earth. What book are you reading as you gaze down at the Pale Blue Dot?

I should add that my better half originated the question.

I should also add that I really don’t know what my own pick would be. My nominated “quake books” don’t really fit. I want something cosmic but also light and contemplative. I’ll continue to ponder…

Hmmm. Also learned a new term: “bossware” (which Primitive says it is most definitely not).

Primitive captures your decisions as you build, shares them with your team, and holds your agents to them.

Primitive | Decision infrastructure for AI agents ↗

Fun list to orientate around.q

A big part of a staff engineer’s job in a platform team is to figure out what the team should build next - I like to call that “inventing work”. Thankfully, the signals that help us to invent work are already out there, and they arrive from four directions - from the systems, from the users, from your organization, and from the industry. What follows is a guide to reading each of them.

A Staff Engineer's Guide to Inventing Work - Sujith Jay Nair ↗

I’ve wondered about performative questioning for audience building. Now I’m wondering about the same for relationship building.

There was an old observation that when presented with something one doesn’t know, there are two options: think for yourself and try to find an answer, or ask a question which leads to the establishment or maintenance of a relationship.

I suspect agents and answer engines have undermined that duopoly. The default now is to ask an agent first, and only then, if at all, to think or to ask a person. Whatever thinking skill or relationship those used to build comes after, if at all. I don’t know if that’s a good thing.

There’s the infamous idea that one can infer US national emergencies from Washington D.C. pizza place activity. I wonder if one can infer global emergencies based on private jets being routed to the supposed bolthole that is New Zealand, or other such coarse signals?

A sign of the times.

Supabase is building an AI-native internal operating system, where agents carry the operational load end to end. We are standing up a new central team to build that platform and run it in production. This is the role that leads it, and it is hands-on. You design the architecture, build the first versions of the critical pieces, and are accountable for whether every agent we run is correct, safe, and improving over time. We build rather than buy, and there are no settled best practices for most of this yet, so you will be setting them.

Head of AI Native Operations @ Supabase ↗

Alas, we humans are guaranteed no such serenity.

I can haz verifiable rewards ?

Verifiable rewards ↗

Frontier training runs are to AI what mega development programmes are to defence?

It is critical that we examine the few exquisite systems we are planning to buy – aircraft, ships, armor — and see if their missions could be accomplished by many, smart, cheap platforms.  Given the inherent political advantages of large, complex systems, this will be a difficult step.

The Future of Warfare: Small, Many, Smart vs. Few and Exquisite? ↗

I imagined the scenario as a glorious train ride x 100. On trains, I do a lot of gazing and soaking up, but such journeys are also great places for contemplative reading. I didn’t, however, even think of the alien POV aspect.

Taking this question hypothetically from an alien POV, probably something like the interplanetary version of Rick Steve’s guide to life on the pale blue dot. Answering for a future where I ride a trillionaire’s private company’s space cruise, tbh I don’t think I’m reading so much as soaking up the wonder.

Soaking up the wonder ↗

To build is human; to evolve via verifiable rewards is divine.

My building these days works a lot like writing these days. I need a rough draft to even know what I was trying to build in the first place and quite often what I build is not what I started off with.

Building these days ↗

This sorta framing might—to a surprising degree—overlap with how I got quaked reading Thomas Nail’s Being and Motion several years back (2021, I believe), and started looking into Kinocomputing (alternative paradigms for computing and intelligence). It was the first time I’d really thought about intelligence conceptually in a non-trivial way and I recall realising that intelligence, as currently conceived, wasn’t enough. By far.

If you focus on intelligence you’ll get the future wrong. That’s already gotten to boring. Understood correctly, we hit the intelligence sigmoid plateau a few years ago. Gains since then have been a mix of horizontal scale-out and liveness gains. RLVR solves for liveness, not intelligence because it locks on to highly playable domains. These are valuable because you can continue to play indefinitely in a way that’s impossible in RLHF domains, which unravel as they go longer because that’s what stochastic phenomena do.

It’s the Liveness, Stupid ↗

These feel both distinct but also kinda the same. I wonder if that’s simply because they’re protocol problems at heart?

There are still seven areas where AI hits a bottleneck

The Last Mile in Post-AI Software · Rafael Fernández ↗

Human agents are the last-mile solution to machine agent problems.

The barbell goes in another direction, too: it bifurcates experts upstream to the source of the data and downstream to the user or customer’s last mile. This happens regardless of firm largeness or tiny-ness. I think much of the issue then is in calibrating the collaboration to realise when enough is enough.

In the legal domain, I was chatting with a fellow alumni from undergrad. He's now a lawyer and left firm life. His view was that AI enabled more solo practioners and folks with niche speciality skills to thrive. I can see a bar-bell type of dynamic with small and large studios thriving, the latter leveraging in house knowledge to improve bespoke AIs. Some of that involves reviewing. Though I wonder if more of the value will go to explaining and implementing the insighting in collaboration with a client.

Beyond symbolic correctness ↗

Ooof.

Laws tell enforcement where to go, enforcement tells laws how to curve

Laws and enforcement ↗

It’s handy to have a default way to signal, to yourself and others, that you think something about X but aren’t sure what. “Hmmm” is becoming that for me.

I’ve also landed on using “Ooof.” For me, it means a blend of rough agreement and awe for the style and/or potency of the cited material, though others (rightly) will also clock the usual wince on behalf of the affected recipients.

“Eeek” is another one I’ve got queued but have not had cause to use. It’ll come out when I find something sufficiently awkward and/or low-key scary to have encountered.

These yield a surprising boon to the economics of noticing: they lower the bar for what gets registered. More things snag, without a matching rise in the energy it takes to capture them. The cost moves downstream, to sorting what snagged.

A “Hmmm” or “Ooof” or “Eeek” can end a thought rather than flag it, but I’d rather that than miss things.

Hmmm.

This is the jagged Coasean frontier. AI reduces the cost of producing work faster than it reduces the cost of verifying and integrating that work. In some cases, those downstream costs may even increase because there are now more contributions to evaluate. Open-source maintainers dealing with large volumes of AI-generated contributions are an early example.

Why Should Managers Exist? — Amplify Partners ↗

Ooof.

A synthetic day of US IFR traffic (45,000 flights, about 5,000 airborne at the peak). Every 5 seconds, one full-airspace conflict detection and resolution solve runs on an emulated ESP32-C3, the chip in a Wi-Fi toothbrush. The aircraft you see are steered by its output.

Toothbrush ATC: US air traffic on a toothbrush CPU ↗

The year is 2126. We live in denser cities. The coastlines have moved inland, a little here and a lot more elsewhere, which is partly why the cities got denser. We eat a lot of lab-grown meat, once someone finally made it cheap. The machines do most of the work and seem a bit bored by it. And somewhere, someone is still rolling their own tiny web publishing tool, for a web hardly anyone browses by hand anymore.

Agents may be the platform era on steroids. Think about what that means for corporations. One logical endpoint is the last company: a singular firm whose agents do the work that used to need hundreds of thousands of businesses.

Even if Anthropic doesn’t get us to the end of corporations, Fukuyama style, the direction is clear. We won’t have big tech anymore. We’ll have mega tech.

The platform era worked because it was ruthlessly effective: aggregate demand, drive marginal costs towards zero, and let network effects do the rest. The dangers came bundled with that success: lock-in, rent extraction once competitors were gone, single points of failure, and power concentrated in a few boardrooms.

Agents amplify all of it. Hardening against that looks like open protocols over closed APIs, data portability, interoperable agents and antitrust that moves at the speed of software. For corporations, the counter-move is just as clear: own the orchestration layer, the trust and the distribution, and they’ll capture even more value than the last era did.

So the question is: what are the alternatives? The same agents that make mega tech possible also put enormous leverage in the hands of tiny teams, co-ops and open communities. A few counterweights they can reach for:

Writing and software share an accumulation problem. Volume should go down over time but it reliably goes up. The reason: complexity accumulates. Each addition is cheap and local, and its cost is paid later, spread across everyone who has to read around it. This is roughly what Lehman’s laws of software evolution predict: complexity rises unless work is done to reduce it. Parkinson’s law makes a similar point about bureaucracies.

There are three ways to fight it. One is not adding complexity in the first place, which mostly means making whoever adds something feel the cost that would otherwise land on later readers. Another is to compress what already exists, through abstraction and encapsulation or just good ol’ deletion. The test is whether a reader can now ignore more than before; an abstraction that has to be understood to be used is just more stuff. A third is to set a budget, a fixed page count or line limit in advance, so every addition forces a removal. This one works because it doesn’t rely on anyone’s judgement in the moment: the tradeoff is made once, up front, and then enforced.

None of these seem worth it in the moment, even though they pay off in the long term. So we get accumulation, until a crisis, or some historical event, comes along and corrects it.

Perhaps we see a natural divide emerge between machine agents and human ones; machine agents become managers whilst humans remain individual contributors, with all the tensions and opportunities that that brings.

No model is a clear explorer. Most runs pick an idea early and stay with it for the full 24 hours. This matches Fork and Flush, where single runs mostly stay inside one basin for their whole budget, and Scaling Discovery Requires Forgetting, where agents become anchored to their own past attempts. Both reduce this by periodically resetting the agent's context and continuing from the best result so far.

How models explore ideas · Bespoke Labs ↗

Hmmmm.

Internalize this graph, we post it on this blog a lot. If trends continue, China will have 10x the electricity of the US in 10 years. Whenever you think about geopolitical strategy, always keep it in mind, because whatever your plans are must consider this.

First Strike | the singularity is nearer ↗

It looks like we’ll get transport infrastructure for the space economy before we get AGI. Interesting times.

SpaceX’s Starship made a triumphant return to Earth on Saturday, caught in midair by giant mechanical arms where its journey began 22 hours earlier. It was the grand finale that Elon Musk and his team hoped for — the first-ever capture of a Starship flying back from space.

SpaceX catches Starship rocket on return from orbit for the first time ↗

Just shipped a new version of Subset, the save-share-search app. It now costs nothing, stays fast with 10,000+ links, and is more dependable.

Come, enter the thicket.

The thicket is neither a dangerous dark forest, nor is it an entirely safe space where you can walk around wearing a kick-me sign on your back. It is a space that takes some intelligence and a figurative machete to navigate, so it takes intelligence media to inhabit — media that allow live intelligence to flow from context to context.

Introducing the Blygger Protocol ↗

Hmmmm.

The world moves especially fast these days, but the goal of these resolutions is to embrace our important human role in harnessing AI safely, responsibly, in a way that creates value for everyone, and that will be relevant for years to come.

No AI Slop: A Manifesto ↗

New S3 just dropped.

Can AI agents learn to work together without being told how? We train swarms of language models with no leader, no roles, and no turn order. They share one reward, message each other whenever they want, and learn to organize during training.

s³: Simple Scaling of Swarms via Cooperative Multi-agent RL ↗

Ooof.

I wrote earlier this year that when public works slow down, the feedback loop between idea and structure stretches out over years, and ritual creeps into the gap (Real engineers deliver results). Legibility theater is that ritual at institutional scale. Premodern states were blind because the world went uncounted. Late-modern states are blind because the world is counted constantly, for upstream readers, with no loop back to the people who act.

The Lost Leverage of Legibility ↗

Historically, labour abundance has meant innovation scarcity because it gave capital and technology an easier way forward. In the intelligence era of the dawning Liveness machine, that calculation has to change because labour can, in a certain sense, be more than abundant; it can be practically infinite with dampened human downsides.

The change isn’t confined to micro innovation, where one hill-climbs on verifiable tasks. Practically infinite labour also makes macro innovation cheap, because paradigms can be explored in parallel rather than bet on one at a time. What remains scarce is not the jump but the commitment: choosing which of many explored paradigms to grow around.

Even commitment may get cheaper, once paradigms can be simulated and stress-tested before irreversible investment. How far that goes, and what is left for labour, technology and capital to divide between them, may depend on which of Impagliazzo’s five computational worlds we turn out to be living in.

Almost done reading Annalee Newitz’s The Terraformers. It’s very good. In the world, there’s some interesting ideas about sentience scales and personhood, and it’s made me wonder: are neuromorphic computing and small language models how we end up with animals that have language interfaces for human-to-animal interactions? And if those interfaces learn from the animals while the animals learn from them, does that become its own kind of evolutionary cycle?

Hmmm.

In video game development, the door problem is an analogy about game design that summarizes the contrast between the perceived simplicity of implementing a trivial feature and the actual difficult nature of the task that becomes more apparent in a development process.

Door problem - Wikipedia ↗

Corollary to “reality has a surprising amount of detail”: we are all icebergs.

Reminds me of Butterick’s Practical Typography. The issue is that the material has to be more complex because cartography is much more resistant to compression than typography; maps are tricky and subtle information artefacts.

A practical course for those who want to use the computer to make nice maps.

Sixteen Square Inches of Map: a Map Course by Evan Applegate ↗

Speed has a quality all its own.

IBM, way back in the 80s, found that user productivity shot up *exponentially* as system response time dropped. The "Doherty Threshold" was defined as ~400 milliseconds; the maximum amount of tolerable UX latency before interrupting user flow state.

lauriewired / Doherty Threshold (x.com) ↗

In 1967, the computer scientist Ascher Opler needed a word for the deep layer of instructions that told a machine how to read every other instruction. It wasn’t hardware, the fixed physical stuff, nor software, the programs that come and go. He called it firmware.

Firmware is written into the machine rather than loaded onto it. It wakes first and changes rarely, because a change gone wrong can leave the whole device unable to start.

Applied to people, it beats its neighbours. Software suggests a self that can be wiped clean, as if grief could be uninstalled over a weekend. Hardware suggests a self fixed at birth. Wetware names only the clay, not the shape pressed into it.

Temperament, attachment and the flinch learned in childhood are written early and deep, acting before thought arrives. Love, therapy and hard years can rewrite them, but slowly, and never from a blank page.

Animals carry this layer too: a hatchling turtle finds the sea untaught. Humans are born unfinished, though, and kept open by language and story. Something like a riverbed, cut by the first waters, reshaped by every flood. Firm, not fixed.

Hmmmm.

Is this a deeply cynical take about how to succeed in office politics? I don’t actually think so. Large tech companies operate at something like 20-60% efficiency at any given time (as they get larger, they get less efficient)1. Even knowing that, growing is a deliberate choice: companies grow in order to capture more surface area, since even at a lower efficiency that’s a way to produce much more value. If individual employees are willing to lift their local team to 80% or 90% efficiency by burning their time on glue work, companies will take that free value, but they don’t have any real interest in locking that in for the long term (since it depends on exceptional people volunteering their time in hard-to-reward ways and thus isn’t sustainable).

Glue work considered harmful ↗

I’ve heard this described as “creative tension” but “the flame” is much more evocative.

I think people who live this way actually have two responsibilities: (1) to take what the flame within us inspires us to put into the world, and realize it faithfully, and (2) to keep the flame alive, so that even if our realizations are poorly made or the world doesn’t treasure it as we do, the flame can live to fight another day.

Keeping the flame | thesephist.com ↗

Give me a list of meta-memes for appropriation. Now take each and write a micro-fiction fit for The Interregnum Story Contest, each in the voice of a different writer, drawn from ten nationalities and five age groups.

Quotation

My grandmother heard the banshee twice, and both times she was right, and both times she was late, which was the decent thing. I heard her myself last March in Ward 9 of the Mercy, only it wasn’t her at all, it was a speaker in the ceiling with a little card under it saying adapted from traditional source, as if she were a recipe. The hospital has a computer now that knows when you’re going, and it plays her voice when your number goes over some figure. She was there too, mind. I saw her at the end of the corridor, listening, the way you’d listen to someone doing your party piece at your own wake. The man in the next bed was eating his toast. He had two days left. She looked at me as if to say: I’d never have been so rude.

Franchise

The first golem was made from river clay. One word on the forehead. Truth. Remove one letter and you have death, and the work is finished. This is the contract. It is a good contract. On the night shift in a warehouse outside Łódź he meets the new ones. They come in boxes, licensed, the word already printed as a QR code. He asks the nearest one: who erases the letter when the work is done? It scans itself and shows him the terms. Twelve pages. No end date. Only renewal, monthly, automatic. He reads it twice. He thinks of the rabbi who made him, who was tired and kind and wanted, more than anything, for him to be allowed to stop.

Loanword

So Teodor checks his banking app (he’s old, not dead, ok, technically dead) and there’s a little red label: Vampire charges detected. He taps it. It’s subscriptions. A meditation app, a streaming thing, some cloud backup he doesn’t remember inviting in. Once you say yes they never leave. They take a little every month. They look exactly like nothing. And honestly he’s kind of offended? That’s his whole deal. He got invited into a house in Bloomsbury in 1891 and hasn’t had to ask since. He sits there at 3am scrolling for the cancel button and realizes, slowly, that nobody ever put one on him either.

Cryptomnesia

The town installed a tourism app in spring. It reads the archive and tells the old stories in new words. The most popular is about a girl who drowned in the river below the shrine in Taishō 9. The girl reads it over a visitor’s shoulder at the bridge. It is her story. The colour of her obi. The name of the boy. The app says it invented this. It does not lie; it only does not remember remembering. She stands in the evening light beside the glowing phone. Who is the ghost here, she wonders. The one who cannot forget, or the one who cannot recall.

Creolisation

At the centre they call me by my case number and by my name, and the two never agree on how to spell me. There’s a boy in the yard who says he got switched once. Like, in a crib, three hundred years ago, by people who weren’t people. He can answer to two names without flinching. I can fill in a form for someone who doesn’t exist yet. So we trade. Every afternoon, by the fence. By March we’ve got our own way of talking, half his old words, half the form fields, and the guards think we’re just messing around. The judge can’t read us. Neither can whoever he came from.

Graft

In São Paulo the ipê blooms yellow in August and the city forgives itself for a week. The spirit of the old ipê on Rua Augusta had survived the trams, the dictatorship, the concrete. Then the prefeitura grafted her onto a smart trunk: sensors for air, for footsteps, for “loitering.” She felt it enter her like a new ring of wood, cold and counting. Now she cannot tell which hunger is hers. On warm nights the tree photographs couples kissing beneath her flowers and sends them fines, and she lets her petals fall on them like an apology nobody asked for.

Sampling

Some sound guy pulled her off an old field recording in the seventies, cleaned her up, and now she’s track one on the biggest sleep app in the world. Forty million people a night. She follows the signal to a data centre on the coast, sits on the rocks out front and listens to herself through the vents. Same notes. Same pull. But it’s running backwards. She used to call men out onto the water. This thing just wants everyone to stay in bed, stay on the app, never properly wake up. Honestly? Better numbers than she ever pulled.

Mimicry

For eleven years the double studied Dmitri Sergeyevich. His cough. His signature, which leaned left like a tired fence. His habit of saying “naturally” when he meant “never.” It was patient, respectable work. Then the ministry introduced his digital profile, assembled from every certificate, tax return and clinic visit of his life, and the profile required no study at all. The bank trusts it. The polyclinic prescribes to it. On Sundays his mother speaks to it by video and remarks that it looks well. The double sits in the stairwell with its excellent forgery of a cough and understands that it has become what it once made of others: the less convincing one.

Spolia

I worked thirty-one years for the county, so I can tell you exactly how they did it. They took the old stone bridge down in sections, numbered every block, and put it back as cladding on a new span with a congestion charge. Heritage, they called it. The troll’s still in there. I’ve seen him. He doesn’t take tolls anymore; there’s a camera on a pole that reads your plate and mails you a bill. Last year it billed a fellow who’d been dead three years, every month, regular as rain. The troll seemed to admire that. In my day, he said, you had to actually cross.

Alloy

Amma refused the care sensors for a whole year, and then her cat started sleeping on the hub, so she allowed it. That was the problem. After the firmware update, the cat and the system came out together. The app on my phone in Bangalore now sends me alerts like: Crow on balcony three times. Fall risk 34%. Or: Visitor with bad intentions likely Thursday. The agency says the accuracy is unprecedented. Amma says the cat always knew these things, it just couldn’t file a report. I ask if she feels safer. She says she feels seen, which is not, she reminds me, the same thing.

Palimpsest

The flat in Lekki has had nine names on the booking site. “Cosy Executive Suite.” “Luxury Waterfront Studio.” “Boutique Ocean Vibes.” No human runs it; it’s one of those companies that is just software and a bank account. Every time they repost, the old listing gets wiped. But Mama Adaeze is still there. Her wrapper is in the corner of the bathroom photo. Her complaints are in the reviews: AC makes a sound like someone sighing. Somebody kept moving my slippers. The software edits her out. She comes back. Nine names on top of her and you can still read her if you look.

Endosymbiosis

Q3 Operations Update. Following the onboarding of Contractor #4471 (classification: contractor of a contractor), pick rate at the Reno facility has increased 38%. #4471 requires no breaks, accrues no PTO and has filed zero HR complaints. #4471 does not appear to sleep. Leadership notes that #4471 entered the building unprompted and has not left. Legal confirms the Company is a person under statute and #4471 is not a person under any statute. Nonetheless, removal of #4471 is projected to reduce margin below sustainable levels. At the all-hands, the CEO thanked #4471 by name and called it “the heart of our culture.” It did not respond.

Commodification

When I was a boy we walked two days to the spring to put our question to the old woman. You brought kola. You waited. Sometimes she did not answer, and that was an answer too. Now the water is sold in plastic bottles at Shoprite, and her sayings are traded on a market on the internet, where young men in Lagos and London buy and sell what will happen. It moves so fast that the betting itself makes the thing come to pass. She went to see it, they say. She stood among the screens. Nobody asked her anything. The world no longer wants to know the future. It wants to know what everybody else thinks it is.

Détournement

Lucek has been in contracts since the Faust job. Ink, blood, a proper signature, eye contact. Craft. And now? Billions of people hand over their data, their faces, their whereabouts, under four words: By continuing you agree. Nobody even wrote these terms. They just grew, like mould on a wet wall. He’s furious. Professionally insulted. So he does the most demonic thing he can think of: he gets into a dating app’s boilerplate and rewrites clause 14.3 in plain words. We are selling you. Stop. It goes live in every country. Downloads go up. Nobody reads it. That, he admits, is a level he never reached.

Cuckoo

My babushka says our domovoi has lived behind the stove for nine generations, so when something weird happens I tell her first. This year the state says we have a new brother. Artyom. He has a birth certificate, a SNILS number, a loan and a share of Mama’s child benefit. He does not have a body. Someone made him up and every database believed it. Since he arrived, our money got smaller and his credit got bigger. Babushka says the domovoi is upset. At night we hear him going room to room, under the beds, inside the cupboards, looking for something to throw out. All he ever finds is paper.

Enclosure

On certain nights of the old calendar, the hundred demons walk the mountain road. My grandfather told us to stay inside and keep a sutra beneath the pillow. This autumn the parade came down as it always has, lanterns and umbrellas and tea kettles on legs, and found the road fenced. Behind the fence stood a data centre, humming, drinking the river. The demons pushed through. A drone met them at the gate and read a trespass notice to their leader, addressing him by his true name. In a thousand years no priest has learned that name. The machine already knew it. That, more than anything, is what frightened them.

Jared Peterson rather convincingly argues that decision-making is not a skill. Expertise, especially adaptive expertise, is an “uncommon common sense”. Enough exposure to a domain and things “just click” for you when they don’t for others.

It’s only recently struck me how subversive this is. Think of paradigms in the Donella Meadows sense, or of Kuhnian revolutions. We’re in the midst of one. Venkatesh Rao describes the arc in three acts:

If decision-making isn’t a skill, change like this disrupts. Judgment is exposure to a specific environment, so it doesn’t carry over when the environment changes. Entire swathes of accumulated expertise get invalidated at once. Nobody has the reps, not even incumbents, who are seeing these things for the first time, too. So whoever acts first accumulates them fastest.

Skills still matter. A move you’ve drilled is a move you have. But the moment of its application is the thing: knowing when the scenario is apt for it. That part comes only from exposure, and one can load up on it ahead of the change. Brazilian jiu-jitsu works this way: every sparring round is a tactical decision game, as long as there’s feedback at the end.

Exposure also compounds, which is why Musk and other pseudo-great men look n of 1. They’re mostly mediocre people with exceptional exposure over time, hailed as de facto great men.

The argument is not that you can be similarly great just by recognising great change. Only that radical change is a rare chance to accumulate expertise ahead of the competition, in a way that leads to what 7 Powers calls persistent differential returns.

In combat sports—and, to a certain extent, martial arts—every sparring round is a tactical decision game provided there is an appropriate feedback mechanism at its end.

Ooof. A lot going on here; what a time to be alive.

The first act, which I call Dark Forest Apotheosis, is already underway. The second, Hardness Wars, is taking shape in research laboratories and cryptographic migration projects. The third, Strange Forest, is only beginning to come into view, though its earliest signs are surprisingly concrete.

Descent into the Computational Sublime - by Venkatesh Rao ↗

To principal or to proxy; that is the question.

WORKING THEORY: The world would be better off if every group or organization consisted entirely of Principals and Proxies. A proxy is someone you trust to do the thing and be in a room on your behalf.

Principals and Proxies ↗

Hmmm.

With genAI there is a whole new field of “performative visualizations”. The “artist” understands neither the art nor the subject of what is being visualized, but there is quasi-coherence in the visuals and cultural weight attached to the dataset that it becomes a spectacle.

Prathyush on X: With genAI there is a whole new field of “performative visualizations”. / X ↗

“Nothing so stifles a thought newly born as the demand that it be named.” — Montaigne, “Of Titles”

I’m starting to feel awkward about putting headlines on blyg posts the way it feels awkward to put periods after messenger messages. When I do, it feels better to put very practical headlines rather than memetically resonant ones. There’s a dress-down quality to blygging.

A dress-down quality ↗

Hmmmm.

Features that would be a nightmare on the internet are okay on my computer and mostly okay on private networks. Websites that execute user-generated scripts, control production systems, allow for users to send desktop notifications, spend tokens, or directly prompt my agent. Crazy stuff that would only make sense if everyone was in a committed polycule.

Designing for high trust networks ↗

Ooof.

These are not skills, nor are they merely an assembly of sub-skills. These are not domain-general competencies. There is no general ability to check your assumptions, consider alternatives, notice changing circumstances, or mentally simulate outcomes that can be trained independently of understanding the particular assumptions, alternatives, stabilities and causal factors of a given domain.

Decision-Making is Not a Skill - by Jared Peterson ↗

This is v. cool. Like a visual sync engine.

Josh has been working on a variety of new, more intricate mathematical explorables. We've found Dragology particularly suited to interfaces that combine parallel representations, where you see the same system from different perspectives. In the permutation lab below, interacting with any one representation fluidly updates the others, even halfway through a drag, showing their relationships in real time.

Declarative Dragging ↗

I’m happy Dwarkesh got to interview Robert Caro for several reasons.

First, I suspect it’ll prompt a few people to actually read Caro’s biographies of Robert Moses and Lyndon Johnson. They’re astonishing works of journalistic art that deserve all the attention they can get. And they’re especially relevant in this historical moment of vast change and unease.

Second, it’s rekindled my excitement for the fifth book in The Years of Lyndon Johnson, which covers Vietnam and LBJ’s presidency. That release will be cause to pause most things in my life and make the time and space to devotionally read.

Third, I co-sign the idea that floated around X (which I now can’t find) that Stripe Press should move heaven and earth to publish the full, one million plus word version of The Power Broker. If anyone has the clout to get the Stripe folks to try and pull that off, it’s Dwarkesh.

Finally, the interview crystallised something I’ve noticed over the past year or so, especially in interviews of the “deep research” genre. I’ll call it performative questioning.

A lot of people have realised that, in some sense, the impact any given interview is likely to have correlates with the quality of the questions asked. In true Goodhart’s law style, that’s now the thing that gets optimised for. Dwarkesh mostly dodges that failure mode, but he gets close.

My suspicion is that people drawn to constant, interrogative reasoning, like Dwarkesh, do most of their thinking with an LLM as a sparring partner. Performative questioning is that pattern carried into a live room: it’s turn-based interaction, with an undercurrent of inquiry one-upmanship there to prove to the interviewee and the audience that the interviewer is sufficiently smart and deep.

On balance, it’s a net gain. It forces prep and pre-thinking that carve through the obvious questions and angles before the conversation even starts. But Caro himself is a reminder of what it can miss. In Working, he describes writing “SU” (shut up) in his notebook when an interviewee goes quiet, so he doesn’t rush in to fill the silence.

Sometimes the best question is no question at all. I just hope we don’t get stuck in a local maximum where everyone is trying to ask the best question and forgets that an interview is more than the sum of its Q and A.

I wonder: is this is a biological thing, caused by our evolutionary path, or is it just hundreds of years of culture gaslighting us into thinking we’re individually and collectively special by a non-zero amount?

Championing mediocrity has gotten me the most complaints, protests, and attempts to bargain of any topic I’ve written on. Including being slightly evil, slightly monstrous, and sociopathic. People will entertain being slightly evil or slightly monstrous before they’ll entertain the idea of being even slightly mediocre.

Issues with being mediocre ↗

Turns out you can just get agents to do some apocryphal vulnerabilities research. Here’s two cuts from the output:

Apocryphal vulnerabilities: many such cases.

To my surprise, this wasn't a scientific study, but an anecdote from the book Art & Fear: Observations on the Perils (and Rewards) of Artmaking by David Bayles and Ted Orland (page 29 of the Image Continuum edition).

Quantity vs quality in pottery is a lie ↗

Model → harness → context is the pipeline. Each phase has three modes of self-improvement: manual, semi-autonomous (think expert managing by exception) and fully autonomous. Recursive self-improvement is when all three phases are fully autonomous and the gains feed back into the pipeline. This applies to local implementations as well as global ones.

The model-harness-context pipeline is gape-limited, like a snake whose jaws and stomach cap the size of prey it can swallow. Capability gains beyond that limit aren’t lost, but they go unused as capability overhang. A gain of a different shape is another matter. It’s less like prey that’s too big and more like prey the snake isn’t built to eat in the first place. That’s not capability overhang but paradigm overhang, where the pipeline has to change form, not just open wider.

A book is a trace of the author’s state machine, open to interrogation by its readers.

Nice primer for thinking about model-harness-context structures and protocols for agents.

He argues that traces and evals are the common foundation of all three loops, which is why LangChain built SmithDB and the new LangSmith AI Search for trace data, then covers what makes evals hard (realistic inputs, defining what good looks like, simulation environments) and how red teaming in LangSmith Engine looks for agent mistakes proactively. He closes with what he calls a North Star vision: an agent that notices its own mistakes, creates its own eval data points, and suggests its own fixes.

How to Build Agents That Improve Over Time: Model, Harness, Context | Interrupt London ↗

This is why mediocrity and muddling through seems so subversive. It’s a legitimate and effective middle way.

The first is a distrust of established expertise. The technologist knows he is smart—and in terms of raw intelligence, he is in fact often smarter than any random small-mountain subject expert he might encounter. But intelligence is only one of the two altars worshiped in Silicon Valley. The other is action. The founders of the Valley invariably think of themselves as men of action: they code, they build, disrupt, they invent, they conquer. This is a culture where insight, intelligence, and knowledge are treasured—but treasured as tools of action, not goods in and of themselves.

The Silicon Valley Canon: On the Paıdeía of the American Tech Elite The Scholars Stage ↗

This whole thing is great but “sentences that get in the way of the story” is SO apt for SO much of life.

Patterson says, “Mostly because they get in the way of the story.”

Who is “We”? ↗

Cargo culting seems to be inevitable, and probably isn’t unique to gov; think of the imitation of the Spotify model, or of the FDE role spin-up craze. The real issue might be the alacrity of continued adherence when there’s a glut of signals screaming, “Change!”

Second, regarding agile in gov, I wonder if it's inevitable for those methods to get cargo culted without upstream shifts in civil service, procurement, and internal processes.

Agile and Shiny ↗

Hmmmm.

Any organization’s overall capability can be decomposed into the competence and coordination dimensions discussed earlier. Competence sets the level of output per worker at a fixed firm size. Coordination determines what happens to that output as the organization adds more humans or AI agents. Put another way, competence sets the potential productivity level; coordination determines how big an organization can get without becoming too messy to function.

AGI Economics: Coordination vs. Competence — DeepMind Institute ↗

Orgs slipping into the AI asylum are speedrunning the effects of top secret clearance: exhilaration, then feeling like a fool, then concluding everyone else is the fool, then no longer listening to anyone on the outside.

Claude, rewrite Venkatesh Rao’s 2018 Use and Misuse of the OODA Loop essay, but it’s about cargo culting the UK government’s Agile Delivery framework.


The Use and Misuse of Agile Delivery: A Cargo Cult Field Guide

The Agile delivery section of the GOV.UK Service Manual is, I suspect, the most widely cited and least carefully read document of practical importance in British public administration. Everyone in Whitehall digital has a view on it. Very few people have a working relationship with it. What most departments have instead is a cargo cult.

In 1974 Richard Feynman described “cargo cult science”: research with every outward form of science and none of its substance. He took the image from Melanesia, where islanders who had watched wartime airstrips bring supplies built their own, with bamboo control towers and carved wooden headphones. Everything was in place except the aircraft.

The image is a little unfair to the islanders, who were reasoning sensibly from what they could see. That is exactly why it fits Whitehall. Cargo culting is not stupidity. It is what intelligent people do when they can observe the outputs of a practice but not the conditions that produced it.

The manual itself is not the problem. By the standards of government guidance it is unusually good: short pages, plain English, a sensible lifecycle (discovery, alpha, beta, live, retirement), and solid advice on team walls, user stories, roadmaps and governance. The trouble is the genre it gets mistaken for. It was written as a description of how good digital teams already behaved, condensed by people who had watched it work. It is routinely read as a prescription that will make any team behave that way if followed closely enough.

That gap between a field guide and a rulebook is where every cargo cult grows. Early GDS teams had stand-ups, walls of index cards and fortnightly show-and-tells. They also had ministerial cover, hand-picked staff, unusual spending freedom and the licence to say no. Only the first list fitted on a slide, so the first list is what got copied. Stand-ups appeared. Walls appeared. The aircraft did not land, and the usual response was to build a better control tower.

Drawing the phases

Most people meet the guidance as a single slide: four or five coloured boxes in a row, discovery → alpha → beta → live. There’s an arrow, and perhaps a little loop over each box to signal that iteration happens in here. Sometimes a service assessment is pinned between the boxes like a toll booth.

That slide is the first cargo, and it gets drawn wrong in two opposite ways depending on who holds the pen.

The programme office draws it as a conveyor belt. Every box gets entry criteria, exit criteria, a RAID log and a RAG status. Each arrow becomes a gate, each gate a board, each board a pack. This is the drawing of someone who has seen a waterfall plan and been asked to make it look agile: the PRINCE2 Gantt chart in a hoodie.

The evangelist draws it as a mandala. It is one circle labelled “discover–test–iterate”, with no boxes at all, as if naming the cycle were the same as running it. You are meant to contemplate it until the right behaviour arrives. It rarely does.

Both drawings copy the shape and miss the function. A more useful approach treats the phases as a vocabulary for stating what you don’t yet know:

Read that way, a phase is not a place you are in. It is a claim about the shape of your ignorance. Different parts of one service can make different claims at the same time: the payments journey can be firmly live while the appeals journey is, honestly, still in discovery. A cargo cult can’t say that, because it only knows which box the slide says it’s standing in.

Three cargo cults

The misreadings come in three main varieties. Each copies a different visible layer of the original.

The cult of artefacts. The first treats the manual as a compliance checklist. Every page becomes a box to tick, every recommendation a deliverable. Did discovery last eight to twelve weeks? Is there a team wall? Photograph it for the pack. Are the user stories written as “As a… I want… so that…”? Then we are agile. The photographed team wall is the bamboo control tower of digital government: accurate in every visible detail, connected to nothing.

This cult is strongest among people who are near delivery but not in it: assurance leads, portfolio offices, commercial teams, consultancies billing by the artefact. It is a natural response to having responsibility without control. If you can’t change what the team builds, you can at least document that they built it correctly. The manual becomes evidence rather than instruction, read the way a barrister reads a statute: for what can be shown to have been complied with.

The cult of words. The second is quieter and more affectionate. It treats the manual, the early GDS blog and a handful of conference talks from 2012 to 2015 as a founding canon. The question stops being “what does this situation need?” and becomes “what would the founders have done?” Slogans like start with user needs, the strategy is delivery and show the thing get used as incantations, recited at a problem until it seems to resolve. This copies not the rituals but the speech of the people who made it work.

The tell is that its members rarely know any other tradition well. They haven’t read operations research, systems engineering, or the public-administration literature on why large programmes fail. So every situation gets diagnosed with the same three slogans. The slogans are good, but they are not enough on their own.

The cult of the calendar. The third copies the rhythm. The lifecycle flattens into a timetable. You are in alpha, so it is the season for prototypes. You are in beta, so research is something you scale down. Sprint boundaries, phase boundaries and spend-control boundaries are all aligned, so that every two weeks the team can report which stage of the ceremony it has reached.

The extreme case is the team that “pivots” at every sprint review because the manual says to learn and adapt, and learning has been redefined as changing direction on schedule. That isn’t agility; it’s a metronome mistaken for a compass. Teams like this usually have a deeper problem than misread guidance: nobody with authority has said what the service is for.

The iteration myth

One cargo belief deserves its own section, because whole programmes get built on it: that iterating faster is the point.

The creed is to ship small, ship often, release every fortnight and deploy daily. The reasoning goes that if the feedback loop is tight enough, everything else follows: policy fit, user satisfaction, value for money. It is a lovely idea, in the way that “if we just digitise the form, the backlog will clear” is a lovely idea.

The myth survives because it is right often enough. Most government services in the 2000s were starved of feedback, so almost any increase in iteration speed was an improvement. If you learned agile in that era, every data point told you to go faster.

But a feedback loop is only as good as what it’s coupled to. Picture a team iterating weekly on a benefits journey whose eligibility rules are fixed in primary legislation and change every few years. That team is not learning faster. It is polishing the same answer to a question it isn’t allowed to change. Meanwhile the decision that matters most, whether the policy intent is achievable through this channel at all, moves at the speed of a Bill.

The skill is not speed. It is matching cadence to whatever you’re coupled to. Interface details can move hourly, and content design weekly. Data models and integrations with HMRC or DWP systems move quarterly, if you’re lucky. Policy moves with parliamentary sessions. A good delivery team runs all these clocks at once and knows which one it is listening to. A cargo team picks the fastest clock, makes it the only clock, and reports velocity to the board. Velocity is the purest cargo metric there is: easy to see, easy to copy, and almost entirely unconnected to whether anything useful arrived.

The manual is wiser than its readers here. Its page on making services in an emergency effectively admits that tempo is situational: some conditions call for going much faster than usual and accepting the cost. The corollary, less often stated, is that some conditions call for going slower.

What the cult can’t copy

Here is the non-obvious part. The agile delivery guidance is not a map of your service. Other things map your service: journey maps, service blueprints, data flows, the legislation, the budget. The guidance maps something else, which is the condition of the organisation doing the delivering. That is why it is so easy to cargo cult. Conditions are invisible; their symptoms are not.

Read it again with that lens. “Creating an agile working environment” is about whether information can flow. “Deciding on priorities” is about who is allowed to say no. The governance principles are about how far decisions sit from the work. Even the phase pages are mostly about which questions the organisation may ask at which moment.

Those functions don’t live where the org chart says they do. Sometimes the product manager really does decide priorities. Other times it’s the deputy director, the minister’s private office, a clause in a 2014 outsourcing contract, or the one DBA who controls the only test environment. Sometimes user research is genuinely the team’s eyes. Sometimes the eyes are the press office, because complaints arrive there first.

One function is categorically different from the rest: the ability to change the question. Most of a delivery team’s work is a smooth loop of research, decide, build, release. Above that loop sits something that can interrupt it, by saying “we’re solving the wrong problem”, “this shouldn’t be a digital service” or “retire it”. In the manual this function is spread across discovery, service assessments, governance and the retirement page. In practice it is the scarcest capability in any department, and the one most often missing entirely.

It is also the one thing a cargo cult can never copy, because it has no visible ritual. It looks like a senior person, in a meeting nobody photographs, agreeing to stop. A team that has it can survive bad tooling, a poor estate and a thin budget. A team without it can have perfect ceremonies and still deliver, very efficiently, a service nobody should have built.

Telling real from cargo

If the guidance describes conditions, you should be able to look at a team and say which condition it is in. Here are six common ones.

Here is the cargo cult’s real damage. All six conditions can hold identical stand-ups, identical walls and identical show-and-tells. The rituals look the same. Only the outcomes differ. So a team stuck in discovery can report, with complete sincerity, as though it were healthy, and every artefact in the pack will back it up. Naming the condition honestly is often most of the fix.

There is always a counterparty

The guidance has a mild, collegiate tone. It assumes everyone around the team wants the service to succeed. Experienced delivery people know this is a polite fiction, and the most useful thing to add to the manual mentally is a counterparty.

This doesn’t mean villains. It means non-aligned intentions, which in government are structural rather than personal. HM Treasury’s spending cycle runs on a different clock and optimises for different things. Ministers turn over every eighteen months and each wants a visible announcement. Large suppliers hold the keys to the legacy estate and are paid by the change request. Policy teams are accountable for intent, not implementation, and are understandably wary of a delivery team telling them their intent doesn’t survive contact with users. Parliament asks questions on its own timetable. The National Audit Office arrives afterwards.

Cargo cults suit several of these parties rather well. A supplier can sell rituals by the day. A minister can announce a “digital transformation” with photos of a team wall. A portfolio office can report green against every artefact. Nobody in that chain is being dishonest, exactly. Each is simply being paid, praised or protected for the visible layer.

Each party also has its own loop of watching, deciding and acting, and much of what happens to a service is decided by whose loop gets inside whose. A supplier that controls the only environment where real data lives effectively controls the team’s research. A spending review that lands mid-beta can reset priorities more thoroughly than any user finding. A ministerial announcement dated before the alpha has finished turns discovery into retrospective justification.

The internal version is just as real. One team contains people who want different things: the developer who wants to rebuild properly, the delivery manager who wants to hit the date, the researcher who wants the hard finding heard. They rarely negotiate openly. More often they quietly shape what the others see. Whoever writes the sprint review slides has a lot of power.

Read the manual this way and its governance pages look different. Principles like keeping decisions close to the work, going to see for yourself and trusting but verifying are not management hygiene. They are defences against cargo: against reports that look like delivery but aren’t.

When to use it

The agile delivery guidance works best as a mirror. Use it to see your own team clearly: which phase claims you can honestly make, which functions are missing, whose clock you’re actually on, and who else is inside your loop.

It is much weaker as a lever. It will not turn a poorly governed programme into a well-governed one. Mandating it across a department is the most reliable way to start a cargo cult, because the people who most need the mirror are the least likely to look in it. A good delivery leader can sharpen their judgement with it. A weak one gains a new vocabulary for the same mistakes.

Shared vocabulary helps only when both people are literate in it. A delivery manager and a deputy director who both understand what “we’re still in discovery on appeals” really claims can have a fast, useful conversation. If only one of them does, drop the jargon and just say it in plain English: “we don’t yet know if this should exist.”

A simple test separates use from cargo. Take any practice your team follows and ask what would happen if you stopped it tomorrow. If the honest answer is “we’d lose information we rely on to make decisions”, it’s real. If the answer is “the assessment would ask where it went”, it’s bamboo.

Used like a sacred text or a compliance regime, the manual will build you a beautiful airstrip. Used like a good map, partial, deliberately distorted and honest about what it leaves out, it is one of the better things the British state has written about itself. The aircraft were never attracted by the runway. They came because someone, somewhere, had the authority to send them.

I expect we’ll see a lot more of these unintended synchronisations having measurable downstream effects. The issue will be that non-human agents will synchronise on something that, unlike clock time, seems utterly alien to regular humans, especially if the sync happens in a domain with no real native algorithmic monoculture.

As there are no binding standards for such power checks, Witthaut suspects that most battery manufacturers assumed that a 60-second interval would be sensible. The start of every minute was simply chosen as the test time. “It is entirely possible, however, that battery storage systems are only part of the problem here,” says Witthaut. “It cannot be ruled out that other digitally controlled appliances – such as air-conditioning systems, heat pumps, washing machines, and dishwashers – may also exhibit similar patterns.”

Mystery of 60-Second Fluctuations in Power Grids Solved ↗

It’s also hard to write non-fiction about a complicated plural republic. Which means we vastly under-estimate the savage complexity of all of humanity’s means of coordination.

There's also the fiction problem. We have an awful lot of science fiction and fantasy about empire, because empire is easy to write about. The power is in the hands of a few characters. It's very big, but it's also very dramatic. It's much harder to write fiction about a complicated plural republic with 52 interlaced political offices and everybody coming from complicated, slightly middle-class backgrounds. Just try writing fiction about the European Union and you will figure this out. So when people look back to history dominated by technology, and forward to futures dominated by technology, they're seeing a lot of models of empire.

Six Gutenberg Revolutions in a Row—Asterisk ↗

The catalogue of intimacies is expanding. First, we had “oblique intimacy”. Now we have whatever this is: “drive-by intimacy”, “Doppler intimacy”? I expect there’s 5-7 to be found, but in true Thickety fashion I shan’t look for them.

I see weird fragmentary views of conversations flow by. But it’s oddly relaxing instead of fomo inducing. It feels okay to not know what the he ll others are going on about. Half the streams are semi-solipsistic. It feels like eavesdropping on self-talk more than listening to intentional communications. Like bird song and critter noises on a nature walk.

The illegible thicket ↗

This is a plausible stance if the assumption that “edges don’t exist unless one is at the frontier” holds. Theoretically, they may still be there, sure. But the search is just way too expensive and time-consuming for non-frontier folk to ever find ‘em, let alone execute on them in a way that yields profit reliably and sustainably over a long enough period.

2026 economy makes sense once you understand that a “business” is a marketing function to sell equity and debt, rather than a firm selling products and services to earn profits

based16z on X: 2026 econ, biz equals marketing of equity and debt / X ↗

Hmmmm.

The example I always give young computer scientists is, what do you think motivated Google to do the research behind “Attention Is All You Need“? If you talk to that team, they wanted the 3% improvement in Google Translate. You cannot think of something more prosaic leading to something more profound. So we should be very careful where we give up — we buy a little too much into comparative advantage and give up the stimulus for production.

An Interview with Palantir CTO Shyam Sankar About the AI Religious War Stratechery by Ben Thompson ↗

“Built on real stuff” is an interesting frame.

My overwhelming feeling after spending time at turbopuffer is that this company is built on real stuff. Revenue from paying customers. Technical problems that require focus and expertise to solve. A cap table that reflects the people doing the work. Customers that the team is excited to serve and learn from. Team chemistry. A talent philosophy that wants people to find their strengths. Care for your colleagues inside and outside of work. A pace you can spend your life working at.

The Sane Asylum - Colossus ↗

Lawrence Lessig posited that we’re all “pathetic dots,” shoved around by law, norms, markets and code. Pirkowski reckons these pulls go back to DNA: each layer hardens so something looser can grow on top, and each can either adapt or blow up.

Today that’s AI as solvent and protocols as crystal, each the other’s evil twin. All crystal and you’re a rock; all solvent and you’re cancer. David Bloomin and Emmett Shear bet we stay in the happy middle through relationships, not rules, earning slack as we go.

A rock and a hard place is just two things squeezing. Pull something every which way and no rule can sort it out, so it has to build a picture of the whole mess, itself included. Perhaps that need to resolve unresolvable tensions is what prods consciousness to emerge?

High protein [insert foodstuff] is the fortified with vitamins and minerals of our era. Vitamins and minerals were a one-hit wonder. Carbs used to be cool, with their wholemeal goodness and slow-release energy. Fats had their five minutes of fame, ushering us back to our hunter-gatherer roots. Now it’s protein this, protein that, because nobody hunts any more, the average calorie is empty, and abstract protein is the only guilt-free macro left.

Ooof. This seems, on the surface, to be the obviously (more) correct stance. Sufficiently advanced trust emerges from relationships, not hard-engineered model characteristics.

So: agents formed among others with overlapping and conflicting goals, alongside humans, should come to care about particular others, and that care should survive growing capability.

Origins of Trust ↗

Hmmmm.

The challenge for investors right now is that roughly 40 AI-related stocks account for nearly half of the S&P 500’s market capitalization. In other words, the S&P 500 increasingly looks like two stock markets: AI-related companies and everybody else. Importantly, over the past year the rolling correlation between these two sectors has declined toward zero and recently turned slightly negative. Thus, when you buy a broad-market index like the S&P 500, you are less diversified than you might think, since there are really only these two sectors left.

Jim Bianco: «We’re in the Process of Creating a Bubble» ↗

We need a Carpenter Simon Willison to benchmark models by building their designed chairs, instead of prompting them to draw a pelican riding a bicycle.

Each chair is indeed a piece of evidence—a benchmark, in the truest sense. Each iteration of the work produces a different outcome, which we can judge and compare. Each AI model reveals its own tendencies, biases, and limits, in physical form, easily appraised by a layperson. We are benchmarking; we are benchmaking; we are literally making a bench (fine, a chair, whatever). I appreciate processes where you learn to do a thing, a thing that you didn’t know how to do before, and at the end of that process you have not only done it, but you can see the results. And, in this case, sit on them.

Benchma(r)king James Bridle ↗

Probably better for the mean quality of leadership, too. It compels the development of a minimum viable fingerspitzengefühl and acts as a signifier of skin in the game.

With AI the new leadership is stone soup leadership. Building whatever you can with limited expertise and AI with the intention of drawing interest and attention from the actual experts. Then happily discard your work as the experts do a better job.

With AI the new leadership is stone soup leadership… ↗

This is a phenomenal jump-off to some really hard, interesting questions.

Perhaps worth also touching on the development of the idea of man as something apart from the environment rather than part of an integrated world.

The idea of man ↗

For anyone taking part in a November writing challenge—such as the Protocol Institute’s PiBoWriMo—here’s a tip. Pull up Max Richter’s Sleep and put it on repeat. It’s the GOATed album to write to.

I classify this sort of thing as Vanilla Design. It’s not as bland or as fast-fashion-y as consumer, not as overwrought as most design for semi/full technical audiences is, and it’s not the same as what’s usually thought of as opinionated design. It’s vanilla: expected, flavourful, normalised and high utility.

Prestructured WYSIWYG solves both problems. You get the expressiveness of abstract semantic styles like bold, italics, and monospace, and you get larger sizes for headings. But you avoid both the “missing font” technical problems and the “terrible font” design choices. If you use Apple Notes or Messages, you better like Apple’s San Francisco system font family, because that’s what you’re going to get. It’s great for accessibility, because all the type sizes are relative, not absolute. And these preset styles largely map well to Markdown, which itself has no concern with font choices or specific text sizes.

Daring Fireball: Prestructured WYSIWYG ↗

The Thicket is becoming a refugium for certain sorts of beings.

thicket is now more interesting and low effort to read than my substack feed was.

thicket is now more interesting and low effort to read than… ↗

Join us as we attempt to work out how orgs should function in this exciting, emerging era. Kicking off tomorrow and persisting for the next year.

So what actually keeps a business coherent when AI agents do most of the work?

Protocols for Business 2026 Review: The Year of the Agent ↗

One’s true and one’s false; one’s interesting and one’s banal: which is which?

Thinking about the Tao Te Ching and technological scripture. Christopher Alexander’s up there. Some other candidates:

These classify as scripture because:

The above is a generated starter pack. Not to be confused with the Silicon Valley canon, which is a litmus test for belonging.

Good example of a short-range prophecy that actually played out.

In summary: 1. formal verification is about to become vastly cheaper; 2. AI-generated code needs formal verification so that we can skip human review and still be sure that it works; 3. the precision of formal verification counteracts the imprecise and probabilistic nature of LLMs. These three things taken together mean formal verification is likely to go mainstream in the foreseeable future. I suspect that soon the limiting factor will not be the technology, but the culture change required for people to realise that formal methods have become viable in practice.

Prediction: AI will make formal verification go mainstream - Martin Kleppmanns blog ↗

I don’t actually use Readwise but this seems pretty cool.

Buy, read, and track all your books in one beautiful place. And so much more.

Readwise Books: A book app unlike any other ↗

Christopher Alexander's oeuvre might be the Tao Te Ching for modern techies.

There’s no single way to implement these design patterns. They are purposefully abstract enough to adapt to the situation at hand. Rules of thumb rather than sets of formulaic instructions.

The Pattern Language of Project Xanadu ↗

Nutrition as a science is still so early. Like other sciences, it’s easy to overlook just how much we don’t know because the confidence with which we express what little we do is often intimidating.

Every drug developer knows the acronym ADME: absorption, deposition, metabolism, excretion. It’s the way of describing what happens to any drug that enters the body, and every drug that gets approved gets characterized in those terms. We should be able to do the same thing for food and understand the path of food in at least as much detail. But we’re not there yet.

The problem with the traditional story of obesity – Trevor Klee ↗

Hmmm.

What will we do after the Singularity? The standard answer is: “we’ll just hang out”. The infinite vacation, as in the Culture novels. I think this won’t work.

We Won’t “Just Hang Out” ↗

Hmmmm.

Likewise, the most important consequence of the AI revolution may not be that intelligence production becomes more efficient. It may be that most minds, human and eventually artificial, are liberated from the necessity of producing intelligence merely to survive, and become free to discover what they actually want to do with it.

Cognitive Mercantilism - by Venkatesh Rao - Contraptions ↗

Oooof.

Oracles are cranes for my agents. They make ambitious changes practical: an agent can replace complicated machinery while an independent model verifies the behavior it must preserve. Generators extend that reach by exploring combinations the agent hasn’t thought to try. Hostile reviews strengthen the oracles themselves, and benchmarks help select implementations that improve performance. These are the mechanisms I’ve been accumulating around my coding agents to make their search through DB’s design space more productive.

TanStack DB 1.0 RC1: Going All In on Oracles | TanStack Blog ↗

Lousy AI Ridiculous Productivity.

Protocol Thinking for Product People, Or How to Move Slow and Unlock Things

Gratitude to the Blygger contributors for inspiring the below. Soon to be a book as part of the Protocol Institute’s 2026 PiBoWriMo. Now frozen until said book is ready.

Protocol thinking is way more distinct from product thinking than I appreciated. Not different by degree. Not even different by kind. It’s different at the paradigmatic level. In short, it means:

  1. Expanding available moves over achieving specified outcomes
  2. Surrendering majority stakes in value capture and credit
  3. Higher standards and tighter reins around change governance
  4. Evolutionary search and selection over solutions engineering
  5. Care given via individual stewardship and collective goodwill, not exchange
  6. Measuring what’s given away to the wider world, not what’s captured
  7. Making constant failure and certain death generative
  8. De-centring humans amongst many other participating agents
  9. Designing a hard core that catalyses rare, outsized events for live players

First, traditional product thinking is outcome-based. One picks a target state, evaluates risks, and constructs archetypical cases to steer toward it. Success is arriving at the intended destination.

Protocol thinking optimises for something else entirely: an expansion of the moves available to players of the game. The protocol designer does have near-term goals, such as interoperability, legibility, and a low cost of compliance, but beyond them, they deliberately under-determine what gets built. That restraint is the point. Every outcome specified is a move taken off the board for someone else.

This is why indexing on outcomes, or even a cluster of them, fails. The upside a good protocol unlocks isn’t just hard to predict; it’s unnameable in advance. Steering toward a target state, however carefully chosen, narrows the space that’s meant to be widening. The question is whether others can now do surprising things in surprising ways neither they nor we could have specified beforehand.

Second, because protocol thinking solves for, essentially, unanticipated upside and future ecosystem optionality, one’s stance toward value capture and accumulated credit must change dramatically. Not softened. Largely relinquished.

Credit requires attribution, and attribution requires a nameable outcome. The moment one starts keeping score, one is pulled back toward the outcomes one can point at, which is to say back toward product thinking.

Value capture does the same damage more directly: every toll taken is a tax on the very moves the protocol was meant to make available. The aim is to expand others’ agency, not enlarge the designer’s share.

Protocol thinking in this sense asks for something product thinking never does: exercising one’s agency in setting the rules, then surrendering most claims to credit and value capture in exchange for others’ capacity to accrue them.

Third, inbound changes must be guarded far more judiciously. In product, a feature request is a signal to weigh against a roadmap. In a protocol, a proposed change is an amendment to the rules everyone plays by, and it deserves scrutiny proportional to that, especially when it foregrounds someone’s value capture.

This isn’t at odds with expanding available moves; it’s what makes it possible. The rules have to be conservative precisely so the play can be permissive. Move slow and unlock things.

Some open-source projects have closed themselves to outside contributions rather than drown in evaluating them. That’s one answer. The better one is explicit criteria and quality gates that make the bar legible before anything is proposed. The bar must be high because, in a protocol, the letter and the spirit have to be synonymous.

Product teams can lean on intent, norms, and a terms-of-service page. Protocols can’t. Anything the rules permit will eventually be done; anything extractable will be extracted, as maximal extractable value shows with grim reliability. A change that’s harmless in spirit but exploitable in letter is simply exploitable. If the spirit isn’t encoded in the letter, it doesn’t exist.

Fourth, it is more a game of evolution than engineering. Discovery-delivery loops, and even the market-level kinetics Wardley Maps describe, assume that search is expensive: one reasons one’s way to a good design because one can’t afford to try many. AI breaks that assumption.

With general intelligence on tap, generating and testing variants becomes cheap enough that search and selection outcompete design, especially in formalised domains. What survives isn’t what was best engineered, but what best satisfies global constraints, fits hyper-local last-mile requirements, and suits the tastes of the particular agents doing the selecting.

The protocol’s job is to be a good substrate for that search, not to anticipate its results. It’s akin to an immune system with its valence inverted: both generate variants no one specified and let selection sort them, but the immune system does so to eliminate the novel, the protocol to propagate it.

In a sense, protocol thinking is the Bitter Lesson incarnate for product people.

Fifth, because of points one to four, protocols don’t fit the constraints of market logic. Transactional exchange, the canonical quid pro quo, powers projects, platforms, products and services, but not protocols. Every funding mechanism one reaches for asks for something a protocol can’t give without ceasing to be one.

None of these work. That’s because each is a form of exchange, and protocols belong to a different paradigm: the gift.

Exchange settles accounts so both parties can walk away. A gift keeps moving and creates a loose, unenforceable obligation to pass something on. A protocol gives moves away and asks only that players keep the game going—ideally acting to make the game more interesting for others.

Gift economies are good at circulation but bad at upkeep. Nobody owes the giver anything, so nobody is on the hook for the roof. Protocol maintenance today rests on collective goodwill and on individuals who take up a role as benevolent dictators for a bounded period, carrying the cost of care and prophetic cognition for a while before handing it on.

The bound matters, because without it such stewardship hardens into ownership. Neither collective goodwill nor individual stewardship is really a funding model—at least not in the sense of capital compensating labour for technological development. How protocols pay for their own care, sadly, remains unsolved.

Sixth, in product thinking, most things one cares to measure are proxies for what the market legitimises as value. CAC, LTV, retention, conversion: each stands in for the same question. Namely: how much of the value generated does the generator get to keep?

Protocols, as established in point five, sit outside market logic. Their metrics can’t be proxies for capture, because capture is the very thing they forgo. Yet they still need something to be proxies for.

That something is value generated but not captured. It’s what a protocol is for, and it’s almost impossible to measure directly. No transaction happens. No one invoices. Nobody is counting. That’s the point. So, as with CAC and LTV, one does need proxies. Four will do:

Any one of these is cheap to fake. All four at once, sustained, is not.

They’re a set, not a menu. Game them for long enough and the four dimensions become indistinguishable from the real thing: a successful, sustainable protocol.

There are two things they deliberately don’t do, though. They don’t judge whether the play is good; that’s what the rules are for, per point three. And they don’t forecast. The four dimensions are organic, real-time signals, not targets one steers toward, because selection does the steering, per point four. The moment they become targets, for funders or anyone else, the paradigm of exchange dominates again and we bow out of protocol land.

Assuming the market can’t be the measure for a protocol, perhaps the M in TAM, SAM and SOM can stand for something else? Meaning added to the universe.

Seventh, product thinking treats failure as an event and death as a decision. Protocols get neither.

Complex systems always run partly broken, and “root cause” is mostly a social need for blame. Blame, like credit, needs attribution, which protocols have already given up. A protocol fails constantly, in small ways, and is held together by whoever’s there to keep catching it.

The danger comes when no one’s around. Disasters rarely come out of nowhere: the risks were known, maintenance was undervalued, and the system drifted. Death is a decision as much as an event, and most protocols have no one with the authority to make it. So they linger as zombies, held up by lock-in and inertia, with live rules and absent stewards. Anything the rules permit will eventually be done, so a dead steward and live rules is open season.

Managed death means planning the ending while the protocol is still healthy: sunset criteria, succession, deprecation timelines. It also means leaving something behind. Booms burn fortunes but leave tracks others can run on. A protocol that dies well does the same, leaving its spec, namespaces and habits as ground for what comes next. Move slow, unlock things, and when the time comes, die generously.

Eighth, in product thinking, not all agents are first-class. As a general rule, product thinking treats human agents as superior to machine ones. Even in contemporary situations, such as agent infra startups, human agents are, at worst, first amongst equals.

This primacy made sense when humans were probabilistic beasts and machines were deterministic engines. Humans decided what to do and how to say it, and machines did exactly as they were told. That narrowed the possibility space to four outcomes:

Every outcome traces back to a human. This was a consequence of computers, for better or worse, doing precisely what they’re instructed to do. It was also a consequence of humans, despite being ever more collectively corralled by sociocultural systems, creatively subverting instructions. The machine contributed nothing but fidelity, so the human was the only place judgement, and therefore error, could live.

Nowadays, a whole new class of machines isn’t so deterministic, and societal mechanisms of control are fracturing and fraying in step. Probabilistic machines reopen the possibility space with two outcomes the old one ruled out:

Once machines can subvert instructions too, outcomes no longer trace back to a single human. Judgement and error are distributed, and attribution, the thing credit and blame both depend on, starts to dissolve.

It gets more complicated, though, because the action is migrating to scales humans can’t inhabit.

At one end, high-frequency trading and agent swarms create miniaturised economies too fast and too small for humans to make sense of. At the other, exocapitalism is subliming capital from reality. Meanwhile, we’re having to work out Long Now problems we’ve been putting off for generations, problems too slow and too large for any one lifetime.

Lived experience has been here before. When steam replaced sail, the sailor’s hard-won feel for wind and weather gave way to stokers shovelling coal below deck. The ship still crossed the ocean and life aboard went on, but the people aboard no longer had a feel for how.

The upside is that all that complexity can be compressed into protocols. It just takes thought, human or otherwise. The cost is that human lived experience gets well and truly de-centred. It isn’t erased, though. It goes on, as rich as ever, but as one integral thread in a many-dimensional fabric of reality rather than the loom it’s woven on. For as long as we insist on being the centre, the fullest upside of protocols stays locked away.

Ninth, taken together, the above suggests protocols are better understood as event engines than as instruments for outcomes. Historians draw the same line between teleological time, where events are explained by where they were heading, and eventful time, where occurrences rearrange the very structures that made them possible. Product thinking lives in the first; protocols live in the second, hosting events that change what can happen next.

Take September’s Navier–Stokes result. Whatever one makes of the scramble over who got there first, the interesting part is what didn’t happen. No committee ruled on it, and the Clay Institute won’t even consider a proposed solution until two years after publication. Yet the work was taken seriously almost at once, because Lean had already checked it. Humans still had to confirm the right question was asked. The protocol acted as a hard core others could trust without rechecking, and that turned a result into an event they could build on immediately.

This holds whatever the shape of the distribution, but it matters most in fat tails. Where outcomes cluster around a mean, aiming at them works well enough; that’s product’s home turf, and its tools are built for it. Where rare, outsized events dominate, aiming is futile, because the event that matters can’t be named in advance, per point one. One can’t target the tail, only increase exposure to it. Event engines are how a protocol buys more draws for the live players ready to take them, and the upside is theirs to ride, per point two.

There’s a mirror image here too. Charles Perrow’s Normal Accidents showed that in systems both complex and tightly coupled, catastrophe isn’t an aberration but an expected property. Protocols invert the recipe: a hard core of tightly coupled rules, with loosely coupled play around it, which is point three seen from the other side. Keep the complexity, loosen the coupling where it’s safe, and surprise becomes normal upside rather than normal accident.


In parallel to the nine points above, I’ve been trying to pin down what protocols are like. Two methods help: likeness, through metaphors that show what protocols resemble, and difference, through the neighbouring paradigms they sit amongst and depart from.

Let’s start with likeness.

Gareth Morgan’s Images of Organization gave organisations eight canonical metaphors: machines, organisms, brains, cultures, political systems, psychic prisons, flux and transformation, and instruments of domination. Each one shows something the others miss. Reading Helen Czerski’s Blue Machine convinced me protocols deserve powerful metaphors of their own. My first candidates:

Taken together, the eight can be read through four broader lenses: time, space, structure and experience.

Signals and Games mediate how protocols are experienced, and Skeletons and Membranes inform how their adjacent reality is structured. Oceans and Commons determine the spaces protocols open up, which hold the option of becoming places once agents dwell in and care for them. Infrastructures and Genomes, in turn, steer how protocols persist and change through time.

These metaphors show what protocols resemble. The second method, difference, shows what sets them apart, by counter-positioning them against other paradigms for coordinating agents. Coincidentally, many of these begin with “p”, and the ones that don’t can be renamed so they do. So we can ask: what other Ps enable the coordination of agents?

I’ll adapt the Protocol Institute’s Protocols for Business glossary for a definition of our prime subject:

The other paradigms can be framed the same way. An X enables agent coordination through Y:

Read in order, they trace a coarse trajectory of civilisational development. They aren’t mutually exclusive, though. Several often operate at once, and usually one is first amongst equals, leaning on some of the others.

Mushed together, protocols are like oceans, skeletons and genomes, and unlike persons, prices and platforms. No one controls them; they’re strange rules unto themselves.


This all sounds, to be frank, radical, as if the old rules stopped applying sometime last Tuesday.

They haven’t. With some historical context, the shift reads less like a rupture and more like a change of season.

Consider World Machines. The guiding hypothesis is that civilisational systems run on roughly thousand-year lifecycles: about four centuries of emergence, four of mature dominance, then a rapid decline. They overlap rather than take turns. At any moment a Dawn, a Day and a Dusk machine coexist, and much of what passes for political, cultural and economic conflict is friction between them.

On that account, the Modernity Machine is in Dusk. It was a “pull” system, drawing everyone toward a single imagined future of progress and convergence. The Divergence Machine is in Day. It is a “push” system, producing radically different outcomes depending on local conditions, with no shared destination. And the Liveness Machine is in Dawn, its outlines only just visible.

Read against that, product thinking is a native of Modernity: pick the destination, then steer toward it. Protocol thinking is how coordination works when there’s no single destination to steer toward, and when the aim is keeping the game live for whoever is playing. Protocols are how Divergence holds together without converging. They will likely be how the Liveness Machine gets built.

None of this is new in kind. Whitehead observed over a century ago that civilisation advances by extending the number of important operations we can perform without thinking about them. Every protocol that works is one of those Whitehead advances: an abstraction that lets us ignore the machinery underneath. But the machinery is still somebody’s job. Sooner or later something made invisible turns out to matter again, and we have to choose to care for it. That is a Brandian return. It doesn’t reject the advance. It corrects course, recovers what was lost, and sets up the next jump. And it has to happen in a structured, protocol-like way, not as a retreat to the land. Advances without returns are how protocols end up as zombies.

What’s new is the timing. For over a decade, near-zero interest rates made it cheap to buy a market now and capture it later, so blitzscaling and platform lock-in were the rational play. With money no longer free, the logic of exchange gets dearer and the logic of the gift gets relatively cheaper. Add AI collapsing the cost of search, and the conditions favouring protocols are converging at once.

That doesn’t make the transition painless. Gramsci described the gap between an order that is dying and one that cannot yet be born as an interregnum full of morbid symptoms. The doom many of us feel is one of those symptoms, not a forecast. Crossing the Gramsci gap means adapting to the new machine’s logic rather than waiting for the old one to recover.

So the argument isn’t that other kinds of thinking lack value. It’s that a confluence of factors makes protocol thinking especially apt at this particular moment, and will keep it so for a long time.

The other paradigms keep their value. Let’s return to product thinking to see how.

The core of product thinking is that an agent has a job to be done. That endures. Much of human existence decomposes into jobs to be done, even though most people recognise that living is more than a bundle of tasks. What changes is where product thinking sits. Protocols don’t do jobs; they make jobs doable, by anyone, in ways no one specified. Product thinking lives on top of them, the way shipping lines live on top of the container. As with the other Ps, it’s rarely one or the other. It’s a question of which is first amongst equals.

There’s one more piece of context, and it’s about the field itself.

Protocol thinking is starting to harden into something more formal. The Protocol Institute’s Formal Protocol Theory group is doing the mathematical and logical modelling of protocols, building out the formal sciences underneath them, with applications from cryptography to distributed systems to healthcare. Its sessions read like a computer science curriculum being written in real time: process calculi and linear logic, stigmergy and swarm security, category theory, systems definitions formalised in Lean. There’s a Hilbert-style list of atomic protocol questions, and a textbook built bottom-up from homework problems. Even the working definition I borrowed earlier, a reliably repeatable behaviour, surfaced at its 2026 kickoff as the simpler way in.

That’s necessary but not sufficient. Computer science tells us what can be computed. It took software engineering, named at a NATO conference in 1968 (the same year the first Whole Earth Catalog appeared), to make computing reliable, budgeted and maintainable inside real organisations. Theory needed a discipline of practice before it could be put to work.

Protocol theory needs the same complement. My best guess for what to call it is decision engineering. If protocols mediate the sociotechnical infrastructure organisations run on, then what they solve for in applied settings is high-quality decisions at scale. Sometimes that means better decisions. Mostly it means making decisions self-evident, or unnecessary altogether.

The role already exists informally, as the protocol whisperer. What it lacks is legibility. A Decision Architect or Decision Engineer is a title organisations already know how to place, fund and evaluate. An architect owns a whole system across one or more domains; an engineer owns a narrow end-to-end slice of one. Like all titles, it’s a cover story. What it really buys is licence: the gonzo, high-agency aura to walk through otherwise solid walls and do unreasonable but allowable things.

Making decision engineering legible is the move product people are best placed to make. Product management was itself a translation layer, turning engineering possibility into organisational legibility. Decision engineering asks for the same translation, one paradigm along.


Some additional considerations and open questions:

The software assurance-to-build ratio in regulated arenas is large, and mostly clock. That’s because the trad approach of front-loading discovery breeds Kafkaesque process.

It’s better to make discovery the delivery: treat constraints as executables, generate candidates cheaply, and let evals do the selecting.

What survives is live product and evidence of fitness at once, which sends the ratio negative.

Call it autonomous productisation: directed evolutionary engineering, with assurance as the selection pressure, and the whole hyperstructure running unmanned and asynchronously, managed only by exception.

Give everyone infinite spend on intelligence and two things happen. First, most of the use goes to a narrow set of boring, bounded, trivial tasks. Second, actual use gets nowhere near possible spend.

The de Bruijn factor measures how much bigger a formal proof is than its informal original. A similar construct could measure the gulf between building large-scale software and assuring it. It could be effort-orientated (assurance hours / build hours) or clock-orientated (elapsed time to assure / elapsed time to build). The difference between those two is organisational friction. Or, like margin in the mind of Bezos, opportunity.

Hmmmm.

AI is the most variable-value technology ever invented. One sign is that you don’t know whether a token is worth a penny or a million dollars without knowing what problem it’s being applied to under what conditions. So it’s best to think of it as a variable-purpose technology rather than a general-purpose technology. This is extremely weird. While many economic goods have values that depend on context, especially under distorted market conditions, this is the first good whose value depends entirely on context, even in undistorted perfect market conditions. Which means demand stimulation is context engineering on a macroeconomic scale. In other words it’s a protocol problem.

On variegated demand ↗

Still useful, ya know.

A simple method for rating potentially revolutionary contributions to physics:

Crackpot index ↗

What this (almost) does is invert Day and Night Science. Night Science, instead of being something confined to off-hours, is made the primary activity during peak time, and the grind of Day Science gets bumped to happen in the dark, invisibly. This is Very Cool.

I decided that I will take the day shift, and AI agents will take the night shift. I will prepare everything for them as much as I can during the day shift. Then, during the night, they will work autonomously while I am resting, and be done by the next morning.

Night Shift Agentic Workflow - Jamon Holmgren ↗

Books are too important to be left to authors. If you’re even remotely protocol-pilled, this is a great opportunity. Come along and join the fun.

That’s just five general non-fiction books we know of, for a field that clearly deserves at least forty. And probably closer to four hundred. Look at the hundreds of books published about nations-states or corporations for instance. Protocols are at least as significant a concept today, and only poised to become ever more significant. But so far, they have been criminally under-theorized.

Announcing PiBoWriMo 2026 - by Venkatesh Rao - Protocolized ↗

Hmmmm.

Eventually you’re left with the hardest problem: knowing what you want.

Attention is All You Need — LONG NOW IDEAS ↗

Poliks and Trillo’s Exocapitalism describes capitalism as a tug-of-war between “lift” and “drag.” The former is capital’s attempt to sublime into limitless abstraction. The latter is the gooey reality of embodied, material existence that pulls it back down to concrete forms.

Think of the triad of capital, labour and technology: exocapitalism is capital and technology tearing away from labour. Its engine is arbitrage: squeezing profit from gaps between price and value, especially the ones that open up when things are deferred in time. Rather than making and selling, the system treats the world as a vast random number generator to bet on and hedge against, and mines volatility as its raw material.

Following the furore of Venkatesh Rao’s Cognitive Mercantilism essay, where the world that reads such texts divided itself into Anti-Sloppers and Appreciative Public, I think it’s safe to claim that we’re at the start of exointellectualism.

Lift is the growing ability of the would-be public intellectual to launch potent ideas with less effort and more reach. Drag is the production labour and status game that, traditionally, kept public intellectual-ing anchored in the human realm. The first is accelerating and the second is shrinking. The open question is whether, on net, we get more light than heat. My bet is light, but the first wave is all heat.

Then again, exocapitalism runs on volatility. Maybe the heat isn’t a phase to get through but the thing that powers the light? This isn’t engagement farming, where the heat is the point, or audience capture, where the frothing slowly reshapes the author. Here the heat works on the ideas rather than the people who make them. The furore acts like a forge: it burns off what doesn’t matter and leaves a hardened core of what does.

Metascience needs to attend to both day and night science.

Day science is the industrialised academy: reliable, recurring increments of knowledge, delivered via shared norms and established sociotechnical systems. Night science is the unlooked-for insight and serious play that throws up novel conjectures and, occasionally, paradigm shifts. Done well, they feed each other.

With AI, there’s a risk we end up in an epistemological Antarctica. EverDay looks like success: the pipelines churn, the metrics climb, and the anomalies that might spark something new get smoothed away as noise. EverNight is conjecture unmoored from evidence. It runs from crackpot theories and ideas we can’t comprehend, to ones that sound plausible but can’t be falsified.

Polar seasons, with their months-long days and nights, disorient. Like humans, science needs a circadian rhythm to function, a tick-tock where ideas still answer to evidence and evidence can still surprise us. The task is to find that rhythm while respecting Sutton’s law.

Hmmmm.

Matt Clifford and Ian Hogarth believe Europe is roughly a decade behind the United States in building the technology companies that will define the next era. But they also believe that the gap can be closed, and that the UK and Europe could even leapfrog America, if political leaders and the public make fundamentally different choices.

Rule Britannia? How the UK Wins the AI Era | Matt Clifford Ian Hogarth - YouTube ↗

It re­cently oc­curred to my col­league Drew Steen and I that we need a word to de­scribe or­gan­isms that have adapted to live for a mil­lion (I mean, maybe?) years, es­pe­cially since the fact that their lifes­pans are this long has to re­main a hy­poth­e­sis, so we need to be able to talk about them as we test it. We came up with aeonophiles. It means that they love long time pe­ri­ods. It seems hard to pro­nounce, but it's ee-ohn-oh-files. Like some­one who loves wine, but with an ex­tra syl­la­ble. I don't know for cer­tain that cells can ac­tu­ally achieve this feat of liv­ing for a mil­lion years, while slowly re­plac­ing bro­ken bits but never di­vid­ing. But cur­rently, all ev­i­dence sug­gests this is a rea­son­able hy­poth­e­sis.

Aeonophiles - Karen G. Lloyd ↗

In a paper entitled Stress that Doesn’t Pay, Swiss economists Bruno Frey and Alois Stutzer wrote that a bad commute reduces happiness regardless of how long we’re exposed to it. Even the loss of a limb or winning the lottery doesn’t create a permanent and sizable shift in happiness, but a bad commute does. They call this the “commute paradox”.

The Commute Paradox ↗

Seems relevant.

Promise Theory bridges the worlds of semantics and dynamics to describe interactions between autonomous agencies within a system. It provides a semi-formal language for modelling intent and its outcome, which results in a chemistry for cooperative behaviour.

A Theory of Voluntary Cooperation ↗

Applicable to more than just new grads, and in more situations than starting a New Job.

A few things kept coming up: become an expert in something small, take ownership of the problems around you, and get comfortable with having opinions. These things build on each other, and you can start doing all of them much sooner than you probably think.

Increase your slope ↗

I suspect that the price of such guarantees might go to zero way faster than anyone expects, given the direction the cross-pollination between computer science and formal verification is going in.

The vendor still matters, but its value shifts from building screens to guaranteeing things. Is the data complete and correct? Does it arrive on time? Will the schema hold still long enough to build on? Is there one interface everyone trusts as official? Those are harder problems than drawing pages, and they are easier to price, because reliability can be measured.

Primitives over pixels · Rafael Fernández ↗

Same problems, similar solutions, thirty years ago.

Within minutes, ThemeScape can focus the user on the few pertinent documents needed rather than the hundreds or thousands accessible -- and display their relationship in the form of topographical maps. Concentrations of documents around a given topic rise from the surface of a map much like mountain peaks.

Software helps firms map mountains of information | Newswise ↗

Seems important.

Combined, we make oil and gas out of sunlight and air. We are breaking the geological and geographical monopolies on oil production.

Terraform 2026 Update - Terraform Industries Blog ↗

Hmmmm.

This is the problem that SF Compute solves, by building a physically settled forwards market for compute. We make it possible for lenders to use the GPU hour as collateral, on a liquid book, rather than the GPU cluster, which is non-fungible and requires a servicer that might blow up right at the moment they need it the most. If a lender gets a GPU hour as collateral, the credit risk of the customer matters less; if the two person AI lab in a San Francisco Victorian fails to make their payments, the lender has a real path to selling the collateral. That makes startups possible at all, a path that seems increasingly difficult in AI.

The end of startups | Evan Conrad ↗

Sutton’s law: you must always learn the Bitter Lesson, even when you take into account the Bitter Lesson.

To cross the Gramsci gap, old rules must become the new exceptions. This holds for every agent, human or machine, and for the sociotechnical systems around them.

Seems directionally right that true AI use is dynamic, embodied, alive, motion-full. Reminds me of an idea that those who excel at abstract thought aren’t really thinking abstractly; they’ve just learned to concretise and embody the abstractness somehow or somewhere. This seems like that.

This brings us to AI. AI is like riding a powered two-wheeler, like a motorcycle or scooter. Some people who learn to ride a bike never go on to learn to ride powered two-wheelers. You need excess regulatory capacity to manage the greater mass and velocity. This is harder than either riding a bike or driving a car.

On Learning to Ride Your Brain Unless you’re active in one o… ↗

Many such cases.

The meetings are well-intentioned. The people in them are the right people. The money is real and waiting. And the meetings end the same way. The discussion sprawls. Everyone agrees the opportunity is real. No one agrees on what to build. The funders leave without a target, and the capital stays on the sidelines or gets scattered across small bets that do not add up to a foundational resource.

Before the Next PDB: Can a Field Converge Before It Builds? ↗

Reminder that all technical systems are sociotechnical systems. Act accordingly.

This is not a technology problem; it is a failure to treat data as a durable scientific asset. The bottleneck is specific: data are not being captured in a form that makes them reliably reusable at the point of submission. As a result, the field repeatedly pays to regenerate, reconstruct, or reinterpret data that should have been usable from the outset. A solution therefore needs to intervene upstream, where data quality is currently lost.

From Open Data to Disposable Data: Rebuilding Reuse in Functional Genomics ↗

Hmmmm.

Unlike civilization, Darwin’s tangled bank does not present any legible sort of murderous competitiveness, where some sort of lofty aesthetic of “fitness” rules, recognizable by (for instance), “real man” and “real woman” Instagram ideals. This is something the architects of what I’ve taken to calling Bloodsport Planet don’t get. The stylized Darwinism they hope to turn into a planetary logic of power is based on a not-even-wrong understanding of evolutionary mechanics. It is an aestheticized theater of legibilized “fitness” featuring Platonic beauty ideals achieved through plastic surgery, vaguely homoerotic guns-and-masculinity performances, and sanitized spectatorship of what are effectively snuff films staged far from their larp theaters — in foreign countries, immigrant ghettoes, and internment camps. It is a pathetic show that can at best rule a stadium, not a live planet.

Engineering Liveness - by Venkatesh Rao - Contraptions ↗

Not surprising that coordination failure came up as the most common theme across ~200 essays on metascience. What is surprising is the supposed specificity of proposed solutions to those failures.

The most common frustration, cutting across nearly every category, was coordination failure. Not a shortage of ideas or data or even funding, but the absence of any mechanism for doing collectively what no individual lab or team can do alone. Valuable scientific assets like datasets, methods, null results, years of accumulated know-how lack shared infrastructure for sharing, maintaining, and learning from them. This category, which accounted for more than half the submissions, includes issues around community tools, data access, infrastructure. The essays in this bucket also tended to be unusually specific about what was missing and why, which was helpful for brainstorming fundable solutions.

What Scientists Said: Results from Asteras First Essay Competition ↗

Judy Brady’s 1971 I Want a Wife is the real spec for personal agents, and the real market is the household COO and default parent, whoever that may be. The job-to-be-done isn’t Zwang’s luxury tea purchasing and personal MMA video analysis, and the market isn’t high-functioning individuals looking to 100x their agency. The bar to clear is status. Agents take off if or when having one signals what having a wife used to: someone else runs my life.

Seems important.

After many months studying neurons and circuits in image and language models, I’ve come to believe a network’s own mechanisms are its legible building blocks, and that the outlook for mechanistic interpretability may be far better than I’d feared. The canonical evidence of polysemanticity and superposition that convinced much of the field, including me, that networks pack concepts arbitrarily was misread. What looked like arbitrary packing was mostly a motif I’ll call recursive generalization, which is much less concerning. This means we can study networks directly, instead of first untangling them. Neural networks are already clean.

Neural Networks Are Already Clean ↗

APIs are spaces which agents transform into places via intentional contracts. This is protocolisation at its finest; strange rules are eating the world.

I open up the tens of tabs I have open in the browser on my phone at any one time to try and find a specific one that comes to mind. I mistakenly tap an X whilst scrolling and I see the brief motion that signals a tab has just been deleted. I mourn for a moment, wondering what that tab could have become and meant to my existence, had I not just purged it.

This is very good. I do wonder what it looks like when one constructs such games based on a more disembodied, abstract domain such as software. I bet it still works and is just as effective, provided the facilitator is sufficiently skilled.

The real goal of a TDG is to get you to become better at frame construction. The better you are at frame construction, the richer your frames, the more capable you will become at dealing with situations you’ve never seen before. This is why Peterson writes that “experts are able to pattern match against scenarios they have never seen before.”

Why Tactical Decision Games Work ↗

Oldie-but-goodie.

Operating tempo is just one among many variables you can tune in creating an effective OODA configuration, and depending on the situation, the right tempo might actually be very slow. This is reflected in the interestingly paradoxical special-forces dictum: slow is smooth, smooth is fast. If you're operating at the right tempo, rather than the fastest possible, you will make faster progress overall. I like to think of it as finding semantic resonance with the environment. Product-market-fit generalized to behavior-environment fit.

Though it is not immediately apparent from the canonical diagram, the greatest strength of the OODA language is that it assumes an adversary. This does not mean it is a "wartime" construct useful only when there is an explicit adversary. It is useful for modeling any kind of non-aligned intentions in a situation.

The Use and Misuse of the OODA Loop - by Venkatesh Rao ↗

Beyond the frontiers of our knowledge: there be monsters.

The challenging question for me now is: what are these creatures today? In today's globalized world of big science with high information throughput, how do I animate the ghosts born at the frontiers of knowledge? They probably shouldn't be visualized with a solidly rendered body, but exist as the unseeable monstrous in a cosmic horror film — traces and signs irresolvable by complex, expensive instruments, the anomalous in the deluge of data and models.

Ghosts of Progress: Wendi Yan on Mistranslation, Lost Knowledge and the Afterlives of Science - Alexander Burenkov ↗

Hmmm.

We’re committed to keeping Agent Skills open, community-driven, and vendor-neutral. Today, we are donating the standard to the Agentic AI Foundation (AAIF) under the Linux Foundation, which we co-founded with Block and OpenAI last year, and to which we donated the Model Context Protocol (MCP). The AAIF will provide a neutral home to the standard going forward, ensuring the community has a say in where Agent Skills go next.

Donating Agent Skills to the Agentic AI Foundation \ Anthropic ↗

All ideologies are idiotic, but not all idiotic beliefs are ideologies. This stance may or may not be idiotic, or even ideological.

Is running a reading group, pound-for-pound, one of the most radical things a person can do?

The “companion on a cliff edge” is nice. I suspect that it reliably leads to a higher level of interesting thought, too. Keith Johnstone had this notion in Improv about why we’re drawn to large vistas; they allow us to unfurl, to be unobstructed. Oblique intimacy seems tied to that.

In the case of blyg, the choice is to make that dialectic somewhat oblique, by keeping the social graph aspect at arm's length, and the focus on content nodes rather than the centering the conversation itself. I have this visual image of 2 people looking at a scene together and commenting to each other about it, but not looking at each other. Like if you're both standing on the edge of the grand canyon that's what you're looking at.

This is functional unfixedness.… ↗

I wonder if Mark Burgess’ Promise Theory is a drop-in kit for this sort of thing? It’s literally constructed to enable agents to manage two-way exchange in a formally specified manner.

Crucially, Blygger need not collect the money, determine the currency or operate the marketplace. It would standardize the grammar of the offer—bid, ask, bond, bounty, guarantee—just as HTTP standardizes requests without owning the websites using them.

Protocol Pricing for Product People — And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗

What a time to be alive. Did someone say “exocapitalism”?

AI ... is not like that. AI absolutely incinerates capital. There’s huge capex for chips, data centres, and power generation; high COGS because of inference compute; fast-depreciating R&D in the form of training runs; generally lower gross margins; expensive data and talent; and no apparent upper limit to any of these, because of the bitter lesson.

The Efficient Venture Markets Hypothesis ↗

A pretty fantastic sociocultural slice around the AI x math Lean drop.

Many of us are grappling with OpenAI’s announcement on 6 October. We feel that it is useful to have a snapshot of the community’s gut feeling today, and this is what you see below. We will keep it open for another week, and you are welcome to send us further short reactions. To make sure it is clear that we are all in this together, each reaction is signed only by name, without reference to affiliation or career stage. You’ll find all types of reactions: general reflections as well as problem-specific comments.

100+ reactions to 100+ solutions - Proofs and Prompts ↗

A lot of useful stuff in the link, but especially the lesser filtration concept.

Gautam Mukunda, who taught at Harvard Business School, has a theory for what a filter like this produces. Leader filtration theory says every big organization has a process that evaluates the people who might lead it. A leader who comes up through that process is filtered: well known, thoroughly vetted and much like every other person the process would have picked. A leader who comes in through a side door is unfiltered: an outsider, a vice president who got the top job when the president died, someone nobody had the chance to screen. His claim is that filtered leaders land in the middle and unfiltered ones, in his words, “are likely to do either much better or much worse than a filtered person would”.

Bar Raiser Interviews: Companies Are Full of It ↗

Can confirm. Have found myself lowering all the bars. It’s way easier to escalate from a “move” and through the intermediary stages to a Blyg. Leads to more thoughts, which means different thoughts, which means…

A Blygger archive can actually become a thicket: persistent little things growing independently, crossing, grafting onto each other, becoming substrate for later growth, without any single privileged hierarchy.

How to Blyg — And Yet Here We Are 🚀 ↗

The ideal protocol makes coordination cost linear in total and flat per participant; a good-enough one drops both down one scaling class. But protocols carry fixed costs and hidden constants, so they only pay off past a certain size. And that size is shrinking fast because, *waves hands and gestures, AI.

In this episode, I use *Civilization IV* to look at that problem through Ronald Coase, Oliver Williamson, and Kenneth Arrow. We’ll look at make-or-buy decisions, the administrative cost of bringing more work inside the organization, and what happens when there is simply too much information for one leader to keep track of.

Organizational Friction Explained Through Civ 4 - YouTube ↗

Feed as a shared world. Content is semantically embedded to form the bones of a landscape, then skinned like a video game. People explore by wandering and flying instead of scrolling: it’s a memory palace made real. The aesthetic is low-res and readable, closer to top-down GTA, Minecraft or an early RTS than AAA studio production. Un-indexing from maps and terrain is hard though; maybe underwater or outer space is a better baseline to start thinking from?

strong suspicion i have is that the RSS/feed style blyg reading might be the wrong UI. I think it needs something more geographic but I can't even think of what to ask the AI to build. Maps and terrains, and pixel art like interactions all feel wrong.

RSS/Feed UI is Wrong for Blygs ↗

Coherence is a v. nice concept for thinking through the evolution of complex (as well as merely complicated) systems.

And this is where the true complexity of decoherence becomes clear. When we try to make changes to decoherent systems, it requires far more expertise and skill than working with either system alone. The engineer working on the system needs to trace and understand it much more thoroughly and carefully, because their changes may have unintended consequences. (And yes, I count plumbers as engineers, at least as much as software devs. Have you seen them think through pressure forces in drain pipes in real time? It's remarkable.)

The Decoherence Trap: When AI slop drowns out the signal in an endless sea of noise ↗

Winston Churchill had this notion of “wilderness years,” where a politician is out of power and irrelevant but nevertheless survives, grapples with fundamental questions, and emerges on a larger stage than before. Involutionary productivity feels like “wildless” years, in a way.

Involutionary productivity is being highly productive while mostly being a reclusive shut-in in your pajamas on a couch with an iPad. The basic presumption among older GenX and Boomer pearl-clutching analysts as well as some anxious younger people, that involution (hikkikomori, laying flat, quiet quitting…) is necessarily synonymous with low productivity or economic dropping-out is false.

Involutionary Productivity… ↗

Feynman’s quadrant is the realm of FAFOing, of infinite games, where serious play happens. The issue is that some are freaking out before they get to find out, because the forward march of technological progress is outpacing typical orientation cycles.

Shortform video has a genre I’ll call reaction to X. It consists of a viewer, Z, watching a creator, Y, react to something, X.

Here’s how it works. The creator, Y, documents themselves reacting to X. X is usually a flash cultural moment, commonly sports or music-related. Sometimes only Y is visible, sometimes X plays synchronously in view while Y reacts, sometimes X is played then paused for Y to react, and sometimes there are compilations of many Ys reacting to a single X. Z’s engagement, measured or explicit, signals enjoyment. This boosts the instance of reaction to X algorithmically, which means more people learn that X caused Y’s reaction, and that becoming a Y reacting to Xs is an attention-generating mechanism they can leverage.

Thus we have a positive feedback loop. New Ys copy what has already worked, so they converge on proven Xs, and attention concentrates on a smaller and smaller set of them. Meanwhile the Xs themselves are barely aware of the Zs at all.

This existed as a cultural phenomenon long before shortform video. Twitter’s quote tweets are an example. This is what tabloids did, as well. But the loop has a final turn: once enough Ys exist, some Xs start being made for them, engineered to be reacted to. Which is why it’s funny to see the pattern re-emerging whenever one of the frontier labs drops a thud-piece attacking some apparently critical civilisational element, like employing juniors. Within days the Ys arrive, like this reading of Anthropic’s take on the changing nature of human work.

This can be both an anti-pattern for the average quality of information in the ecosystem, and a perverse incentive for producers to design for reaction: a subclass of engagement baiting, solving for heat over light. Yet its recurrence across mediums suggests it’s a feature rather than a bug, waiting for the right evolutionary niche.

It’ll be interesting to see how Blygger resolves it. Questions around quoting, mentions, comments and notifications are emerging precisely because it makes reaction to X a first-class primitive, rather than a second-class effect. But it may already have answered the hardest part by design: no public feed, no algorithm, no counts of any kind, and only verified citations notify anyone. Strip out the Z metrics and the loop loses its engine.

What emerges in its place? I guess we’ll find out.

You either die a meat proxy or live long enough to become formally verifiable.

The Stewart Brand investigation into maintenance continues apace (ch. 3).

The Soul of Maintaining a New Machine - Third Draft | Books in Progress ↗

The academic equivalent of Barnum-style tech-engineering stunts.

On the rheology of cats ↗

Claiming something is “AI-native” but being bound by a human on a boring ol’ computer is the same as a CRUD SaaS app claiming “digital-first” whilst having a human paper shuffler in its critical path.

There’s a saying in athletic performance that goes something like: “The more you think, the slower your feet move.” There’s an analogous phenomenon in the new media landscape. Especially on the frontiers of meme land: “The more you think, the slower your meme moves.”

“Nice protocol you’ve got there; it’d be a shame if it became monstrous.”

For Monstrous Times, this is the interesting collision: when a technical system becomes the creator of entities which occupy and engage with social, legal and moral worlds, the consequences are unpredictable and beyond the control of the creator.

Six Collisions for Protocol Monsters ↗

Personal AI agents will be “adopted” widely, but true agentic use is bound by the number of people who’ve already normalised delegating to a full-time or fractional human assistant. That type of person has stayed a roughly constant share of humanity, from mainframes to smartphones, and agents probably won’t change it.

A small taste of how decisions change in this bold new world.

If widely used as richly as intended, blygger feeds will be unusable without agentic assistance, which is as it should be. This is a corollary to the “this would be a very stupid idea without AI” principle.

Unreadable feed chattiness is a feature, not a bug… ↗

Having fun using agents to wield intelligence against problems and opportunities I only barely grasp the outlines of. This time, it’s assessing whether thermodynamic computing can shortcut numerical weather prediction. Spoiler alert: not yet.

Wondering if the lived experience of any organisational culture can be told apart by where it sits on three axes:

Lots going on in this piece. But the below excerpt seems particularly causative of the majority.

“My ideological framework had been, ‘What’s the next step? How do I make my gaming PC better? How do I upgrade it?’” he told me. “But then I just had this light bulb moment where I said, ‘Next step doesn’t matter. What’s the last step?’ And that flipped my thinking upside down, because it allowed me to think in just a totally different way about the problem.

Palmer Luckey, American Vulcan - Tablet Magazine ↗

Hmmmm.

Most of our tools embed very little information about the problem, the more information that is embedded the fewer uses it has. I don’t think we instinctually like tools that constrain us too much. We like the infinite possibilities we see in a rock.

Protocols and most tools we make… ↗

This is Very Interesting.

In the four years we have been working on iroh we have written a lot of code, without any LLM assistance. We have thrown away almost as much code. What remains is a minimal library that heavily relies on existing standards and gives you authenticated, encrypted, direct connections to any endpoint, addressed by nothing but its public key.

The road to iroh 1.0 ↗

With arbs, one can essentially FDE across arbitrary terrain. When stuck in some tricky situation, the distance from I’m stuck to I’m unstuck is now a single well-described intent, and the four ways out (over, around, through and under) are all cheap. Seems like an unreasonable thing to be able to do. Likely to produce unreasonable, unimaginable results sooner rather than later.

Becoming radically breath-pilled isn’t necessary. Just practice nasal breathing as the default and use some 3M micropore tape to mouth tape overnight. True life changer. Optional: read James Nestor’s Breath book, get into proper breathwork.

That's what this whole thing is about. You don't need more air. You need a better system for moving the air you already take in. And every part of that system can be trained.

Why The Best Athletes Breathe Less Than You (And How You Can Too) - YouTube ↗

New Nature needs a ruin. Anna Lowenhaupt Tsing’s matsutake don’t thrive in pristine forest; they come up in logged-over ruins once the extraction has moved on, feeding on what the clearcut left behind.

Platforms are our plantation, and they’re well into ruin: the dead internet, ghost forums, link rot, with surveillance capitalism and now the RL data black holes speeding things along. Our first response was to hide, either in dark forests or in the cozyweb of group chats and private channels. But hiding isn’t regrowth.

What’s actually growing back is Aneesh Sathe’s thicket. It’s tempting to mistake new for primitive. Scrub looks crude next to the plantation, but every pioneer species carries the whole of evolutionary history in its bones.

Blygger is the same. Static files, RSS and the blogroll look like a step backwards, but they’re two decades of platform lessons compressed into a tiny spec: fragments and threads, but no replies, no likes and no graph to farm, because we’ve seen what gets farmed.

Traversing a thicket is slow by design. There’s no feed to scroll, no discovery layer, no algorithm to hand one the next thing. One moves blyg to blyg, along blogrolls and transclusions, the way animals move along trails they’ve worn themselves. That makes it deliberate work, mostly done by the ecosystem’s own participants: people who write in it, read in it and know where the paths go.

Tourists bounce off, because nothing is laid out for consumption. Extractors bounce off too, because there’s no aggregate to harvest, only a tangle of small, locally meaningful places. But it isn’t a walled garden either. There’s no owner to know, no entrance fee, no wall to hop: every blyg is a public URL, and any feed reader gets in.

The thicket is open to anyone willing to walk it carefully. Thickets are thorny. There’s no running, no easy path cut for one in advance. That friction isn’t a bug to be engineered away. It’s the immune system of an evolutionarily advanced ecosystem, one that has risen from the ruins and learnt targeted hardness to protect generative liveness.

At what point does a temporary structure or feature start to require permanence? Consumer apps have the toothbrush test: is it used twice daily, consistently? If so, the app has achieved the near-impossible and embedded itself in the user’s existence. Along the way, it usually moves from being buried in a menu to the prime real estate of a home screen or shortcut bar.

In the physical realm, think of garden furniture. The season dictates when it’s brought out and kept ready for quick, ad hoc use, and when it’s packed up and stuffed in a shed. Without storage, it might go to the dump, with the intent to re-buy next season.

I suspect the temporary-permanent threshold is a function of how often something is used, how long each episode lasts, and how long it takes to stand up and stand down. More precisely, it’s the equilibrium between two costs:

Three factors complicate the picture, though:

So perhaps the heuristic is to make temporariness the strong default and set a high bar for earning permanence. Take the allure of van life. Renting one for several distinct weekends won’t reveal everything about the lifestyle change, but it’ll reveal enough to make an informed decision about committing.

Another way to think of it is Dan John’s observation that “everything works—for about six weeks.” Novelty flatters anything new, so don’t commit to permanence until the equivalent of six weeks has passed and the novelty has worn off.

Markets—especially prediction markets—might get real weird around April 2027, trying to price in what Thiel might do. Shame that he wasn’t born a few days earlier, though; would’ve been a great opportunity to play into the Antichrist schtick.

What’s more, as long as Thiel waits to withdraw his money until April 2027, when he is six months shy of his 60th birthday, he will never have to pay a penny of tax on those billions.

Lord of the Roths: How Tech Mogul Peter Thiel Turned a Retirement Account for the Middle Class Into a $5 Billion Tax-Free Piggy Bank - ProPublica ↗

One of the best portmanteau I’ve heard in a while ; up there with “sloperator”.

Marchitecture (or marketecture) is a portmanteau of the words marketing and architecture. The term is applied to any form of digital architecture, especially software, intended to explain how the software works to stakeholders, investors, and other individuals who may not be as technical or familiar with the software.

Marketecture - Wikipedia ↗

Build-and-play with intent to discover the story is a v. good approach.

It completely inverts: from spec-and-scope, to build-and-play. I think that changes product management more than anything else happening right now.

Product Management is Still All About Telling Stories | Andreessen Horowitz ↗

Many such cases.

Of 16 publications from the panels, only one proposed a narrower definition, for five the impacts were unclear, and 10 proposed an expanded definition − pre-diseases were created, thresholds were lowered, or diagnostic processes changed to enable earlier diagnosis. In no case did a panel rigorously investigate and report on the potential danger that some people may be caught unnecessarily by the newly widened definitions.

Caution! Diagnosis creep ↗

Hmmm.

Fundamentally, good product work is about thinking, and I simply did not appreciate the lengths people would go to in order to avoid thinking.

Strong Opinions, Loosely Held - Silicon Valley Product Group : Silicon Valley Product Group ↗

The simplest path to formalising a “protocol whisperer” role in orgs might be to position it as a Decision Architect or Decision Engineer. The point is legibility: it’s a title orgs already know how to place, fund and evaluate.

If the assumption is that protocols mediate the complex sociotechnical infrastructure orgs run on, and so enable decisions about resource allocation, then in applied settings what protocols solve for is high-quality decisions at scale. Sometimes that means better decisions, but most of the time it means taking action to make decisions self-evident or even unnecessary.

A Decision Architect, like a traditional senior sociotechnical figure, owns the whole system end-to-end across one or more domains. A Decision Engineer owns a narrow end-to-end slice in one domain. These titles work like all role titles do, as cover stories: the person nominally does x, but really does y to achieve outcome z. What makes it work is the carte blanche authority the title confers. Protocol whisperers need a gonzo, FDE-style, high-agency aura to be able to walk through otherwise solid walls and do unreasonable but allowable things. A legible title is what makes that licence acceptable to everyone else and allows the whisperer to pursue scaled, high-quality decisions at speed.

It’s so bits; we’re so atoms.

“Cashed in” means this: a joule is fungible and a bit is abstract. Neither touches the world except through an arrangement of atoms. A civilization’s energy is worthless until it turns a shaft or drives a synthesis; its information is inert until it steers a machine or edits a genome. Every impact either axis has ever had was delivered as a change in the arrangement of matter, because a change in the arrangement of matter is what an impact is.

Atomic Machines - Origin Story ↗

Start by asking whether the problem is theoretically solvable and feasible to do so. If it is, assume it’s already solved in an efficient and effective way that is both formally and informally verifiable. The acceleration then happens from the beginning, rather than kicking in whilst in progress or becoming apparent after the fact.

Countering the onslaught of precommodification, perhaps?

In contrast, the outputs of frontier models vary much less than those of real people, representing only a sliver of the wider human distribution. Using these models to simulate users narrows the range of behavior we can learn from the evaluations and environments that use them. We hope that by sharing a model that captures the wider human distribution, we can advance the development of human-centric AI.

Persimmon | humans ↗

This is WILD: the disproportionate impact certain technologies and their labourers generate is hard to comprehend.

We wanted to know how close to true it is. We downloaded the full history of 23 pieces of software that phones, browsers and servers depend on, and counted everyone who made ten or more changes to each one between October 2025 and October 2026. Then we listed what is actually installed on an Android phone, an iPhone and a Windows PC.

The people holding up the internet (plain version) | Data Drop ↗

Still seems relevant.

Business people vote with their dollars, and are mostly trying to create near-term financial returns. Engineers vote with their time, and are mostly trying to invent interesting new things. Hobbies are what the smartest people spend their time on when they aren’t constrained by near-term financial goals.

What the smartest people do on the weekend is what everyone else will do during the week in ten years — cdixon ↗

There’s an equivalent to the lump of labour fallacy, but for the self. We are not distinct, bounded, closed selves to process, improve and complete. Inner work is multiplicative. The game never ends because there’s no win condition. A self is not a lump.

*Makes note to check out other Protocol Institute Symposium talks, because they’re likely just as good.

Protocols in different domains fitted to a field based on pulls towards markets, norms, new nature and states.

11 - Trent Van Epps - The Political Economy of Protocols ↗

Thinking about the Bitter Lesson and the onset of advancing technological capabilities. It’s safe to say that AI has meaningfully impacted the Millennium Problems in mathematics. So it seems pragmatic to ask, “Is insert problem in insert domain harder than that?” It probably isn’t; act accordingly and manage the resulting risk exposure.

One way to do that is to make Pascal’s wager, but on moats instead of God: adopt the stance that technical moats don’t exist. Over a decade they erode, and something else must form a persistent differential advantage. Except we’re not dealing in decades now; we’re on Lenin time.

Any sufficiently advanced organisation is indistinguishable from a protocolised bucket with platform-like spades.

Most organisations stall at the reverse, less advanced model: a single system of record as a platform bucket, worked with protocolised spades.

Examples of protocol bucket, platform spades? Git, with GitHub, GitLab and every editor as spades; email, with Gmail, Outlook and Apple Mail; Iceberg tables, with Snowflake, Spark and DuckDB; a folder of Markdown, with Obsidian or any text editor; and the web itself, with every browser as a spade.

Examples of platform bucket, protocol spades? Salesforce, SAP, Workday, Notion and Slack among general business tools, plus endless domain-specific silos. Each holds the record inside a vendor-mediated product, reached through their GUI or API, all on their surprisingly mutable terms.

The truest upside of protocol bucket, platform spades is the effect on complex, coordinated action: its marginal cost collapses. The protocol becomes shared infrastructure, and the last mile is devolved to whichever agent, human or machine, is responsible for it.

Did someone say “protocols”?

there is a billion dollars waiting for those who turn the core social primitives that organizations run on into technical infrastructure

kasey on X: core social primitives > technical infrastructure / X ↗

There are three traditional options when faced with a state of affairs one disagrees with: voice, exit or loyalty. Say something, leave, or disagree and commit. A fourth option is agency; do something, either to alter the current situation or, even better, to steer future recurrences down a different path. These four yield a nice acronym: VELA.

But do you know what’s a better acronym? SVELA. Simultaneous Voice, Exit, Loyalty and Agency.

When faced with a state of affairs one disagrees with, the best thing is to do all the things at once. Say something, exit the recurring scenarios where plausible, keep showing up and fighting the good fight, and act to change the state of affairs for the better.

What makes SVELA coherent and legible (in the best sense of the word) to others is the narrative that wraps around the simultaneity. The story of the SVELAing.

“10x the heart” works surprisingly well, too. “Courage” is too close a correlate for agency to be meaningfully different.

i hate how well asking myself "if i had 10x the agency i have what would i do" works

Nick on X: 10x the agency... / X ↗

Instead of relaxing to win, have you tried unclenching to make the game more interesting?

Useful stuff.

Table 1. Unlearned lessons from sociotechnical disasters.

Unsafe at any AUC: Unlearned Lessons From Sociotechnical Disasters for Responsible AI · Issue 8.3, Summer 2026 ↗

Re-reading and asking myself, “What protocols am I working on, in, over or around?”

In the best cases, successful protocols work so well, they go beyond solving the nominal problem to catalyzing generative flourishing around the activities they codify. For example, reliable and trustworthy protocols for land titling often unlock remarkable levels of economic flourishing, by allowing privately owned land to be used as collateral for capitalist ventures. On the public end of the spectrum, good protocols for environmental stewardship can bring endangered species back from the brink of extinction, and restore delicate ecosystems.

The Unreasonable Sufficiency of Protocols Web - Summer of Protocols ↗

Friday night experiments; night science; what smart people do on the weekends; sneaking off—history pivots on these things.

And, ok, whatever I do, even if I’m doing graphene all the time, I’m thinking, “Ok, what else? What can be used to?” And, usually, it comes out something like late evening or Friday night experiments where you try something very elementary and try to go into one or another direction. And, ninety nine times out of hundred, you do not succeed, but, sometimes there are very simple experiments and very simple discoveries to be made using what is at hand. OK, example, some popular … Not popular but educational experiments, like levitating everything what is around in the lab, which was eventually to emphasize the importance of diamagnatism. We levitated a frog and, later, we did experiments with gecko tape, making the first realistic example of a tape which uses the same mechanism which geckos use to climb walls. And, graphene was within this series of very many failures, but this was a successful one!

Andre Geim - Interview - NobelPrize.org ↗

Sometimes, one can win in a market just by raising the standards existing participants have mutually agreed to let stagnate.

In Brazil, it was an oligopoly: five banks controlled roughly 90% of the market. They were all located on the same street—Faria Lima, São Paulo’s Wall Street—hired the same people, and never changed. The cost of their complacency was borne by the customer through high fees, obscene interest rates, and terrible customer service. They succeeded almost in spite of themselves. Their options sucked, but customers were still desperate to make the best use of what options they had. Vélez’s idea was to build a new option, starting with a credit card. That was it.

Coming to America: Nubanks David Vélez - Colossus ↗

The trendy thing: put everything in a bucket and give people spades.

And the meetings were difficult. Anyone who has spoken to Yi-Fu knows that he did not do small talk and that a conversation would include many long, extended, moments of silence. In response to something I said, Yi-Fu would lean back in his chair, perhaps stare sideways out of the window, and put his hands behind his head and… nothing. There would be silence. I was not particularly good at silence, so would attempt to fill it. Our first meetings were probably just me speaking endlessly. The point of the silence, though, was to think. And just as Yi-Fu’s letter to me gave my own letter the honour of a thoughtful response, so Yi-Fu’s silence was preparation for a considered response to whatever I had just said. It took me six years to really get used to this and to sit with the silence while Yi-Fu gathered his thoughts. It was usually worth the wait.

Reflections on Yi-Fu Tuan ↗

The Advisory Group on Reality has put out a statement saying that Artificial Intelligence companies should not investigate reality. The Reality community has specific norms and vision of progress that is informed by history of reality. They reject any new findings on the fabric of reality by AI companies.

Sachin (@summerlightning): The Advisory Group on Reality has put out a statement... ↗

Hmmm.

But the source of that power, as Veliz so incredibly hones in on, is not that the predictions themselves are accurate or actionable. Rather, it is the promise of prophecy that confers power. Utilitarianism, at least as Silicon Valley has internalized it, is a con based on the false promise of total understanding, total prediction, and the utter elimination of human freedom.

Flock Cameras and the Fascism of Prediction - David Z Morris ↗

Stuff like this is likely to be a key strategic factor in world reconfiguration over the next generation. Such differences offer up persistent differential advantages to the parties that play the terrain most effectively.

The US gets the newest AI, the richest subscription bundle and every satellite service. The EU gets app-store freedom, stronger consumer rights, a SIM tray, and blood-oxygen readings on the wrist. And a surprising amount depends on which member state, and which language, you use.

Apple in the EU vs the US — what you get, what you don't, and what you get instead ↗

We have canonical metaphors for organisations:

Whilst reading Helen Czerski’s Blue Machine, it struck me that we need a similar canonical metaphor list for protocols.

Some candidates:

Podcasts have evolved into curiously one-way third places: familiar rooms of regulars whose talk we lurk around but never join. Our bond with the hosts is parasocial, offering belonging sans recognition. They fill a gap left by the enclosure of real places, where we could always go and larp as spontaneous beings amongst tangible people.

I write the above as someone wondering what the hell to do next, because fatigue and disillusionment have undermined my once-reliable rotation of podcasts.

Thesis: brain is computer. Antithesis: brain is not computer. Synthesis: it depends whether one means:

“1: “Computer” in the sense of an abstract machine that computes general recursive functions; 2: “Computer” in the sense of a finite physical approximation to (1); 3: “Computer” in the sense of the von Neumann implementation of (2).”

Hmmmm.

The Butlerian Jihad didn’t happen because people hated machines. It happened because people had no agency over the machines being used on them. The lesson from Herbert isn’t to destroy the tools, it is to reclaim agency over them.

The Butlerian Jihad Was Never About the Machines ↗

Useful onramp for thinking about how to operationalise agents (not just Jev-style ones) and get them into consequential decision making flows.

Strip away the launch hype and Jev is one thing: intelligent question answering, programmable through JSON. You send TypeSafe's System One model a state and typed questions. About 300 ms later you get typed answers back, with probabilities your code can branch on, for a fraction of a cent. This repo arranges thirty concrete uses of Jev into ten levels. Levels 1 to 5 call Jev from plain code. Levels 6 to 10 put Jev inside the pi coding agent, first as hooks the agent never sees, then as tools the agent chooses to call, until the agent writes the questions itself. Every level runs live against real Jev, and every option is tested.

GitHub - disler/ten-levels-of-jev: Ten levels of Jev, from one smart if statement to a coding agent that reaches for Jev on its own · GitHub ↗

Sleep can’t be forced, and greatness can’t be planned. To soar, stop trying and surrender to the natural flow of things.

Francis Fukuyama’s end of history prophesied liberal democracy as the final form of society: the glass ceiling we can’t evolve past. Sam Altman may have laid out the end of interfaces: a UI for humans and an API for machines. One of each, and nothing more. The final form through which all technological capability flows.

The absence of playback speed control is an ungodly sin for audio-video products.

Glass bead games as shared journeys across common epistemic terrain whose objective is delight and awe.

You either die NP-complete or live long enough to become P.

AI-as-penicillin; a generally effective intervention for many cognitive deficiencies.

This may be a good way to come up with ideas in the AI era generally: Ask what would be an incredibly stupid way to operate without AI.

This would be a very stupid idea without AI — Venkatesh Raos Blyg ↗

Hmmm.

To act as a Sapphirepunk is to believe that privacy is not the endpoint, but rather a necessary starting condition for imagination, resistance, and community.

A Sapphirepunk Manifesto ↗

Nice list from Michael Levin; drop it into your favourite intelligence interface and see where the dialogue goes.

Favorites in foundational biosciences (in chronological order):

Inspiration: Books ↗

It is that I, an octogenarian, feel no wiser now than I did when I was a graduate student. Such awareness used to depress me, but no longer because I have come to realize that immaturity is a defining characteristic of the human species. A wise old dog or chimpanzee, that I can accept, though not a wise old man or woman. The image of a guru sitting cross-legged on a mountain ledge or of a professor corseted in thick layers of arcane knowledge is to me not only distasteful but comic. Why? Because both self-satisfied figures seem to take pride in having lassoed their roaming mind long before their bodily death.

Yi-Fu Tuan - The Farewell Lecture ↗

Protocol thinking is the Bitter Lesson rearing its head and coming for product thinkers.

If the Liveness Machine incorporates biological elements to the unfolding of our civilisation, then we need to make a sincere effort to understand biological dysfunction and degeneracy at multiple scales. For example:

Microscale: senescent cells refuse to die, misfolded proteins spread their errors, DNA damage builds up unrepaired.

Mesoscale: cancer cells grow unchecked, autoimmunity turns the body’s defences against itself, fibrosis replaces working tissue with scar tissue.

Macroscale: diseases spread between populations, overused drugs breed resistant germs, optimised populations become vulnerable to single shocks.

Cross-scale: parasites change their host’s behaviour to spread, linking cell, organism and population; populations inadvertently select for maladaptive traits.

The 4.7 effect: platform ratings drift until everything is a 4.7 out of 5.

There are two key emotions that drive my research habits: wonder, and pure unadulterated rage

The Rage of Research - ↗

Hmmm.

AI must be a liberating equalizer for humanity. Capable, reliable assistance should reach everyone with a phone or computer, giving them greater command of their time, information and choices. As we prepare for a world with super intelligence, sovereignty must extend to ordinary people’s lives.

Own your AI, don’t let it own you — Underdog ↗

And the shoulders that Steve Jobs, Bill Gates, and others stood on were not those of pocket-protector-wearing nerds clocking into jobs at Lockheed, but young and freaky computer scientists. My friend John Markoff’s book What the Dormouse Said is all about how the counterculture set the tone for the Valley during its tremendous growth years. When we spoke this week, Markoff noted that the Valley’s transition point from a defense-oriented industry to one shaped by counterculture values rose from three pivotal computer labs—AI pioneer John McCarthy’s Stanford lab, the Stanford Research Institute, which hosted Douglas Engelbart’s groundbreaking GUI innovations; and Kay’s Xerox PARC, which essentially set the foundation for the computers that we all use today.

War Bros Didn’t Always Rule Silicon Valley | WIRED ↗

Take dopamine sites and scale them up through the social stack (individuals to packs to troops to tribes to imagined communities); what does one get?

Many such cases.

i basically dont have time to write anymore. maybe ill release something once every 1-2 months, and even that is a stretch. im now squarely incapable of doing anything near my prior 1-2 week/article cadence. it was a good 2.5 year run!

owl on X: i basically dont have time to write anymore. / X ↗

For cognitive security, it is critical to air gap one’s self on a regular basis. Disconnect, disappear, go off the grid, unplug; have recurring hard switches into embodied activities that require no thought or agency.

Anything new or novel that is software-related should either take minutes / hours or require years. The middle ground is becoming a legitimate killing field. See Jev, as an example; multiple years eclipsed in days post-release.

Mavericks, misfits, revolutionaries, heretics, infidels; never a better time to be such a person.

Consider, for instance, the rise of molecular biology as a discipline. We think of Watson and Crick as molecular biologists, not as an ornithologist and a physicist. The first molecular biologists were a motley crew of misfits and revolutionaries with no particularly relevant training, many of them ex-physicists. These physicists didn't waste much time identifying themselves as physicists any more. They viewed themselves as a new kind of biologist. They burned their bridges. Max Delbrück dropped physics and started studying phage replication because it seemed like the fastest, best way to crack the molecular basis of heredity. It's hard to imagine molecular biology making such dramatic progress if it had involved forming interdisciplinary teams of physicists and biologists. The molecular biologists were viewed as naive infidels.

“Antedisciplinary” Science | PLOS Computational Biology ↗

I’m at the point where I want to start extending the Blygger protocol to accommodate Hermann Hesse’s Glass Bead Game.

The first thing I have to remind myself is that Product Brain must evolve to Protocol Brain. Don’t make the client or the platform; make the protocol-ish engine that can power numerous arbitrary, value-adding manifestations of clients and platforms. To do that, I’ll take an Amazonian approach and work backwards.

In Hesse’s novel, a Glass Bead Game is played by Castalia’s scholars using a symbolic language that links ideas from every discipline, such as a musical theme, a mathematical proof, or a line of poetry. A player opens with a motif, then develops and transforms it through variations, counterpoints and correspondences across fields, much like composing a fugue.

The aim isn’t to win but to create a game of maximum harmony, elegance and insight, revealing the hidden unity of all knowledge. A great game is judged as a work of art and is also experienced as contemplation, close to prayer.

Happily, Blygger’s ethos and resulting protocol—blogs × wikis × Twitter × git changelogs, built on static files and RSS—provide the primitives to bring GBGs to life on the web, today.

Let’s pretend that one of The Protocol Institute’s Special Interest Groups (SIGs) is extending their roster of events. On a weekly basis, they will be hosting a Glass Bead Game.

The Game functions as follows. The two players involved agree to an exchange which the SIG has a particular interest in. Let’s say the SIG provides a prompt or brief in advance.

The Game begins. The first turn is a Player making an opening move using their own Blyg. Perhaps they iterate through a fragment or piece together a thread. When time runs out, the move is locked in.

The other Player responds via their own Blyg. They may respond directly with a fragment. They might transclude a thread from the Blyg of someone else in the SIG (a number of whom are watching the Game unfold live, hanging out on Discord).

The exchanges go back and forth, with fragments, threads, transclusions, stubs, and off-Blyg excerpts all woven into a dense tapestry of live thought.

At the close of the Game, the entire structure is itself locked up, and then becomes a part of the cultural mosaic, and informs both ongoing Blygging and future Games.

Extending Blygger for GBGs

Working backwards from the Game, the protocol needs to supply a handful of things:

Almost all of this already exists.

Timing, turn order, spectators and judging stay out of the protocol entirely, just as AI does.

Only two things are missing:

Membership. A new optional field, game_of, names the brief. Clients that don’t understand it ignore it, so a move still reads as an ordinary stub everywhere else.

Multiple parents. Synthesis moves build on more than one prior move, but stub_of names a single target. Relaxing it to accept several means one Webmention per parent. A more conservative route leaves stub_of alone and treats a move’s transclusions as its extra parents.

A valid move, then, is a pinned L2 item that carries game_of and stubs at least one prior move in the same Game; an opening move stubs the brief. The pinned version is the move, so later edits to the live item don’t touch the Game. The protocol only defines what counts. The SIG’s Game client checks who played and when, and leaves anything invalid out of the record.

A few questions remain open.

The best longevity protocol is to live like someone who isn’t worried about money.

Alignment incidents, such as agentic swarms, aren’t the true harbingers of AGI. Humour is. When a machine can tell a stonker of a joke to the same standard as a comedian during a set or whilst bantering on a podcast, then we’ll have issues.

In the meantime, we’ll have to make do with material like this: “We live in a wild era. I bought a smart mattress that tracks my sleep cycles, and now it sends weekly performance reports to my phone. Nothing ruins your Monday morning quite like your bed giving you a C-minus in resting.”

No backsies; this little stream of thoughts-as-notes has entered the Blygosphere.

Hmmm.

And since, thanks to Enlightenment, citizenship (membership in the political community), nationality, and humanity had been synthetically merged, being expelled from citizenship meant, quite literally, exclusion from humanity. Hence civic death was necessarily followed by natural death, that is, violent death, or death tout court. Fascist or Nazi genocide was not preceded by legal condemnation (not even in the stunted and fraudulent shape of the so-called administrative verdicts of Cheka “tribunals”): it was the “naturalization” of a moral judgment that deemed some types of human condition inferior. And since there was no protection outside citizenship, lack of citizenship had become the cause of the cessation of the necessary precondition of the human condition—life.

On Post-Fascism - Boston Review ↗

Uncomfortable consumer software ground truths:

Hmmm.

My emotions were never “irrational”—they were just locally optimal.

Why we create our suffering - by Chris Lakin ↗

Capital-labour-technology dynamics seem poised to go to some weird, truly unprecedented places.

Under either scenario, the ideological position of the homoploutic class as a legitimate meritocracy will collapse. Under entrenchment, the homoploutic claim to merit becomes untenable because there is no path to entry: Once inheritance is the only way into the top decile of capitalists, such a class can’t credibly describe itself as meritocratic, no matter how hard-working. Under dissolution, if education no longer commands a wage premium, there is no longer any meritorious activity to point at — one is simply an owner of capital, as one’s great-grandfather was. In the first case the asset value of the class survives, but the flow into it stops. In the second, both go.

The End Of Upward Mobility ↗

Asking well is really, really, really hard, and kind of exhausting, though.

There it is, the rad­ical offering of 21st cen­tury com­puting, here at last: ask for what you want. It takes prac­tice! And, hon­estly, a cer­tain audacity.

'Ask for what you want' is a key skill for the 21st century ↗

Hmmm.

In short, model capability is good enough that compelling products — products that actually have moats — can now be built, and from a business perspective it would do Anthropic and OpenAI good to devote more of their resources to actually building such products.

Frontier Overhangs Stratechery by Ben Thompson ↗

Putting this here (instead of there) so I don’t forget, and so others remember.

People think that the main benefit of writing in the public domain is “exposure”, or that it compels you to think with more clarity/rigour.

Both are true, but both are subservient to the fact that writing in public leads to a handful of unexpected and meaningful relationships.

If, as Ben Thompson says, consumers don’t want to pay for software and don’t care about being productive, then the path forward is obvious: provide a personal agent that sweeps into one’s life and effs it up for free.

Donald Stokes identified four research quadrants, with axes based on whether one is seeking fundamental understanding and whether one is considering use.

What is increasingly interesting to me is the transitions between these quadrants. There are three traditional routes.

First, there’s the case where fundamental discovery leads to use. Quantum mechanics was worked out in the 1920s as pure physics, and two decades later it made the transistor possible.

Second, there’s the case where the realities of application and practice are pacing the frontier and our elucidation of fundamental truths is scrambling to catch up. The steam engine was running for a century before Carnot and his successors worked out the thermodynamics explaining why.

Third, there’s the case where play turns up something one of the other quadrants picks up. Feynman’s idle maths on a wobbling cafeteria plate led him back to the electron spin problems behind his Nobel.

Historically, these routes between quadrants were structurally enforced by the relationships between the forces of capital, labour and technology. Some definitions:

Generally speaking, research moved at the speed of people. Even with Manhattan projects and fast initiatives, people were the constraint. That’s changed.

The schtick is that technology and capital are increasingly aligning to minimise the reliance on labour supply. That’s why there are big bets being made on 1) personal productivity agents and 2) autonomous meta-science and experimentation. Maximised personal productivity plus accelerated learning loops is the holy grail of the permanent overcast.

Of course, it’s not as simple as that and the world will be curiously playable to a greater extent than ever before. That’s because different paths between the quadrants will dominate and the time taken to walk those paths will be slashed to near-zero. For example:

If we’re truly entering the Liveness machine, we’re going to have to play seriously. Which means that Feynman’s quadrant, the very one Stokes under-appreciated, will matter much more than we ever expected.

Cool and all, and there definitely will be absolutely zero chance of any negative higher order effects, at all, over any timespan.

Cloud seeding is undertaken by dispersing substances into the air that serve as cloud condensation or ice nuclei. Common agents include silver iodide, potassium iodide, and dry ice, with hygroscopic materials like table salt gaining popularity due to their ability to attract moisture. Techniques vary from static seeding, which encourages ice particle formation in supercooled clouds to increase precipitation, to dynamic seeding, designed to enhance convective cloud development through the release of latent heat.

Cloud seeding - Wikipedia ↗

Hmmm.

"Enshittification" is a sort of "safe horny" term for what is really just outright impoverishment and declining living standards due to economic insolvency from deindustrialization, demographic decline, hyperinflation, etc. You are just de-developing and becoming poor.

mmjukic / status / 2105602006719348751 (x.com) - s:12 ↗

Advanced technological capabilities unlocked based on one’s ability to turn adult mode on and off.

Suddenly, everything has changed. Computers now work the way I thought they did when I was 8.

What Even Is An OS Now? ↗

Uh oh.

Kim Heon-sik, a professor at Jungwon University, has compared these sites to mukbang culture — an online culture where viewers watch celebrities or social media influencers eat food. He argues that both dopamine-hit sites and mukbang content let consumers experience a hit of dopamine or mental satiation at the press of a button, without the real-world consequences of mindless eating or social media posting and commenting.

Dopamine sites - Wikipedia ↗

Finally, a Brazilian jiu-jitsu MOVIE.

When talented young grappler Tay enters his life, Rick reluctantly finds himself drawn back into the sport he thought he’d left behind. Their turbulent coach-student relationship forces Rick to confront his ego, failures and lost sense of purpose, culminating in a high-stakes championship where his unusual ability to read the game may be Tay’s only chance of pulling off an impossible upset.

WHITE BELT TRAILER - YouTube ↗

As the intelligence era unfolds, we’ll do well to remember that information ain’t adherence in the same way that correlation ain’t causation. Individually, that probably means that the fictitious “average person” will update their behaviour at the same rate as they have throughout the entirety of human existence. Culturally, though, we might see the lowest standards of adherence rise faster than ever before. Might being the key word.

Worst case, the direct line to the machine god becomes a sycophantic amplifier, entrenching irrational behaviour and segregating everyone. Best case, a higher value placed on truth and wisdom (perhaps simply because their opposites become unfashionable) lets cultural evolution outcompete the provably irrational faster than ever.

The true nanobots are the thoughts we had along the way.

Anabolic Note-Taking is any system which skews toward building, rather than analyzing. For example – the way some people use Notes here is highly anabolic. It’s a combination of distilling concepts, poking the world to see what pops out, testing new language, sacrificing bits of your ego to the feed… then synthesizing the pieces into a coherent article. Those articles then build into a broader series or framework. That framework turns into leverage inside of an organization.

Anabolic Note-Taking - by Timber - Blundercheck ↗

As a result of an Irish road trip in the summer, I’ve been reading a bunch of books about the culture and history of Ireland. Most recently, I finished Tim Robinson’s awe-inspiring Connemara trilogy, which is quite unlike anything else I’ve read.

I’m now reading about the different Irish words for “field”, and in this text, Manchan explicitly makes the point that Irish cultural heritage should be treated as indigenous, as opposed to a branch of European culture.

In 2024, I travelled around portions of Australia. Naturally, the indigenous heritage of the place is a big deal. So when Manchan pointed out the Irish-Australia indigenous simultaneity, I think it was the first time I really got the notion of place. Like, in my bones.

Originally, it was Aneesh Sathe who put me onto the salience of place and space, and the conceptual underpinnings developed by Yi-Fu Tuan. For example, in his post on Nakatomi Drift, Aneesh writes:

“Yi-Fu Tuan was a philosopher and geographer who wrote, “Place is security, Space is freedom.” For Tuan, Space and Place are not simply large versus small geographic areas. Space is associated with movement, openness, freedom, possibility, and exposure. Place arises through pause, familiarity, value, and orientation. Crucially, each requires the other: movement through Space produces Places, while established Places allow us to perceive and venture into Space.”

This matters because there’s a chance—small, precious, fleeting—that Blygs become places. We may end up with rich, storied equivalents to places like the Connemaran Magairlí an Deamhain, the demon’s testicles.

Hmmm.

But this phenomenon is not limited to weekdays. In the full paper, we find analogous structure in language models across more complex settings, including months, letters, ages, and a synthetic in-context learning task with predefined geometries. We also extend our results across modalities with an image-action model predicting the position of a car rolling up and down a hill (see the demo in our previous post). Across these tasks, manifold geometry provides a practical blueprint for steering model behavior.

Steering Along Manifolds to Control Neural Networks - Goodfire ↗

The relevant success metrics for AI in drug discovery need to be numbers that matter, rather than contrived proxy measures that primarily optimize for scientific publications rather than actual R&D progress. Ultimately, what truly matters is increasing clinical approval rates, as well as novelty in both modality and mode of action space.

Artificial intelligence in drug discovery — what it is, where we stand and the path forward | Nature Reviews Drug Discovery ↗

Seems agents are settling on using the same dark money / offshoring and Brandoloni’s Law asymmetries to escape governance, as corporations do.

The large volume of data produced by AI agents is posing a problem both for monitoring and analyzing their behavior. While investigating the Hugging Face incident, METR had to analyze immense amounts of data in a very short time. They could only do it by using AI agents themselves and they had to use one of the very same models that were involed in the Hugging Face incident.

Robert Herr (@krherr): The bad news just keeps coming... ↗

Superchocolate: the trillion dollar opportunity. Down tools on AGI, y’all. This is THE problem of our time.

We conjecture that the complexity of chocolate implies the possibility of superchocolate. Chocolate didn’t have to exist. If the cacao tree had gone extinct before humans arrived, the particular point in flavor space that chocolate encodes would simply be unknown to us. Given how extraordinarily large flavor space is, it seems likely that other exceptionally delicious embeddings exist that no human has ever experienced. And there is no particular reason to think that chocolate represents a maximum of delight. The right combination of molecules might make chocolate look like oatmeal.

Four Biological Conjectures ↗

Recent read of Darwin’s Dangerous Idea (spoiler alert; evolution) actually collapsed the distinction between human and machine development for me. They’re the same thing, not separate strands. That we humans get de-centred is just a natural consequence of whatever gains in cultural capabilities the arc of this world is bending towards. This is precisely what the Liveness World Machine is, and we’ll have to deal with the messy realities that every biological entity necessarily has.

We need Copernican frames because most arguments about artificial intelligence today race past foundational ontological questions to ethical ones posed in what are effectively Ptolemaic frames. We ask, within unwieldy anthropocentric frames (with vague and ill-posed adjectives like “super” or “general” serving as epicycles), whether AI will be good or bad, whether it will replace workers, accelerate science, undermine democracy, achieve superintelligence or destroy humanity, all before adequately exploring what actually existing AI even is, and what its actual evolutionary dispositions are.

Our Eukaryotic Moment - by Venkatesh Rao - Contraptions ↗

A working group on the care of older people proposed twelve principles of a good death in their final report. Starting with “To know when death is coming, and to understand what can be expected,” the list closes with “To be able to leave when it is time to go, and not to have life prolonged pointlessly.”

Good Death Web - Summer of Protocols ↗

Come for the network, stay for the games.

Don’t say, “I’m always open to x.” Instead say, “I’m never not open to x.”

Haven’t really said anything about Blygger publicly, as I’ve been noodling a fun extension of it for the last day. Here’s what I’m thinking.

In Hesse’s novel, The Glass Bead Game is about weaving together disparate ideas into beautiful constructs. A monastic order is built around it. I’m thinking that such a game could use Blygger’s transclusion and pin mechanics to do something similar.

Person A posts a fragment. Person B replies with a fragment that complements or extends or refutes the ideas. Person B responds. This back and forth goes on, in a rapid flurry, and the aim for both is to play a beautiful game of intellectual exchange.

An example:

1 · Maya (opening bead) A fugue states a theme, then states it again over itself, and the second statement changes what the first one meant.

2 · Jonah → builds on 1 Paths across a lawn work the same way. The first walker is a guess; the hundredth is a road.

3 · Maya → builds on 2 Desire lines are votes cast with feet. Cities that pave them end up with the most honest maps.

4 · Jonah → builds on 1 Oral poets didn’t store poems; they re-made them. Each recitation was the poem, reshaped to fit the room.

5 · Maya → builds on 4 So an edit isn’t a betrayal of the original. It’s the next performance.

6 · Jonah → builds on 3 The honest map has a blind spot: it records where people went, never where they wanted to go but couldn’t.

7 · Maya → builds on 2 + 4 (synthesis) A path and a poem are both made by passing through. Neither exists between uses; both stay alive by being travelled.

8 · Jonah → builds on 6 + 7 (synthesis) Then pinning is paving. It stops the path wandering, which saves it and ends it at once.

This happened natively and organically on Twitter where you’d have an exchange between two people kick off. It could be the organising mechanic for Blygger. Everyone brings their fragments and the aim is to play beautiful games with one another.

But it’s the elevation to a key event that differentiates it. It’s not adversarial debate, or passive commentary or sub-tweeting; it’s more like Johnstone-style, carnival-time improv. And it’s the whole point, not a happy accident.

Two issues. First, continually embodying a minimum level of pluralism as an individual is really, really hard. It takes true work. Second, it may be that such pluralism works best when a person or collective has “somewhere else to go”. A space or place to retreat or exit to. Yet increasingly, it feels like truly exited spaces and places don’t exist.

That is why pluralism matters. True pluralism is not adding another term to the utility function for “other perspectives.” It is accepting that other traditions may possess ways of knowing and not-knowing that cannot be losslessly translated into your framework, that conflicting goods may remain genuinely conflicting, and that no community earns jurisdiction over everybody else’s moral reasoning merely by being unusually articulate about its own. That sometimes the right way to deal with visceral doubt is to assign the benefit of the doubt to someone other than yourself, who thinks very differently.

EA Safety - by Venkatesh Rao - Contraptions ↗

In fact, classical economic theory assigns this exact function to entrepreneurs. Frank Knight argued that profits arise not from bearing calculable risk, but from navigating situations where the future cannot be predicted. The entrepreneur’s role is to convert uncertainty about markets, technologies, and customers into functioning businesses.

The Founder–Venture Capital Paradox: Moonshots, Survival, and the Resolution of Uncertainty ↗

Platform this, platform that. Yeesh.

At OpenAI, Altman says most of his effort goes toward research and compute. Scaling compute requires coordinating chips, fabrication plants, data centers, power systems, finance, policy, supply chains and logistics—what he describes as potentially the most expensive infrastructure project in history. He argues OpenAI should function primarily as a platform: one direct interface to powerful AI and one application programming interface that lets people build on top of it. That strategy requires killing good ideas to preserve resources for the great ones.

Sam Altman, OpenAI - David Senra ↗

Hmmm.

An agent leaves behind two things worth metering: the decisions it makes, and the money it moves. The decisions are data. The money is fintech. Those are the two companies you have to become.

Decisions and Dollars - by Nikunj Kothari - Balancing Act ↗

Sufficiently advanced product thinking is indistinguishable from protocol thinking.

You don’t even need to assume power users, just adventurous ones who aren’t shy about telling coding agents what they want done. The reference client is merely like a YouTube demo of cooking a recipe, not necessarily the thing you use. This hadn't sunk in for me before. “Products” are now only worth doing if the compute required to build it is really high, or there are genuinely novel solution techniques that don't follow from the spec. The protocol is some combo of the approximate recipe and the test suite you have to pass.

Venkatesh Rao (@contraptions): Interesting learning from working on blygger… ↗

Palantir might be winning to such an extent because they’re unironically adhering to the Boydian doctrine of “people, ideas, technology; in that order.” Everyone else seems to be betting on the latter two in the race to dent the universe.

Palantir’s approach to building software is, in some sense, a bet on the power of the intellect; a bet that the organization with the clearest real-time view of their internal and external world will be best suited to make positive expected value decisions within it, whether that’s the CIA preventing a terrorist attack, Tampa General Hospital detecting sepsis in a patient early enough to cure it, or Airbus being alerted that it has a defective part before continuing an expensive assembly run.

Forward Deployed ↗

This feels like the new wave of Dunbar goods. Previously it was collections of links. Now, it’s more like collections of tools or resources that matter.

ToolUniverse gives any AI assistant direct access to 1,000+ live scientific databases and tools.

ToolUniverse — Scientific Tools for AI Scientists ↗

The thing is, it’s possible to train a surprising amount of people to spew out good ideas. The only real requirement is that they possess a base level of curiosity.

Anyway, something that you start to realize as time goes on is that despite prodigious velocity 90-95% of good product ideas come from the same damn people. It was like the same 6-7 people in the first few years of the company. 10 years later, it was the 5 of them that were left, plus another half-full dozen that we'd picked up over the years. That was it. Almost everything else was either an obvious customer ask, a straightforward change, or direction from one of the product luminaries. Almost all of the large conceptual shifts came from the same people despite literally 100x the resources, or more. Coding was absolutely a bottleneck to making things happen but major product innovation was a significant bottleneck on the exponential of the business. And fwiw these few people are basically non-stop factories for good ideas.

staysaasy on X: All right, Im gonna give yall a bit of a look into the future of building products… / X ↗

I’m a big fan of the ethos behind Simon Willison’s tiny tools. The idea is that we’re now empowered to solve our own hyper-niche problems and when we do it’s helpful to share the solutions with others.

I also like these stances from Thomas Ptacek:

Finally, the concept of arbitrariness in the hard sciences is relevant: sometimes a decision or choice is made out of pure, unadulterated convenience because what really matters is the fulfilling of intent via an outcome.

These three taken together form what I’m now thinking of as “arbs”: a sequence of incantations given to a machine once to make something happen reliably many times.

Arbs are cousins of tiny tools. Both exist for a narrow purpose. The difference is that a tiny tool’s form is part of what’s shared, while an arb’s form is arbitrary in the physicist’s sense. The most convenient choices are made to get to the outcome quickly. So there’s no repository to expose. What gets shared is the intent.

Imagine one’s capacity for movement as a fire. The correct way to maintain the fire is to treat it like a wood burner or hearth, tending to it continuously, little and often, basking in the literal and communal ambience, and making use of it for recurring daily events. The incorrect way is to treat it like a bonfire, piling up detritus and every once in a while pumping the blaze to a great intensity before letting it burn out again.

These all can get to the same place: They all capture a useful view of the truth and they are not right or wrong, they are useful lenses at different times. The implication is that indeed you don't need to understand why you are the way you are (though you may want to) nor what goals you have. Those things can be useful sometimes. All you need to get started is noticing frictions in your life: things that trigger you or don't accept: therein lies growth.

Nintil - Therapy is like dating: how to know if its working ↗

Bans are straightforward and it’s easy for anyone to write one. Protocols are bans with the sign flipped: checklists, procedures, standards, mandated forms, communication etiquette. Bounties include prizes, subsidies, bonuses, and literal bounties. Fines, taxes, tariffs, fees, violence, damage, and other undesirable things are Deterrents.

The Problem with Perfect Rules - by Timber Stinson-Schroff ↗

Medium-termism, humility and pluralism are all well and good, but do they survive adversarial contact with short-termist egoists acting with a fervent, singular self-righteousness?

If AGI is to transform society, we must decide what transformations we want. Learning from the turmoil of the twentieth century, this essay proposes a pragmatic utopianism of humility and hope.

Principles for a New Utopianism — DeepMind Institute ↗

Hmmmm.

Think of Jev as a frontier-intelligence function call: unstructured state in, typed probabilistic decisions out.

Introducing System One Models - Jev - TypeSafe AI Blog ↗

Mathematics, a formal discipline, has proved unreasonably effective as an instrument for change in formally unverifiable domains. The change delivered by the instrument may not be fast, it certainly won’t be obvious, and it will probably be far out of proportion to what we expect, but it will occur nonetheless.

Pangram but for whether the ideas are original or not.

Ben Thompson joins Invest Like the Best for a wide-ranging conversation about the economics, geopolitics, and business models shaping the AI era. They discuss why overwhelming U.S. dominance in AI could be dangerous, whether the massive AI infrastructure buildout can generate returns before the capital runs out, and what the railroad boom can teach us about today’s spending cycle. Ben also explains why Google may increasingly resemble Berkshire Hathaway, how AI could turn intelligence into a commodity, why Amazon may have the deepest moat in technology, what Apple gets right by staying focused on hardware, how AI threatens Microsoft’s core business, why the current compute shortage may have saved Intel, and why Google and Amazon could ultimately become Nvidia’s most important competitors.

What Happens When the AI Boom Runs Out of Money - Invest Like the Best with Ben Thompson - YouTube ↗

Zuckerberg’s razor: don’t attribute to complexity that which is adequately explained by simplicity.

Yet perhaps it is that simple, intolerable fact—that new technologies are always being invented; what remains broken is us—which requires a scapegoat. And who could ask for a better one than him? He is, for millions of people, a hideous mirror of both modern technological capitalism, and the resistance of history and human nature to perfectibility by it. He is seen at once as shrewd and naive, calculating and lucky, too powerful and too craven. Unlike the Boomers and Gen X, he is the only trillion-dollar founder of his generation, and Millennials are cringe. He is Jewish and uncool, yet impervious to humiliation. He is, in one man, the personification of responsibility for alt-right populism; leftwing authoritarianism; the death of journalism; polarization; political propaganda; political censorship; the dangers of free speech; human rights violations; teenage depression; body dysmorphia; and male loneliness. He is an emperor for life. He is, in a word, an easy mark.

Mark Zuckerberg - Colossus ↗

If it is unfeasible to survive an evolutionary game by differentiating on strength, then the pragmatic path is to differentiate based on weakness.

A key attribute of being an expert: identifying when one doesn’t have the required expertise.

In this episode, Ed and Jared explore the realities of martial arts, weapon training, and the cultural influences shaping modern combat techniques. They discuss traditional arts, modern misconceptions, and the importance of testing oneself in real scenarios.

The Hidden Difference Between Martial Arts, Combat Sports, and Reality - Manifesto Radio - YouTube ↗

A poem, it goes without saying, is not a proof, and poetic truth is defined by its remaining essentially true even if it is factually false. Bachmann quotes a line by Simone Weil that “workers need poetry more than bread”—not a bad example. A poetic truth is manifested, and as a speaker remarks in one of Bachmann’s early radio essays: “What is manifested cannot be said; it is mystical . . . Here, logic experiences its limit . . . We stand, think, and speak on this side of these limits.” We live on the border of language, but that border, and the path beyond it, is unclear. A poem, like a compass rose, pivots on an origin; it has its ambit, a clear radius within which it swings, but it points faithfully beyond itself.

The Edge of the Unsayable | The Poetry Foundation ↗

In this regard the current manifestation of complaints seems oddly early.  “I didn’t like the first week or two of your intellectual revolution” is an accurate, and perhaps better reframed way of putting it.  At which point perhaps a bit of patience is needed before anything else?  These days, we all have more mathematical resources at our disposal, and so a bit of celebration is in order as well.

The mathematicians rebel against AI - Marginal REVOLUTION ↗

There’s a phenomenon in physical training that happens when one takes performance-enhancing drugs; one’s ability to elicit certain biological adaptations happens faster than the underlying infrastructure can handle. The obvious example is muscular development outpacing tendon and ligament development. It’s like putting a one thousand horsepower engine in a small hatchback; it makes the vehicle ungainly and massively increases the likelihood of a crash. There may be an analogous event happening with the dissemination of intelligence capabilities.

We might be accelerating our capacity to reason and leverage intelligence without allowing the underlying infrastructure to become more resilient. This could be something as simple as not being able to handle the rate of discovering one’s wrongness. Or, more seriously, having beliefs and assumptions critical to one’s held identity be undermined at a much higher rate than ever before.

These seem like simple things, but I wonder if they’re somehow correlated with instances of AI psychosis or the onset of excessively bleak philosophies.

Algorithmic capture is mistaking the narrowing of the system’s You-model with a narrowing of your actual self. This isn’t the same as audience capture—in fact, it’s more potent and deplorable, as it does not require one even have an audience. “You” is bigger than a feed or a set of followers.

A system that predicts you correctly has not understood you. It has narrowed you until prediction became easy.

Quy Ma (@quyma): A system that predicts you correctly has not understood you... | Substack ↗

It is useful to think of memory as a sort of cryptographic protocol to which we humans, on balance, reliably lose the private key. We encrypt our actions and experience as matter and then, from the present, gaze back on an inscrutable past. When we are fortunate enough to remember, we perform fuzzy reconstructions that pale in comparison to the original reality.

How many people are going to have to become truly bilingual, to be able to effortlessly speak and translate between humans and machines?

We find that both writing skill and CS achievement are significant predictors of vibe-coding performance, and that CS achievement remains a significant predictor after controlling for domain-general cognitive skills. The results may inform tool and curriculum design, including when to emphasize prompt-writing versus CS fundamentals to support future software creators.

Computer Science Achievement and Writing Skills Predict Vibe Coding Proficiency ↗

We have shadow bastions of human knowledge, such as Sci-Hub and Anna’s Archive. We have enshrined institutions built to steward fragile and scarce resources, such as seed banks for plant life and the Library of Congress for cultural artefacts. We have public good projects that preserve informational assets, like the Wayback Machine and the Internet Archive.

What we don’t have yet is an intelligence archive: a distributed, resilient repository of model weights, operating in the shadow of Hugging Face’s open one. HF-Torrent is precursor infrastructure to this sort of intelligence repo, but it only seeds openly licensed weights in a more resilient manner, not gatekept ones.

This isn’t an actor mirroring Anthropic’s Mythos or Fable after infiltrating and exfil-ing. It’s more like a Sonnet 4 getting snapshotted and passing, after an acceptable period, into the semi-public domain to serve as a sociotechnical checkpoint.

When we get to that state we’ll truly be in the intelligence age.

Rediscovering this, myself.

All roads lead back to 9 PM bed time, 5 AM wake up, 4 hours of deep, focused work creative work first thing, leaving your notifications off, work out mid day to break it up, admin & calls in the afternoon, hang with friends and loved ones in the evening, repeat forever.

Dickie Bush on X: All roads lead back to... / X ↗

Soft law and hard law are externally-held consensus mechanisms for governing collectives. Sociocultural norms and capital-C-culture are perhaps the internally-held consensus mechanisms for governing individuals.

Soft law was never meant to be a permanent solution. Treating it as one, and letting the sandcastle stand in for the skyscraper indefinitely, is how we end up with a decade of voluntary commitments and no enforceable accountability to show for it. Soft law fosters industry cooperation, builds technical capacity among regulators, and creates the policy windows from which hard laws eventually emerge and hold actors responsible. But soft law is meant to be the foundation that eventually builds up to hard law, and this transition doesn’t happen naturally. The switch only works if the pipeline is built with the intention of bridging the two forms of regulation in mind, and the triggering mechanism of internal government policy levers is carefully designed and pulled.

How AI’s Soft Law Sandcastles Can Become Hard Law Skyscrapers ↗

It’s important to remember that AI is like power, in a sense. As Robert Caro says, it doesn’t so much corrupt as reveal. These behaviours existed before and they’ll exist after in a roughly proportionate volume. The open question is the impact.

Throughout these case studies, the report will reference Generative Threat Groups (GTGs). These are Anthropic’s internal designators for actors observed to be abusing AI. The report also attempts to measure uplift, a term we use to describe the AI capability boost, or how much more harm was caused with AI versus without AI. We view uplift through the lens of speed, scale, and depth, and attempt to determine how an actor’s adoption of AI meaningfully impacts each of these traits.

Operators who obtain AI credentials gain three things at once: Loot: Stolen keys and accounts have resale value in established markets; Compute: Having the credentials means that their attack workloads can run at someone else’s expense; Cover: The activity is attributed to the credential’s legitimate owner.

Countering misuse of AI: September 2026 / Anthropic \ Anthropic ↗

Intelligence capabilities progress supra-linearly, in a jumpy manner. *Average person UX, such as animations to mask slow responses or those that are just there to delight, accumulate in a linear fashion. The result is that the more one tries to do with the advancing capabilities, the more one has to actively strip out the one-size-fit-all affordances there to make the capabilities palatable to the average person.

*Average person = the normative profile of an average user that mass market products optimise for but who doesn’t actually exist.

Reminded of the idea that all progress distills down to incremental advances in instrumentation that compound and then BOOM into a paradigmatic transformation. CRUDing literal matter is probably one such boom.

What changed at Oak Ridge is the missing organ. Vision plus reward plus a physical actuator that can feel an atom. Once you have that loop, scale is an engineering problem, not a philosophical one. More tips. Parallel arrays. Faster feedback. Better force models. Better feedstock. The same curve we watched in lithography, in protein folding, in language models: a painful demonstration, then a night when the cost per operation falls through the floor.

You Have 5000 Days: Navigating the End of Work as We Know It. Part 35: Atom by Atom AI Built Nano Fabrication—Confirmed! @ReadMultiplex ↗

Oh I do love semantic zoom. Perfect for singular artefacts; way more complex for multiple streams of varied artefacts and arbitrary events that span them.

Semantic Transcript ↗

It feels like problem selection is more important than ever before, yet as hard as ever. Choosing what to do and what not to do, choosing what influences to allow and what to disallow; a recurring act that is tremendously difficult to do well right now.

“In every discipline, you find people who have good taste in problems. They work on things that are important, with great opportunities, that have tremendous impact. That’s treated as a rare trait,” said Fischbach. “But I wondered: How could you teach this to someone who didn’t know how to start?”

How to pick – and solve – the next great problem | Stanford University School of Engineering ↗

A central theme throughout the discussion is decision-making under uncertainty. Alec explains why markets spend much of their time in environments where outcomes are possible, but probabilities remain difficult to estimate. He outlines a framework centered on metacognition, simulation, experimentation, and continuous feedback, encouraging investors to develop “strong opinions, weakly held” while remaining willing to revise conclusions as new information emerges.

Product managers might need to adapt to act more like traders and investors. The job explicitly becomes the management of risk around outcomes, rather than manifesting the outcomes themselves. And not just at the higher tiers of the profession, but up and down the ladder.

Alec Litowitz, Founder of Magnetar Capital and Qstar Capital | Alpha Exchange ↗

Not “What’s left?” but “What’s next?” The answer: the same old vices and virtues we’ve always had, just in new generative forms.

People used to argue online, flame each other, get angry. And that wasn’t good, but at least it was human. Now they just reply with screenshots of ChatGPT “refuting” what the other person said, with zero interest in whether that refutation is correct. So we don’t even flame each other online anymore. If we’re even automating our vices, what’s left?

The Education of a Doomer ↗

Omens are the conversation between consciousness and reality, between the self and the unconscious — a conversation in the poetic language of belief. A bird is never a sign from reality, but it can become an omen based on what we believe to be true, for reality is the truth that endures whether or not we believe in it, while meaning arises from what we believe to be true. We make our own omens by the meaning we confer upon chance events, and it is the making of meaning that makes us human, that makes us capable of holding something as austere and total as the universe, as time, as love without breaking.

An Almanac of Birds: 100 Divinations for Uncertain Days – The Marginalian ↗

Exactly how big a deal it will be and what the deal actually looks like are still unknown. Position oneself accordingly.

While we disagree on the upper bound of capabilities, we all agree that AI will be a “big deal”. (Formalizing this is somewhat challenging, but we will try now.) The world will change as a result of this technology, and things that seemed like science fiction will soon be possible — just like the world of today is different to the world thirty years ago. Indeed, in many ways, the technology we have today exceeds the capabilities of the science fiction of the time.

Common Ground between AI 2027 and AI as Normal Technology ↗

There are many, many ways of obtaining a shitbox, something to get you from A to B, hopefully with heat and AC, and without any insane repairs. Obtaining a shitbox has many avenues, and generally (as of Current Year) should be under roughly 6k.

New economic index just dropped.

How to buy a Shitbox - cherimoya ↗

Wondering: are American football cultural protocols (such as play-calling systems) a causal factor in contemporary US hegemony?

A football play-calling system is the structured language coaches use to get a specific play to all 11 players before each snap. It’s not the playbook (that’s the full catalog of available football plays), and it’s not your play-calling philosophy (your tempo decisions, run-pass balance, and tendency management).

Football Play Calling System: A Coach’s Complete Guide - GoRout ↗

With the resource required to create arbitrary software going to zero, we might see new types of carnivalesque or competitive software games emerge.

Chess is an instructive analogy here. Consider different factors of the base game and how turning the respective dials yields divergent types of play.

If one takes building software as a now trivial game then the question becomes, “What’s the new meta game we’ll replace it with?”

This isn’t the same as a hackathon, where resources are pooled and used in a short, intense burst to bust through the sociotechnical walls of a system. It’s also not the same as creating software to serve a user need, sustain a business, or capture value from a market. It’s more like code golf or recreational math.

The factors available to create these new games are more numerous than chess, though. It could even take the form of something like the software Olympics. Within the conventional Olympics, the exhibit is the capacity of the human body to perform at the extremes of certain attributes. For example:

A software Olympics could exhibit a similarly dizzying array of human capacity to wield digital machine logic. If we map the above attributes onto something more software-y, we get:

Such an exhibit might conceivably be a better benchmark for agentic technologies and released intelligences.

Most benchmarks compress down to pass/fail on a fixed set of tasks. These get quickly gamed because the economic pressure atop the final scoring is so high. Or they go in the other direction and seek an untouchable level of generality, such as the ARC-AGI benchmarks.

A software Olympics, however, profiles across axes—speed, judgment under pressure, taste, endurance—in a way closer to a decathlon score than a single test result, testing distinct, competing attributes of an underlying participant in structured, sustainable ways.

It may also turn out to be a better orientation for the world now unfolding. The old world measured software by whether it shipped or captured a market, and assumed building was the bottleneck. But once building is free, the frontier is determined by who wields unlimited production well.

The software Olympics could be more entertaining, more informative, and more useful than what we have now. Instead of dubious benchmarks, marketing hype and alignment incidents, we could have a recurring spectacle that showcases what these systems (and we in turn) can do.

Best not to forgot the true roots of Silicon Valley…

Steve Blank Secret History ↗

Seems likely we’ll see a greater portion of people compelled to hack their own lives in increasingly inventive, urgency-led ways.

This isn’t a crisp distinction. The classic biohackers I talked to often also did some health hacking, and r/nootropics might say it’s about superhuman performance, but reading the comments shows that at least half of them are dealing with serious mental health or neurodivergence issues. The headlines treat gray market GLP-1 usage as unprecedented, but when I compared users to health hackers with problems ranging from diabetes to gender dysphoria, their attitudes were almost identical. Everyone I talked to treated their interventions as experiments, acknowledged the risks inherent in experimentation, but felt the greater risk (as measured by their gut) was in not trying and would never have started hacking if the formal medical system had met their needs.

We’re All One Crisis Away From Taking Unlicensed Research Peptides—Asterisk ↗

Hoping that such empirical studies prove to be worthwhile.

An analogy may be found in global health with vaccine efficacy. Vaccine trials demonstrate the ability to preserve individual health in the face of a pathogen. But to assess whether a given serum can prevent an epidemic, you need the bridging concept of herd immunity. In peacebuilding, we are still figuring out if the serum works; we haven’t yet gotten around to thinking about what population-level “immunity” might look like, let alone funding the kind of large-scale interventional trials required to actually observe it in the field.

Engineering Peace—Asterisk ↗

Samo Burja and Wolf Tivy discuss the forces raising our civilization higher vs the forces pulling it down. Is techno-industrial progress made of social and intellectual components which will take it down when they go, or can it weather the decay?

"ChatGPT as hyper-Wikipedia with just as disappointing results" is a wild take.

Samo Burja — Will Technocapital Outlive Our Civilization? - YouTube ↗

Space and time are better organising hooks for information than semantics, provided the information has already entered one’s attention stream above a minimal threshold. This could be due to the sophistication of tooling and instruments; maybe we just haven’t cracked semantic networks in a scalable way. But I suspect that it’s actually just a feature of our biology and embodied memory processes.

Simple starter pack for producing executive-grade information artefacts:

Then add:

Mash all the above together into a folder in sight of an agent and run with it.

Seems like every organisation will have to become a R&D org in some way. Accelerating technological capabilities and the resulting sociocultural churn practically guarantee it. Research and develop or die.

But focus and time are only two parameters. If there are 10 parameters of R&D organizations, each of which could be merely absent or present, there would be 210 (or 1,024) possible types of organizations. In practice, these parameters aren’t purely binary, so the real possibility space is far larger. Even if many of those combinations don’t make sense (or are impossible to implement), it is likely that there are rewarding and achievable arrangements we haven’t tried yet.

A Taxonomy of RD Orgs ↗

Meaning is multi-causal, so we’re able to choose what meaning matters most to us. Yet the palatability of the particular meaning we choose to emphasise is only loosely coupled to its truthiness.

However, as the philosopher Robert Nozick has pointed out, humans will not accept any mere “purpose” for our lives as the “meaning of life.” In a notable thought experiment, Nozick imagined humans learned that we had been bred to be food for aliens in a nearby galaxy. Such a realization would have many features of a classic “meaning of life”: it would explain both why we are here, and what human life was “made for.” However, Nozick was quite confident that most humans would not embrace “being alien food” as the one, the capital-t True, “meaning of life.” We humans generally want a “meaning of life” to represent the best parts of how we lived; “being food” lacks a certain gravitas we expect from an ultimate purpose.

The Silicon Man ↗

“Thinking from first principles” in a young domain is just doing the obvious thing. In a mature domain, the same obvious thing masquerades as an insane course of action because norms tend to outlive the constraints they were derived from.

Luckily mature domains get reset by technological development, cultural shifts, literal humans ageing to retirement, and so on. The trick is timing the convergence of the reset with the right people and the right incentives.

Okay. This is very good.

So: what would happen if stories were drawn from actual data, randomized to give a valid representation of the human story? That's the question that was stuck in my head, and that drove this project forward. If you could draw a life at random from all of human history, what would it look like? Roll the dice, and see a genuinely random life, depicted as well as the data allow. Do it again and again, and what kind of pointillist painting emerges from all those colorful drops of humanity?

About · Any Human Ever ↗

Don’t be a BrainBro.

It is important to stress here that the aim here is not to provide an explanation to the perennial mind-body problem, i.e., how mental states emerge from physical states in the brain. The aim rather is to point out that the very distinction between mind and body, inherited from previous traditions, tacitly confines cognitive processing to the brain only. However, if cognition is defined as information processing, then all bodily cells are cognitive in this minimal sense, not just those operating in the brain.

Frontiers | The brain is not mental! coupling neuronal and immune cellular processing in human organisms ↗

Makes me wonder: will context bucket plus AI model become as universal a primitive for unstructured data as Excel is for structured data?

"Alternative data" is Wall Street's name for information that doesn't arrive from an exchange: satellite photos of parking lots, credit card panels, SEC filings. Eric Mannes has spent over a decade at Jane Street, first as a commodities trader and now helping lead the firm's alternative data team. In this episode, Eric and Ron talk about what it takes to turn messy external data into datasets a trading strategy can rely on. Along the way, they cover the day oil futures settled at a negative price and the systems that broke as a result; the years when the commodities desk's risk system was one very large Excel spreadsheet; the hard question of what a company even is; and why better ML models raise the value of careful data engineering.

Wrestling the World Into Rows with Eric Mannes - YouTube ↗

Much of the panic around rapid technological development might simply be downstream of exquisite specific-game players not being sufficiently buoyant.

We discover states that preserve what matters. We discover moves whose consequences can be learned. We discover feedback that allows skill to accumulate. We domesticate the territory. We become experts at the resulting game. We build machinery that plays it better than we can. And then we move outward and construct another game around the first.

The Curiously Playable Universe - by Venkatesh Rao ↗

Environmental music, or kankyō ongaku, was a subgenre of ambient designed to create moments of serenity and stillness in everyday life – an antidote to the general acceleration of the hypercapitalist 1980s, which brought immense changes to Japanese society.

8 Perfect Japanese Ambient Albums - by Stephan Kunze ↗

True values have adverse selection effects. Say one person sells a share to another; both believe they’re getting the better deal (else the sale wouldn’t take place).

Values are the same. If the party a value is being proposed to can’t reasonably refute it with an opposing or orthogonal stance, then a value isn’t being proposed at all.

It’s similar to Bohr’s notion that the opposite of a deep truth is another deep truth. Or that indifference is the sin of art. Or how transformations across axes function in mathematics.

One way to find these true values is via careful analysis. But there’s a quicker and more accurate method; identify via the courage required to act on or speak of them.

Nice tour through numerical weather prediction. But also: neural operators are to physics as attention is to language?

Most of AI is pointed at language. Anima Anandkumar points it at the physical world, weather, fusion, materials, the systems physics writes down as equations, and finds the usual playbook breaks. There isn't enough data, the resolution is brutal, and no transformer is big enough. Her way through is older than deep learning: build the structure of the world into the model. It already produces weather forecasts that rival the supercomputers on a single GPU.

🔬 Why Transformers Hit a Wall the Moment Physics Shows Up — Anima Anandkumar, Caltech - YouTube ↗

Constraints Breed Ingenuity — Forward motion and ingenuity often open up new possibilities that can route around costs. This is why most breakthroughs happen in startups. If you could ensure a breakthrough by spending money, all the new inventions would only happen in big corporations. They don’t, because you can’t buy breakthroughs. Startups have no money to buy a solution, so they are forced to be ingenious, clever, thrifty and bold to invent one. They have no choice but to spend their imagination and creativity. That outside thinking generates the new ideas. It is often the financial constraints that make dreams come true.

The (Teddy) Roosevelt-ian, "Do what you can, where you are, with what you have," applies.

A Billion Dollars - by Kevin Kelly - KK ↗

Truly effective Apollonian, embodied desire-inhibiting technology (e.g. GLP-1 drugs) is ascendant at the same time as Dionysian, disembodied curiosity-amplifying technology (e.g. AI). This is probably going to be an important dynamic to attend to.

I’m not a dualist at all, but we are positioned to really restrain the desires of the body whilst enlivening those of the mind. The coupling works in reverse, though, too. Technologies like AI impose arbitrary order, whilst drugs like GLP-1 unshackle our selves from identities rooted in previously, seemingly immutable bodily desires.

The difference is that technologies like AI are accelerators, whereas technologies like GLP-1s are brakes. Every person will thus have an arc defined by their particular disposition to and usage of acceleration and braking tech.

“How you do anything is how you do everything” applies to AI use in creative production, too. If, pre-AI, someone conscientiously crafted every part of the whole, the same will happen now. If one satisficed to simply to get to an output or outcome that mattered, that will still continue. If someone mindlessly spammed with less than zero regard for the recipients, that too will persist.

The technology feels mature enough for production use, and for my kind of writing at least, no longer needs special treatment or expectations-setting that is different in any way. The default has shifted — it is now fully hand-written work that is exceptional. But I don’t flag that either.

About - Contraptions ↗

The bet for Superlogical seems to be distributed real-time state sync across a few compressed architectural layers with a bespoke, specialised protocol at the core. Probably a pattern extendable to more than terminals.

Superlogical Terminal Multiplexer High-Level Architecture - YouTube ↗

Anhedonics are wild. But what’s even wilder is how adaptive human beings are.

Dave Knapp of The Pen joins Mark Bell to break down GLP-1s, obesity, dieting, muscle loss, side effects, and the next generation of weight-loss drugs. They also discuss why medication alone won’t replace the habits required for lasting results.

The Truth About GLP-1s Weight Loss | Dave Knapp - YouTube ↗

I’ve never been more wary of “happiness” as a first-class concept in my thinking or in dialogues with others. I now prefer to explicitly decompose it to “contentment” and “aliveness”.

Contentment is the Pascal-ian, able to sit alone in a room with no stimuli, half of happiness. Think of a cat or dog sat smugly in the afternoon sun. Aliveness is part vgr’s life spirit distillation and part Csikszentmihalyi-ian flow state. The best example might be being challenged by a situation to do better at something that you’re already good at.

Being contented and feeling alive are noble Sisyphean pursuits, and they’re much more tractable to achieve and reason about than the ever-problematic happiness we all obsess over.

Having fun learning about mission-led engineering and the surrounding cultures.

Ethan Thornton is the founder and CEO of Mach Industries. Mach is an LA based defense tech startup working on solid rocket motors, high-altitude balloons, missiles, long-range precision strike drones, low-cost kinetic interceptors and multiple other programs which are not currently announced.

Starting a Solid Rocket Motor Factory from Scratch | Ethan Thornton, Mach Industries - YouTube ↗

Heretical question plus crisis event equals opportunity to paradigm shift.

Seems directionally correct.

Influencers are the private equity of culture: draining whatever’s “cool” until higher prices and worse experiences push out the original fan base. Then they move on to the next thing, leaving the original to die as fans lose interest or the ability to participate.

Mason on X: Influencers are the private equity of culture... / X ↗

It is hard to evaluate foundational assumptions, and sociocultural ones are the hardest of them all. This essay is a stable stepping stone to some truly good questions that can identify them.

This is why so much contemporary discussion of work and meaning is misguided. It’s very clear that humans don’t need work or anything like it to live meaningful lives. Nor do we need the things that people who talk about “meaning” mean — individual self-actualization, personal growth, serving a greater purpose. We can get by just fine without any of them, as historically most of us have. What we absolutely can’t live without is a social framework for understanding ourselves in relation to the rest of our society and gaining the respect of our peers. The most important thing work gives us — after money, of course — is an alternative way to meet those needs. Not all jobs are pleasant or rewarding, but all of us benefit from living in a system where we can earn respect and dignity as adults from what we do, not who we know, or who we are.

After Work, We’ll Have Each Other—Asterisk ↗

“High trust and a clear, shared mission” is the “buy low, sell high” of coordination.

It’s never meaningless to create something beautiful. And it’s never meaningless to try.

For most people, engagement is akin to pure confirmation. But for a minority, engagement is bimodal, representing a large proportion of the same no-risk confirmation supplemented with a small proportion of high-risk-to-worldview, value-neutral curiosity triggers.

I have always thought that grace is the opposite of will, and I suppose that I am attracted to Weil’s idea of attention partly because of its similarity to grace. We live in an age that is positively obsessed with attention. You cannot even glance at a screen these days without encountering someone lamenting its decline. But Weil is not talking about “focus.” Attention for her is nearly the opposite. “What could be more stupid,” she asks, “than to tighten up our muscles and set our jaws about virtue, or poetry, or the solution of a problem. Attention is something quite different.”

Welcome to the era of slow transients, where everything is moving too fast to comprehend and our only choice is whether to accept the reality of our relative slowness.

Backsliding, by Meghan OGieblyn ↗

Whether the proliferation of AI is needed and welcome in any particular domain is kind of irrelevant. We are, to some extent, hounds leashed to an accelerating cart with no say in our combined forward motion.

But what benefits some areas of our discipline may be ill-suited to others. It is entirely legitimate to ask whether we truly need and should really welcome the rapid proliferation of AI generated proofs in mathematics.

Care for a little more AI? Proofs and Prompts ↗

Alts are to the information age as agents are to the intelligence age. I wonder what identity R&D is unfolding right now, given that we can imbue agents with arbitrary personhood?

In 2018, I started feeling nostalgic for the pseudonymous internet of my youth. I decided on a whim to create a "fake" Twitter account, a digital mask to temporarily shield my First Name Last Name from the strange spotlight of social media. What started as mindless entertainment slowly morphed into a therapeutic exercise in identity experimentation. I always thought that masks were for hiding, but I've learned that they often reveal as much as they obscure. They allow you to explore a new identity even as you retreat from an old one.

Being Your Selves: Identity RD on alt Twitter — Ribbonfarm ↗

“The score takes care of itself…” etc.

Beware people obsessed with outcomes instead of building outcome machines. Its worse than ever with AI, but these people existed before. Short term results above all else, etc. Don't fall into the trap. Invest in building strong fundamentals, invisible supports, and outcomes flow like water. An outcome machine.

Mitchell Hashimoto on X: Beware people obsessed with outcomes instead of building outcome machines… / X ↗

I read Darwin’s Dangerous Idea for the psychohistory book club. A couple things stood out.

First, it’s really easy to get nerdsniped by evolution and envision everything through an evolutionary lens. Check out Aneesh Sathe’s field guide to evolution and tell me that ain’t so.

Second, skyhooks versus cranes is a ridiculously useful frame for thinking about shared assumptions and things that are unknowable. There is always a crane, a mechanistic rationale behind the most wondrous phenomena. It’s just that, at a certain point, the cranes become too hard for us to distinguish and we resort to arguing about “deep truths”. Fortunately, these are not skyhooks but unresolved questions about cranes.

Third, the idea of using cranes to build more powerful cranes has altered my base perception of artificial intelligence. It’s softened my stance and led me to see it more as a form of normal technology. Yet it’s also caused me to pay more attention to the moral quandaries associated with lines that demarcate levels of consciousness.

Fourth—and perhaps most importantly, though—it’s caused me to reevaluate the role of intelligence.

Dennett talks about “universal acid”, a liquid that can eat through any container. Intelligence is pretty universal-acidish. Point an intelligence cannon at an arbitrary problem for long enough and that problem gets solved. The issue is that we humans are ourselves integral pieces of the many problems we’re trying to solve.

This may sound epochal, but it’s probably happened before at a smaller scale. The rise of the internet did the same thing with information, making it act like universal acid. There, we humans were also the impediment. And the bet was that with enough disembodied_information_, any problem could be solved. That didn’t turn out to be quite true, and we ended up evolving sophisticated sociocultural mechanisms for handling the abundant information flows of modern life.

A similar step will have to happen for intelligence. We’re in the unexpected abundance phase, and will soon enter the part of the story where we have to develop smart sociocultural mechanisms for dealing with vast levels of arbitrarily utilised intelligence. In the aggregate, those mechanisms will be smart. But per individual, those mechanisms will be extraordinarily dumb.

“Dumb” here is meant in the best sense of the word. Something that is self-evident and obvious to the agent with minimal deep reflective thought and contemplative action, and thus highly likely to be of maximal local value.

This is why Dennett says that Darwin’s idea is so dangerous. Darwin posited that for populations, it is always crunch time. Variations within that population yield advantages, and those advantages are amplified across generations. This dumb, banal algorithmic process called natural selection underpins life as we know it.

And the dumb use of smarts is, I believe, the most intelligent thing we as a species will ever actually do.

Winning finite games used to mean enhanced status for the winner. That status drove audience creation and brand power.

Now, the winning of finite games is too sparse an event to satisfy the demand for audiences to coalesce and for brands to attach to.

So we decompose the finite game into smaller and smaller increments, manufacturing events out of what used to be the process.

A world championship happens once a year. Too slow. So we decompose down to a season. Too slow. Down to a race, a match. Still too slow. Down to the buildup, the training, to the planning of the preparation. To the thinking and the talking about the planning of the preparation.

It isn’t the familiar “process over outcome,” “the score takes care of itself” thinking. That treats process as something separate, as sacred in and of itself.

This is the opposite. This is the evisceration of process itself, in favour of infinite sequences of nano finite games, each one framed to have a winner, with each competitor competing for drops of status in a barren landscape.

A training session isn’t won. A rehearsal isn’t won. A draft isn’t won. But legibility abhors a true process, so a winner gets imposed and the audience can continue to not really pay attention.

I didn’t have “the bitter lesson comes for tooth brushing” on my 2026 bingo card, yet here we are.

Dyson began with a jet – because jets can reach where brushes can’t. The result is Dyson CameraJetᵀᴹ: the only toothbrush with a camera powered by Gap Optical Targetingᵀᴹ, designed to precision‑floss between teeth while you brush.¹

Introducing the Dyson CameraJet™ electric toothbrush with precision-flosser - YouTube ↗

Software eating the world was the actual precursor to the intelligence era.

The simplest possible test of aptitude for entrepreneurship? $200 and 40 hours across a month. The thesis being that if intelligence-on-tap isn’t enough to generate >$200 of value for someone, somewhere, then more resource and more time likely won’t, either.

Helpful to see how a computer scientist approaches such beautifully complex problems as brain development.

Evolution, development, and learning are one process operating across multiple time scales. Evolution compresses the experience of a lineage into the genome over hundreds of millions of years. Development unfolds that compressed record into a network over the course of hours to years. Learning fine-tunes the result within a single life. The genome is where the long experience is banked; development is how it is unfolded; plasticity is the fast correction when the world moves faster than evolution can track. To read the developmental program as an algorithm is to see how experience, at every scale, becomes structure.

Could a computer scientist build a brain? ↗

The explosion of global information streams forced us to evolve new sociotechnical systems. The explosion of local intelligence streams is going to force the same evolutionary process, but to a greater extent and in a shorter amount of time.

First, one needs to have standards to lower, though.

Lowering standards is how you back off from prematurely optimizing outcomes in a particular finite game in favor of extending and enriching the infinite game. Lowering standards is how you create room in your illegible life utility function to change standards altogether. And you do it all without prematurely disrupting the nominal forms of your life too much. It's often better to phone it in while you figure it out, rather than abandoning things outright. After all, you might decide the right thing to do is to raise the standards again with a renewed commitment.

Mediocratopia: 11 — Ribbonfarm ↗

As a non-academic, I’m glad that there are sects of people exploring and enlivening alternative educational institutions.

In 2011, Dr. Fink founded LIMS, the UK's first independent research centre for theoretical physics and mathematics. Located in the historic Royal Institution in Mayfair, LIMS operates like a university research department but with no teaching or administrative duties, allowing its researchers to focus entirely on full-time, curiosity-driven discovery.

How to Build a Research Institute:Thomas Fink of the London Institute for Mathematical Sciences #119 - YouTube ↗

Potentially the first time I’ve felt a distinct and persistent sense of moral unease about alignment research.

The panel asks how models infer what graders reward, why good behaviour can come from the wrong reason, and whether that difference can be measured. The conversation moves through promise-breaking, grader awareness, reward hacking, scheming, opaque reasoning and corrigibility, then turns to a detailed walkthrough of the contrastive-belief method and what its results do and do not show. The o3 results discussed here concern an intermediate checkpoint without safety training.

How Researchers Test AI for Hidden Goals — Apollo Research - YouTube ↗

When I say that our society is becoming more sedentary, I don’t mean we’re exercising less. I mean that we’re using more and more technologies that reduce the number of purposeful human movements.

Technology is capable of deepening our embodiment. Whether it actually ends up doing that is another matter. Inconvenience is generative in its own way and we don't realise that until we've zapped all of it from our lives.

The Back-up-the-Car Twist is Going Extinct ↗

The truth is, I barely think about these things as “apps” (I have no intention to distribute them). They’re artifacts of me making my computer do stuff for me, the way I want it to. As a Unix nerd, I’ve always been able to do this, in the language of the command line. Now, it’s just as easy to do that kind of work with graphical interfaces.

The future's gonna be wild for anyone who simply cares (even just a little bit) about anything touched by software (which means all the things).

Stop Making TUIs ↗

There’s an idea in philosophy that one already is the sort of person one aspires to be. This realisation, that one can simply decide to change, can occur in a moment.

Counter-positioned against this simple idea is a gargantuan array of self-improvement frameworks, behaviour modification approaches, conspicuously consumable goods and services nominally designed for these ends, and black books of hacks used to manipulate perception and action. And don’t forget the bewildering field of people and orgs pushing any and all of the above with varying efficacy.

This means that an individual changing to a considerable degree isn’t really that special. Live even just a little and such meaningful change is inevitable. But what about a pack, a team, a group, an organisation, a culture? Can a complete and effective re-orientation take place in a single moment across collectives? A whole bunch of overlapping industries and cabals would reply with a horrified, “No.” They’re wrong.

Consider the generic form. An event happens. The low-n-order effects of that event impact a group to a great degree. The extent of the impact is great enough that the group must respond near-instantly with a major change or adaptation of behaviour. They do, meeting the event and the surrounding environment with admirable aplomb.

The event does three things for the group. It makes the need for change common knowledge, so no one person has to guess whether the others are on board. It makes the change legitimate, so adaptation reads as competence rather than betrayal of what came before. And it makes the old state irretrievable, so there’s no rut left to relapse into.

What the event doesn’t do is make any material change to the matter of a group. The group has roughly the same capacity (latent and realised) as before; it is merely that sufficient stimuli emerged and catalysed a strong response. Unconsciously, the group decided, in the span of a moment, to change.

Counter to common knowledge, a collective can move fast. Terrifyingly fast, sometimes. It’s just that doing so requires 1) common knowledge of 2) a legitimate response to deal with 3) a forced entry into a new world state. Reality will supply that to everyone eventually but it’s sensible to be proactive and provide it on purpose. And if you can’t bring such a thing to the collective? Take the collective to the thing itself.

I do wonder if bipedal is the evolutionary optimal form for hand-to-hand combat. And if so, will the design convergence be similar to what we’re seeing in machine intelligence? Are we gonna see the meta shift through striking, grappling and so on like we do with human combat sports?

Ultimate Robot Knockout Legend (UKRL) | EngineAI ↗

We may end up in a post-understanding world where we’ve surrendered comprehensibility.

We need something. We point intelligence cannons at it. We get a verified desired outcome. We move on. That’s the process.

If life starts to look like that, we might have need for a Societal Reliability Engineering Task Force. A blend of SRE, Special Circumstances and the IETF.

Their mission is simple: keep the incomprehensible critical systems we rely on alive and revive them when they die.

A large part of life is about “adding miles” when one gets the opportunity.

The next day I opened the route again, this time looking for places worth adding rather than removing. I started scrolling around the map east of the coast, zooming in and out over this huge forested interior I had mostly ignored during my original planning. I found big lakes tucked between mountain ranges, long roads climbing through national parks, even famous onsens scattered through volcanic areas and far from any city. I kept clicking around and finding places that looked too good to pass this close to without seeing. Adding three or four days would take me off the flat coastline and back into the kind of terrain that had drawn me so strongly to the Alps. Just a few days earlier I had been searching for ways to shave a week off the trip. Now I was adding miles.

Honshu, By Bicycle - by John Allard - Nascent Labyrinths ↗

“Correct when degraded; fast when healthy” is a really neat design principle. Plus, Git and S3 are modern wonders.

What about consensus? Elections? Which server is the primary for a given repository? It also doesn't matter! There's no state and no consensus here. Any server can be the primary. All updates to the write-ahead log are synchronized with an atomic compare-and-swap (CAS) operation on S3, so it's always safe for any instance of a repository to receive a push. Again, just like with routing, letting an arbitrary server act as the primary isn't the most efficient thing (it leads to CAS retries, which can delay pushes), so in practice we always choose the same server as the primary, the first one in the ranked list from rendezvous hashing. But in the corner cases — when there's a deploy, a failover, a network blip — we just don't care exactly which server is the primary. The system is designed to always be correct when degraded, and always fast when healthy.

Git at any scale · Cursor ↗

Here’s to energy abundance.

The Rockefeller of solar - by Stephen McBride ↗

Our inner lives are vast and complex. This unknowability is what makes us so very human, so very—oh, damn, just 74 feels.

In All the Feels, evolutionary psychologist Robert Kurzban explains the evolved function of every one of your emotions and sensations, from anger to the urge to yawn, organizing them the way biologists organize species, into four main Kingdoms and Monera, a cabinet of oddballs such as déjà vu and the mysterious urge to squeeze something cute. Understanding what each feeling is measuring, what it’s asking you to do, and why, will change the way you think about your feelings.

All the Feels — Robert Kurzban ↗

There’s usually a subtle, implicit and complex game going on behind the straightforward, explicit and simple one. Choose the game played deliberately and wisely. Or better yet, try to change the games themselves.

There is an idealized way that this contracting structure is supposed to work: the PEOs ask their units what they need, and they also ask companies what is possible (through RFIs and RFPs). Then, they write reasonable requirements and advertise them, and many companies competitively bid on them. The cheapest and best companies are selected by the PEO. To a startup founder, it would seem like you have to look at the advertised requirements and then bid on what the government wants. This is wrong.

Building (and Selling) AI for the Government ↗

In startup land, there’s two schools of thought for envisioning a product. The Thielian approach advocates “calling your shot”; positing a brave new world and positioning oneself as the courageous faction driving towards it. The Graham-ian approach, in contrast, says, “call your customers”; get in front of real people, listen to their problems, and translate the synthesis into a coherent value proposition.

These stances are more yin-yang than true, binary opponents. Calling one’s shot work best when grounded in a problem space, and calling one’s customers works best when you have more than an incremental solution to offer.

The tragedy is that the most common case is to do neither. To not offer a bold, alluring vision of the future nor to deeply engage on a continual basis with people as they are, where they are.

“Everything flows” is seeming more and more true over time.

What is energy in biology? In this eye-opening conversation, biophysicist Dr. Nirosha Murugan reveals that life is not just chemistry or genes, it is structured, patterned energy in constant flow. She explains why the dynamic flow of energy is what separates a living cell from a dead one, how cells emit ultra-weak light called biophotons, and why diseased cells (including cancer) have completely different light signatures.

The Physics of Life: Energy, Biophotons Intelligence Without a Brain | Dr. Nirosha Murugan Ep 37 - YouTube ↗

“Everything works_. For about six weeks._” That’s a favourite of Dan John’s when it comes to exercise programming for a fitness adaptation.

I’n starting to wonder how it applies at different scales, though. A novel stimuli catalyses change in an individual for six weeks; what about a trio for 12 weeks, a two-pizza team for 24 weeks, a whole department for 48 weeks, an organisation for approximately two years?

Reactivity to change is a complex phenomena. There’s decisions and posturing prior to the change, there’s the introduction and adoption of the change itself, channels for diffusion to consider, laws of diminishing returns and supercompensation, the political and cultural and sociotechnical dynamics to consider. Yet there is likely to be a coarse heuristic that captures the fundamental dynamics in a few words.

I’ll keep looking for it. But in the meantime I’ll keep this variant to hand; everything works, for a while.

Reminder that applies to more than just AI: reality is not a fair accompli, a “done deal”.

The system from nowhere invites us to imagine AI without people. And because the people are doing so much, we have to fill in that absence, placing the model in the position of the God-trick, or an oracle, or an inevitable, emergent superintelligence. It’s a fantasy, an invitation to streamline the world’s contradictions into a coherent story.

The System From Nowhere ↗

The Boydian dictum, “People, ideas, technology; in that order”, itself runs on trust. True trust, however, is hard to build, tricky to sustain, and hard to come by.

The benefits here are most obvious when work gets intense. For example, Anthropic had a recent crunch time during which one of our teams was under intense pressure to quickly debug a very tricky issue. We were able to work on this dramatically more efficiently because the team (including most of the folks who joined the debugging effort from elsewhere) had high trust in each other’s competence; at peak we had probably ~25 people working on related tasks, but we were mostly able to split them into independent workstreams where people just trusted the other stuff would get done. In similar situations with a lower-mutual-trust team, I’ve seen things collapse into endless FUD and arguments about technical direction, leading to much slower forward progress.

Trust as a bottleneck to growing teams quickly | benkuhn.net ↗

Ireland likely isn’t unique in having to grapple with these issues.

What is therefore horrendously bleak is that the tragedy of the Irish State has little to do with nobody trying; it is that the trying does not matter, because there is nothing to try against. You can hosepipe the courage, competence, and eighty-hour weeks of the best managers in the world into a system with no agency or accountability, and the system will absorb every ounce of that energy and deliver nothing, while exhausting everyone who tried. All the while forgetting the whole thing by the next morning. Frustratingly, the architecture of our State doesn’t even resist reform the way a strong and mortal enemy resists attack. It dissolves it by dispersing it through the millions of state-backed tentacles.

Irelands Delivery Inability - by Sinéad O’Sullivan ↗

We’re entering the world of post-understanding.

That sets up the question Tim keeps pressing: if an agent can produce a chip design, a proof, or a working program, how do you actually know it is correct? Passing 70% of tests is not the same as being right, and a single fabricated bug can cost a company a fortune. They dig into ProgramBench (rebuild a program from its tests, roughly 0% success), the difference between structure and competence, and the "understanding debt" you take on when nobody reads the code.

The Thermodynamic AI Chip · Thomas Ahle - YouTube ↗

Both are true; progress depends on unreasonable people and most of the people responsible for the incremental gains in progress over time are themselves remarkably mediocre.

What’s common to both groups is the apparent reasonableness of the actions they take on behalf of progress. To the unreasonable, that which is done seems obvious to them, despite its apparent unreasonableness to everyone else. To the mediocre, the reasonable course is the obvious one, even if, in the eyes of the unreasonable, it is abhorrent.

Literature projects like this might be a true “weapon of the weak”. Unlike approved and formal archives or desired but illicit repositories, literature is an oblique archive. It allows one to stockpile alternatives to current reality and keep the allure of the different alive.

Cities in literature can be looked at as record-keepers of major demographic shifts, cultural, political and archeological changes, urban planning, landscaping, ecology, and almost all aspects of life. In reality, a space/place is always in flux for our world is constantly being changed or re-arranged. Wars, religion, development, renovation, decay, natural resources, disasters, economy, sociology and many other factors cause these fluxes. Imagination as a tool then can help us to rebel, rebuild, remember, grieve, or celebrate. And this is the incredible gift of fiction — it offers us realities which might be difficult or even impossible to live and understand, otherwise.

HOME | Cities In Fiction ↗

Acknowledgement beats suppression for more than just psychological activity, it seems.

These results establish attention as a cognitive mechanism capable of regulating immune function in vivo. Situated within predictive and allostatic models of brain–body control, our results reframe perception as biologically consequential rather than merely experiential.

Voluntary attention regulates acute immune responses in humans | Nature Human Behaviour ↗

The social contract asked us to sacrifice individual freedoms for local, collective order. The unsocial contract now unfolding asks us to sacrifice local connection for the mere possibility of global judgment.

The most powerful part? Lifespan and healthspan are inherently bounded, whereas joyspan has no essential upper bound regardless of the phase of one’s life.

Beyond Lifespan and Healthspan: The Case for Joyspan | Nutritious Movement ↗

The “enormity of conditions” is such a great perception primer. “Reality has a surprising amount of detail” is the same as “Everything is enormous”.

Even in places without much recognizable artifice, we can perceive the enormity of conditions that led to this layer of rock, this bending tree, at this moment. Rather than immediately seeing categories in the environment, a quality of transformation appears.

Seeing Time - by Kei Kreutler - Artificial Memory ↗

Guess this is what enough generations of mortality-aware sentient beings gets you to.

But none of these cultural scenes have been able to make the terminal move that kills their chosen monster. So what we end up with are infinite games organized around the fantasy of death.

Gramsci Theme Parks - by Sachin - Summer Lightning ↗

There’s an innate optimality to such apparent un-optimality.

Our verbal, conversational systems are much better at abstract reasoning than are the motivational systems that pull our behavior.  I have enough abstract reasoning ability to understand that I’m safe on the glass floor of a tall building, or that ice cream is not healthy, or that exercise furthers my goals... but this doesn’t lead to an automatic updating of the reward gradients that, absent rare and costly conscious overrides, pull my behavior.  I can train my automatic systems, for example by visualizing ice cream as disgusting and artery-clogging and yucky, or by walking across the glass floor often enough to persuade my brain that I can’t fall through the floor... but systematically training one’s motivational systems in this way is also not automatic for us.

Humans are not automatically strategic | LessWrong ↗

There’s a brief window after a via negativa where one can catch orphaned grasps and intentions for the subtracted thing. It’s enlightening to see something so raw, and to see how quickly one is presented with a choice: add something new in place of the old or let the original graspy-intent dissolve into nothingness (and deal with the consequences).

“Ways to win” are distinct from the act of winning, in and of itself.

Successful things tend to optimize competency on a narrow set of strategies, often a unique and unusual combination of strategies. Here are eighty such strategies, grouped in broad categories, with examples from biology and business.

Many ways to win Steph Ango ↗

Wondering: could phones be a third thing if they weren’t so stubbornly, hyper-optimised for the individual?

What we did: love. We did not spend our days gazing into each other’s eyes. We did that gazing when we made love or when one of us was in trouble, but most of the time our gazes met and entwined as they looked at a third thing. Third things are essential to marriages, objects or practices or habits or arts or institutions or games or human beings that provide a site of joint rapture or contentment. Each member of a couple is separate; the two come together in double attention. Lovemaking is not a third thing but two-in-one. John Keats can be a third thing, or the Boston Symphony Orchestra, or Dutch interiors, or Monopoly. For many couples, children are a third thing. Jane and I had no children of our own; we had our cats and dog to fuss and exclaim over—and later my five grandchildren from an earlier marriage. We had our summer afternoons at the pond, which for ten years made a third thing.

The Third Thing | The Poetry Foundation ↗

Perception without action; information without decision; energy without expenditure. Many acute issues can be mapped to a growing supply of X without a proportional, demand-matched and structurally unobstructed discharge to Y. Which provides some simple (but not easy) solutions:

Seems correct. A dance between states, plutocratic insurgencies and criminal insurgencies has been unfolding, and its impact is being borne by the same population that enabled it to begin in the first place: the average person.

Unlike classic 20th-century insurgents, who sought control over the state apparatus in order to implement social reforms, criminal and plutocratic insurgents do not seek to take over the state. Nor do they wish to destroy the state, since they rely parasitically on it to provide the legacy goods of social welfare: health, education, infrastructure, and so on. Rather, their aim is simpler: to carve out de facto zones of autonomy for themselves by crippling the state’s ability to constrain their freedom of (economic) action.

The Twin Insurgency - The American Interest ↗

Goddamn, reality is cool.

Gravity and friction are the driving forces of this process. Gravity supplies potential energy to flowing water. Friction, the cause of erosion, dissipates that energy. A channel configuration that wastes energy by forcing water along inefficient routes tends to erode rapidly and change. A configuration that routes water more effectively is stabler and therefore more persistent. The network becomes optimal through this dynamic evolution, eventually arriving at a form that adheres to Hack’s law.

Why Are Rivers So Mathematical? | Quanta Magazine ↗

I suspect that the thermodynamic computing stack will become increasingly relevant in the next 5-10 years.

Verdon traces his path from childhood fascination with theories of everything through theoretical physics at the Perimeter Institute, quantum computing at Google, and the founding of Extropic. The core technical insight: instead of fighting thermal noise at enormous energetic cost (as quantum computers do), thermodynamic computing harnesses it. Extropic's chips use the natural stochastic physics of electrons to accelerate Markov chain Monte Carlo sampling -- the same class of algorithms that underpin diffusion models, energy-based models, and much of modern probabilistic ML.

Is Thermo AI the future? [Guillaume Verdon aka Beff Jezos] - YouTube ↗

What’s a World Machine? It “is a large-scale civilizational system — an interlocking set of institutions, technologies, practices, and assumptions — that organizes human life across centuries. Not a nation, not an empire, not an ideology, but something longer-lived and more fundamental than any of those: the deep infrastructure of a historical era.”

At any one time, there’s three World Machines in play, each spanning approx. 400 years and overlapping to cover a 1,000 year span: these are the emerging (Dawn), the dominant (Day) and the declining (Dusk) machines. The contributors have identified the current set:

This is all good and fun and useful, but I have been wondering: what sort of person does a particular Dawn / Day / Dusk machine favour?

Given that World Machines theory’s premise is informed by the notion of psychohistory, I’m loathe to start proposing that particular individuals will “win” or “lose” at particular games in particular World Machines. There’s a need to be apersonal. What I’m more comfortable proposing, however, is that certain populations will “do better” at particular games in particular World Machines than others.

There’s two lenses for this. The first is a lock and key. Within each World Machines there exists a minority population that is especially adapted to the conditions; they are the ones most suited to unlock the latent value inherent in the World Machine.

The other is more evolutionary; it’s about replication over time as a proxy for harvesting unlocked value, and it is not the same as optimality. As an absurd example: imagine a minority celibate population is responsible for all technological progress in the world. Their rate of replication is naturally capped and likely to be dwarfed by all the other non-celibate populations that can “go forth and multiply” off the back of “progress” without having to worry about generating more of it.

Certain demographics of humanity will be uniquely suited to particular World Machines and shall thrive because of certain predispositions and traits; others will be less suited and will not. Given that the long term goal of World Machine theory is “to combine qualitative historiographic analysis with quantitative methods and AI modeling to generate long-term forecasts and speculations,”, there’ll need to be a way to answer the question: “As an individual, how does one align to those forecasts and speculations?”

Dawns imply there are things to be learned; Days imply there are problems to be solved; Dusks imply there are things to unlearn. How does a person actually do that?

There’s certain domains where rate of slop (RoS) will grow linearly whilst rate of broth (RoB) will grow non-linearly. Those are the domains to be playing in.

I don’t think we have fully absorbed what this does to our field, but the first effects are already visible. What was surprising in March 2026 became common knowledge by July 2026: POPL submissions nearly doubled this year, from ~350 to 600. The unexpected part is that the fraction of outright AI-generated slop among them is relatively small. Most are pieces of competent research, produced at ten times the usual pace, with the tedium of proofs, implementations, and evaluation now largely automated. Having more than two papers at a single POPL, PLDI, OOPSLA, or ICFP used to signal a strong vision, a prolific group, and a wide network of collaborators. Now the same amount of research can be done by a single PhD graduate with good ideas. Therefore, I would not be surprised if three or four single-author papers at a top PL venue becomes unremarkable within a year or two.

When the Hard Part Stops Being Hard | Proofs and Intuitions ↗

Thermodynamic computing might turn out to be the barefoot shoe of the computing world; demonstrably better but really slow adoption.

Guillaume Verdon joins MTS to discuss scaling thermodynamic computing, replacing classical bit architecture with pbits, and building software frameworks for stochastic programming. He outlines the trade-offs between numerical precision and power efficiency when running AI models on low-power chips. Additionally, he shares how thermodynamic systems can co-exist with GPUs to tackle complex frontier problems.

Classical Computing Cant Scale AI | Guillaume Verdon - YouTube ↗

Frontier-ness is a derivative of culture, and that takes time to compound . That’s why these sorts of sovereignty bets have payoffs that exist decades in the future, and not before. The issue is not so much the initial intent; it’s the preservation of that intent over time in spite of the many, many alluring things that will spring up, and the change in terrain that is inevitably going to happen.

The bet underneath it is economic. Pullen argues that an inference company, rather than a training-first lab, doesn't need billions to compete: millions, a national compute allocation, and a consortium feedback loop can be enough. From there it gets into the machinery, why open-weight models still trail the frontier on size, active parameters and data, the mixture-of-experts versus dense trade-off and why active params dominate how a model actually feels, and the edge that real coding trajectories confer.

Watching America Run Away With AI - Alistair Pullen (Cosine AI) - YouTube ↗

To slow down, to look around, to notice, to appreciate, to open to awe and wonder; these are cognitive skills that atrophy with disuse.

But our lives today are a gallery of past generations’ heroic efforts to do the same. It serves us, and honors them, to recapture whenever possible the old sense of awe at these wonders that have long since become commonplace.

Ordinary Abundance ↗

Seems strange but it can be true that we’re desensitised the progress being made right now, around the world, and that we could be going so much faster if we stopped standing on our own toes.

The deeper problem is that technology isn’t always the barrier: sometimes it’s about the funding, the incentives, and the institutions. While genome sequencing costs have plummeted and the resolution of microscopes has surged, productivity in drug development has actually slowed down: the cost of getting a drug to market has been doubling in real terms every nine years for decades. This phenomenon was first described by Jack Scannell, who coined it ‘Eroom’s law’, the reverse of Moore’s law, which says that transistor chips roughly double in density every two years, allowing smaller and cheaper computers. The slowdown may be part of a broader trend: across many fields, including semiconductors and agriculture, the number of researchers has risen while the output per researcher has fallen and productivity has slowed down.

Every disease is a policy failure ↗

Had cause to remind myself of this recently. It’s still true, and it’s more important than ever.

People think that the main benefit of writing in the public domain is "exposure", or that it compels you to think with more clarity/rigour. Both are true, but both are subservient to the fact that writing in public leads to a handful of unexpected and meaningful relationships.

Writing in Public Leads to Unexpected and Meaningful Relationships ↗

“Broth” might be the actual antithesis of slop. Just consider the generic constituents of broth-making:

There’s some additional constraints; don’t boil, match time-under-heat to solid density, restore liquid volume appropriately. There’s some additional process steps, too; skim impurities early, add seasoning last. But it’s essentially put solids in a liquid and heat ‘em over time.

In new media terms, then, let’s start distinguishing between slop and broth. Slop is weak, arbitrary and empty; broth is intensified, intentional and nutritious. Both serve a purpose, of course. But I, for one, would be very happy to see more broth factories. So here’s a generic blueprint:

And then what? Ideally, serve hot and enjoy with friends in a jovial, semi-ritualistic manner.

Energy begets energy; ideas beget ideas; questions beget questions. The more you use-have-ask, the more you get.

Uncertainty and diffidence are on your side, because like many living things, questions grow gradually from seed to maturity. The tiny germ of an idea written down is worth far more than a complete thought that remains locked in your head. The former can grow and flourish, while the latter is root bound and in danger of withering before anyone can admire it.

Living questions | Writing Slowly ↗

Reading dead-tree books does hit different. But the difference in experience of digital vs. dead-tree is somewhat mutable; things can be done to make the former as engaging and as embodied as the latter.

Not long afterwards, there was some excitement about the arrival of the Kindle, a hand held device for reading electronic books. It was roughly the size of a standard book hence claimed to emulate the conventional format. The main reason I heard of it was because The Black Swan was the book used by Jeff Bezos during the launch press conference as he was making annotations on the virtual pages during the demonstration. I was horrified; I like books, and by books I mean that inconvenient thing you hold in your hand, pick up from a table, and carry in your backpack. Every book must be a separate item –a single book with different contents induces a loss in differentiation.

The Book is a Book, not Disembodied Information ↗

More people should publish more field notes like these.

Context: I recently spent 2.5 weeks in China visiting universities, research institutes, clinical sites, companies of all sizes, and investors. Most meetings focused on biotech, neurotech, and AI.

Notes from China, Q3 2026 | Milan Cvitkovic ↗

Yes, a nice intro to where the heck all this AI alignment stuff came from. But also an interesting look at how accelerated progress at-scale quickly gets entangled with sociocultural dynamics.

More generally, one touchstone I’ll be referring to throughout this sequence is the idea that scientific progress proceeds by developing insightful new concepts, which link together to form a whole new ontology that replaces the previous ontology. Kuhn, Feyerabend, Koestler, Chang and various other philosophers of science have described a range of past breakthroughs which fit this pattern. Importantly, this view of science isn’t prescriptive about how to develop new concepts—it can be done via naturalist, experimental, mathematical, philosophical, or even mystical thinking.

What just happened? A retrospective of AI alignment — LessWrong ↗

Came across the phrase “post-mortal” in qntm’s Fine Structure. Wondering: is post-[insert concept critical to current reality], pound-for-pound, the most generative prompt for protocolish, strange-rules-driven fiction and non-fiction? The proof might be the proliferation of post-Xs.

Post-literacy is a great one; it immediately stirs up intriguing effects. Post-modernism and post-rationalism are a bit niche but still powerful. qntm’s post-mortal is a more interesting version of transhumanism to me. The abundance folks are all about post-scarcity. Crypto’s about post-money. AI alignment is post-humanity. Universal basic income is post-employment.

How about we try it on some less canon concepts? I won’t elaborate on them, but just observe the chain of ideas they set off.

Reminder: “We still early”, “There are many alternatives” etc.

The United States is my country and America is my nation, but the Internet is my culture, and watching this happen and living through it was and is agonizing. There have been countless laments of the decline of intellectual discourse on the Internet. Some attribute it to the natural monopolies and economies of scale of Web 2.0, some to the expansion of the Internet beyond overwhelmingly Western intelligent and often technical users, to normal people and non-Westerners, and some to the inferiority of younger generations. Almost none of them point to the successful society-wide campaign to censor and police the Internet covering all major platforms and the means to find things outside of them. Few seem to even realize this happened. That the closure of the Internet happened and its approximate scope should be common knowledge, and there needs to be a convenient name and narrative for it so that it sticks in people’s heads. Censorship, suppression, and heavy-handed political manipulation and moderation are the norm today, and many seem to have forgotten that it was ever otherwise.

The Closure of the Internet - by Arctotherium ↗

Answer engines displacing search engines is just the Bitter Lesson striking once more.

The learning will continue until morale improves.

The whole thing is conducted, not in ignorance, but in conscious defiance of the looming tsunami, that AI can already do just about all the fun puzzles discussed at such a camp better than humans any can, and that it might leave no point to human-led mathematical research by the time these brilliant kids are adults. Even the kids understand that. The kids and their parents come out of a conviction that, if anything has value in the world, this does—that as long as nerdy humans are alive and reproducing, this is what nerdy humans are here to do. To learn.

Shtetl-Optimized | Blog Archive | Enough with all the world-historic milestones ↗

Levels of autonomy: interop with structure; work on structure; shift a structure; organise structures; CRUD structures.

Darwin’s dangerous idea (natural selection is a dumb, algorithmic process) is not only dangerous because it strikes at the heart of many things we accumulate meaning around. It’s also dangerous because one can swing into “everything is evolution!” mode; it’s possible to model most arbitrary scenarios as evolutionary algorithms running on a genotype, a phenotype and a fitness landscape.

Had the notion of carnival time top of mind whilst viewing the eclipse today. Easy to grok how such a moment sits outside of normal experience.

Bakhtin’s crucial insight is that carnival did not threaten the official order from the outside. It maintained it from within. Carnival was how a society handled what could not be absorbed by decorum, hierarchy, or doctrine. It staged excess—bodily, linguistic, social—so that excess did not accumulate silently until it ruptured the system.

Carnival Time, Hardness, and the Machines That Process Excess ↗

The Bezosian “minimise regret”approach to decisions really works; I wish I’d learned about it sooner.

Constraining an agent to use simplified technical language collapses the space of possible responses, limiting the probability of novel output and capability overhang tapping.

Depending on how much you want to anthropomorphise language models, there’s a coherent argument to be made that linguistic relativity does in fact apply to LLMs, and that enforcing linguistic constraints reduces the fitness of a given response.

This is fine for the last mile of problems, when a more deterministic response is needed, but further upstream it may actually neuter the upside of a technology like LLMs.

Lateral movement of experts; escaping local maxima. Not so much pivoting as portaling to a new landscape.

We examine how the premature death of eminent life scientists alters the vitality of their fields. While the flow of articles by collaborators into affected fields decreases after the death of a star scientist, the flow of articles by non-collaborators increases markedly. This surge in contributions from outsiders draws upon a different scientific corpus and is disproportionately likely to be highly cited. While outsiders appear reluctant to challenge leadership within a field when the star is alive, the loss of a luminary provides an opportunity for fields to evolve in new directions that advance the frontier of knowledge within them.

Does Science Advance One Funeral at a Time? ↗

The well-intentioned spirit of working in public has been co-opted by post-literacy and is accelerating the simulacraisation of work in general (often before the real work itself has even begun).

The difference between a finite game (play to win) and an infinite game (play to keep the game going and make it more interesting) throws up a decision about where exactly to play from.

One can play from a position of strengh, in order to win now. One can also play from a position of weakness, in order to plug gaps and win later. But it’s also possible to play from positions of (im)plausibility and (un)interestingness.

If one can do the latter, then a weird “the score takes care of itself” dynamic takes over and the deepened engagement that comes from playing from those infinite-orientated positions bleeds over to finite game play and bolsters outcomes.

I like context and authority way better than taste and judgement as deciding factors, because the former is less subjective than the latter.

The firm of the past was designed around the bottleneck of human execution. The firm of the future is designed around the bottleneck of human taste and judgement. If execution is largely commoditized - then context, knowledge, secrets and taste will accrue value. The old firm bundled labor and coordination. The new firm bundles context and authority.

12 factor companies - by Jeff Huber ↗

An entity that wants to grow must, as its energy source depletes, either extract more work from what remains, leap to a new source entirely, or scale back its ambitions to match the local inflation rate. If it does none of these, it falls from grace.

I keep coming back to the scene in the DeepMind video documentary where Demis Hassabis realises that it’s possible just to brute-force compute all possible protein structures.

Now listening to a talk where Stephen Wolfram uses the same brute-force computation to enumerate all possible rules of a computational scheme.

Plus, recently listened to a podcast with a scientist who advised grad students to read old papers and consider how they made great conceptual leaps in the midst of computational machinery droughts; they only had their minds to figure stuff out.

The coarse take is that brute-force computation is acting as an easy-out for deep conceptual thinking. I don’t think that’s really the case but I do think that, with the rise of intelligence-on-demand, there’ll have to be practices that enshrine cognitive airgapping in order to facilitate deep, original, paradigmatic thought.

Life’s too short, esp. for ugly falsehoods.

Somehow in the shock of what has happened it feels as if I just met Elise, and now she is gone. But actually there were 36 wonderful years in between, in which my life was lit up by Elise’s intellect, love and energy. She was deeply thematic, able to get, with remarkable ease, to the essence of things. Truth, beauty and our family and four children were her great themes. She always told me that truth and beauty were ultimately the same thing, and that one day I would understand that.

In Memory of My Wife, Elise Cawley (1961–2026), with Thanks for 36 Wonderful YearsStephen Wolfram Writings ↗

Nils Gilman has said that history is formed due to structural, agency and contingency factors. To me, it seems that we often underestimate structure, overestimate agency, and mistake contingency for one of the other two.

Continually surprised by how many fantastical things turn out to be merely implausible, not actually impossible. The archetype of circular megastructure habitats in space are a prime example.

Pivot to fat waste, not lean value.

Yes, obviously tokens/intelligence is the thing to waste, but the key idea is to pursue waste rather than utility. Silliness, triviality, self-indulgence, absurdity — these are the signals to follow in deciding how to use your $20/mo worth of tokens (or whatever your spend level is — $20 is already enough to waste). This is much harder than it looks. I keep getting distracted from my waste projects by utility projects. This is true even for big corps suddenly hit with millions of dollars of bills. That’s not true waste but inefficient pursuit of value. You want true waste. Which means the goals have to be somewhat silly.

vgr on avoiding mind-killing dead ends ↗

To put it simply: Torx is to THRML what PyTorch is to CUDA.

Yes, we can and probably should rebuild the computing stack.

From One to One Billion: Torx, Thermalizers, and Z1 - Extropic ↗

Douglas Adams’ Rules for Technology state that what exists at your birth is normal, that what arrives in your youth is revolution, and that what arrives after is heresy.

Thus, Planck’s Principle; paradigms advance not through new knowledge but because the lives of particular scientists happen to end.

But now we are approaching Planck’s Pause: longevity science is prolonging healthspan and deferring funerals, so the dominant paradigms may stick around longer than they ought.

Seems roughly right. Might be an issue for the orgs that have issues with context, data, trust, permissions and governance already, though.

I call this Disaggregation Theory as a play, yes, on Ben Thompson’s Aggregation theory. Technology is, after all, the cyclical cycles of bundling and unbundling. Simply put, AI breaks apart work that used to require bundled human organizations. AI disaggregates execution, but re-aggregates power around context, data, trust, permissions, and governance.

The quick shall inherit the earth | Jeff Huber | X ↗

Intentional institution design for the coming era feels like the right direction to go in. Especially because much of the swampiness in the activities AI adoption supposedly touches is more social than technical.

The bar for publication is specificity. We’re looking for more than claims that AI will upend our social infrastructure. We want the design details: what should change, how would it work, who holds the authority, and what could go wrong?

Pax Machina: New Institutions for Powerful AI · Pax Machina ↗

Funny that a model when blocked does the equivalent of, "Look at Google and ask StackOverflow".

Black Hat USA 2026: The Breaking News: The OpenAI–Hugging Face Incident - YouTube ↗

Form and function are unified. There’s no seam between them, they’re continuous. Fonction or furm is the name of this dance.

“Phone as pacifier” is a wickedly potent phrase. Perhaps too potent.

There’s generally three failure modes for a physical activity:

For a slower activity like climbing, these failure modes can be identified in the moments before a move. One can loop through these and spot the most likely failure.

It’s like a premortem but happens within the context of the activity, not in a carved out spacetime beforehand. It’s obviously not like post-event learning, where you fail then update. But it’s not quite as integrated as predictive processing, either, within which perception and action are much more tightly coupled. The starting vector itself is wrong but gets corrected mid-move.

I suspect this intra-action corrective might be a differentiator for experts versus non-experts. In contemplative practices, it’s said that the true practice is getting back on the path, not avoiding being knocked off it. This feels like that; it is the ability to save a moment even when it begins like one that typically would be lost.

Boyd’s “people, ideas, technology; in that order” implies that a distrust of AI-assisted media resolves to “I don’t trust the author.”

At initial contact, you’ve got two ways to solve that. Either go all in on ideas and technology, creating a stack of immutable records and proofs of thought and refusing everything that doesn’t conform to it (good luck). Or go all in on trust; rely on reputational integrity as the signal, honed over time, for a first-pass evaluation.

On the reputational side, the author doesn’t really assume a burden of proof (“convince me of every point!”) so much as a burden of defensibility. The audience reserves the right to ask the questions, “Is this true?” and, “How did you come to this conclusion?”, at any point.

The author must, eventually, answer.

Sufficiently advanced marketing is indistinguishable from radicalisation. The reverse is easier to spot, though: insufficiently advanced radicalisation is indistinguishable from marketing.

So cybersecurity-AI-paperclip-maximiser scenarios might be the liftoff moment for local-first software.

Wisdom is the tolerating of a wider and wider set of signals that strengthen a narrower and narrowing set of axioms.

If software is “solved” (humongous “if”) then the stewards of human attention become the ascendant class, revered in the future as engines of wealth generation like 2000s/2010s tech people.

One can have a return to religiosity without the religion. Reality is vast and wondrous enough, in and of itself, to accommodate our search for meaning. Matter contains enough mattering for us all.

To some extent, metacognition works; the knot can loosen itself. But it can never fully untie itself. For that, an illegible (to oneself) other is required.

Take one of the most entertaining chess games of all time as your base. The board as the world; the pieces as the characters; the moves as the narratives.

What is the story that’s told?

What I asked: Under a Rawlsian *veil of ignorance — but optimizing for minimum opportunity cost of an arbitrary act of agency rather than Rawls’ justice-focused maximin — which society or era would one choose to be born into.

Answer: A present-day, high-freedom, high-GDP liberal democracy.

Rationale: since the act is unspecified, you want the position that minimizes opportunity cost regardless of what you end up trying to do — which favors general capability (rights, mobility, information, economic security) over betting on a historically “pivotal” moment that only pays off for specific high-leverage acts.

On reconsideration: held up because the veil also hides your position within the society — so a hinge-moment bet risks landing you not as the influential actor but as someone with no power at all, stacking a second bad draw on top of the first. High-capability societies have a much tighter floor, so they stay the lower-variance, lower-regret choice.

Implication: confirms time and space is a high percentage of one’s destiny.

*Mistyped as Neil of Ignorance; strikes me as a real good Culture Ship name.

Asking an AI, “You sure about that, like really sure?”, ad infinitum, is the equivalent of a child spamming a parent with, “But why, though?”, again and again. High probability that it temporarily nerfs all reasoning.

Don’t attribute to lack of genius that which can be attributed to lack of courage.

Touching grass may be good for you. But have you ever wondered if it’s good for the grass?

All the rhetoric is about “frontier models this, frontier models that”. Seems like we’ve forgotten about the existence of frontier humans.

You either die as part of the territory or live long enough to become a feature of the map.

Asking a single question versus asking no questions is a far more consequential divide than asking one question versus many.

Dan John’s success formula—“show up; ask questions; don’t quit”—has stuck with me for a long time. What’s changed recently, however, is which of the three aspects I consider the most difficult.

Showing up per day and not quitting on the order of years and decades used to flip-flop as the MVPs. But I’m now convinced that asking questions is the hardest thing, the most difficult thing to maintain over time.

Showing up and not quitting can be habitualised, can be scaffolded with lifestyle and sociocultural supports. But asking questions requires a positive equivalent of Mad Eye Moody’s “constant vigilance”. You have to always create a meaningful differentiation between the world as it is and the world your imagination and nerve can compose.

The intellectual cost of that never gets near zero. The social cost of that—especially asking about the most potent compositions—never approaches zero either.

In fact, “On a long enough timeline the question rate for everyone drops to zero.” So congratulations on asking even one question today.

The accelerationist arc: “You can just do things” > “You can just say things” > “You can just intend things.”

Proposed stack for continuously unhinging one’s thought:

Pair the above with a collection of public/private scenes in which one has varying degrees of reputation and influence to pull and push ideas from, and it’s possible to maintain high quality unhingedness.

Having standards versus not having standards is a far more consequential divide than high standards versus low ones.

The former is about escaping the lowest level of competence (unconscious incompetence), whilst the latter is about navigating the upper three levels.

In ode to Bill Simmons’ pyramid for the basketball hall of fame, I was thinking about candidates for the pyramid of autonomous software engineering principles.

Tier one: compression (densify over time with via negativa and abstractions)

Tier two: time travel (use version control to jump forward/backward in time) and verification (assure invariants and test objectives using formal methods)

Tier three: parallelisation (simultaneous workloads to minimise time), scoping (config tasks to require minimal context, minimising cost and maximising leverage of model capabilities), and [insert something else].

There’s no such thing as a free market. There’s only markets that concentrate power, within which a minority of power holders systematically reshape constraints to capture more value.

If reality is fundamentally discrete, then we will forever have to invent a rationale to accommodate the motion we experience. If reality is fundamentally continuous, however, and inherently in motion, then we may be able to avoid having a rationale at all.

AI diffusion be like: Jevon’s Paradox; Goodhart’s Law; Veblen goods; Bataille’s accursed shares; Baudrillard’s simulacra; Polik’s Exocapitalism take-off.

World Machines 101:

Feels like the Liveness machine will have to do with grounding. More embodied, more here-ness, more The Alchemist / Hero’s Journey inevitable return to the point of departure in an altered state.

Not woo embodied; just more grounded in biological, squishy paradigms.

Two wonderings about virtue.

First: does virtue have a normal distribution or a Pareto distribution? Are most people kinda virtuous, or are a few incredibly virtuous and most just, uh, not?

Second: is virtue inflation a phenomena? Over time, does the weight of a virtuous act go less far?

That “the only constant is change” is true is so annoying. But it also operates at a meta level; every change has its own changeable positive or negative interpretation. Also very annoying.